Tucson Citizen.com
Better Business Bureau Consumer Alert -

BBB Sees Increase in Service Demand in 2009, Drop in Complaints

by on Jan. 14, 2010, under Life, phishing, scam, Tips

According to year-end statistics, Better Business Bureau of Southern Arizona provided almost 330,000 instances of service to local consumers in 2009, up 20 percent from 2008.

The increase in service was driven in part by a 154 percent increase in consumer requests for industry specific lists – or rosters – of BBB Accredited Businesses. Consumers usually request the business “rosters” when deciding on a company to do business with.

Complaints filed with BBB were down 15 percent compared with 2008, despite the overall upsurge in instances of service.

“While we have no real way of determining why we saw a decrease in complaints, we like to think it’s because consumers were doing their pre-purchase research, which is reflected in the number of rosters we provided,” says Kim States, BBB president. “This coupled with a decrease in big-ticket spending are likely causes.”

Of the 2,100 complaints filed with BBB in 2009, 63 percent were addressed by the business and closed as resolved as compared to 73 percent in 2008. That entire drop can be attributed to one company- Nature’s Best Acai Berry- a mail-order diet pill company that accumulated almost 300 unanswered complaints. Nature’s Best has since been the subject of government action and is no longer in business.

Among other top complaint-receiving industries of 2009 was Government Job Listing Services, which accounted for 44 total complaints in the second half of the year, all from one Tucson company- Government Careers Inc (GCI). Nine additional complaints against the company are currently pending.

Complainants told BBB they were unaware they were signing up for GCI’s services when they responded to what they thought were job postings for government positions with the U.S. Postal Service, Border Patrol, and National Park Service at CareerBuilder.com and other job listing sites. Those complainants who did knowingly sign up for the service, which cost from $100 and $900, said they never received the assistance promised and were, in some cases, unable to get a refund of their money.

Finally, in a clear sign of the tough economic climate facing southern Arizona in 2009, consumer inquires into Career and Outplacement Councilors – companies that provide job search and placement services to consumers- jumped 130 percent from 2008. The number of consumer inquiries into credit and debt counseling services saw a 45 percent increase, with consumers logging more than 1,700 inquiries in 2009.

The following is BBB’s Activity Report for 2009.

2009 Total Inquiries & Complaints/Southern Arizona

Ten Most Complained About Industries

Description Complaints Settlement %
Health & Medical Products – Scientifically Unproven

303

6.6

Auto Dealers-New Cars

88

94.32

Auto Repair & Service

77

71.43

Computers Software & Services

72

90.28

Auto Dealers-Used Cars

70

84.29

Air Conditioning Contractors & Systems

54

79.63

Television  –  Cable, CATV & Satellite

51

100

Furniture-Retail

39

82.05

Government Job Listing Services

38

81.58

Cellular Telephone Service & Supplies

36

97.22

Ten Most Inquired About Industries

Description Inquiries
Air Conditioning Contractors & Systems

16740

Roofing Contractors

9950

Plumbing Contractors

7409

Auto Repair & Service

6985

Auto Dealers-New Cars

6029

Contractors-General

5509

Movers

5051

Pest Control Services

4953

Auto Dealers-Used Cars

4912

Painting Contractors

4382

2009 Total Inquiries & Complaints/Cochise County

Ten Most Complained About Industries

Description Complaints Settlement %
Auto Dealers-New Cars

9

100

Auto Repair & Service

6

33.33

Appliances-Small-Service & Repair

4

0

Air Conditioning Contractors & Systems

3

33.33

Data Communications Equipment & Systems

3

100

Furniture-Retail

3

66.67

Construction & Remodeling Services

3

66.67

Loans – Auto Title

2

100

Foods-Carry Out

2

0

Fulfillment Services

2

100

Ten Most Inquired About Industries

Description Inquiries
Auto Dealers-New Cars

649

Roofing Contractors

474

Air Conditioning Contractors & Systems

397

Home Builders

376

Contractors-General

356

Real Estate Developers

340

Contractors – Electrical

276

Auto Repair & Service

252

Real Estate

252

Painting Contractors

221