Tucson Citizen.com
Cell-Out Arizona - Prisons, Privatization, and Politics

Governor’s Commission on Privatization Recommends…Privatization.

by on Dec. 08, 2010, under American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), Arizona, Arizona State Legislature, Corrections Corporation of America, Lobbyists, private prison, Privatization, SB 1070, Uncategorized

Governor Jan Brewer’s Commission on Privatization and Efficiency (COPE) announced it will be releasing a report recommending increased use of private prisons in Arizona as a way to address the budget crisis.

That’s right, a group of people handpicked by the Governor, whose top advisors are lobbyists for the for-profit prison industry, just recommended that we give more of our tax money to private prison companies.

And who are the “experts” the Governor has chosen for the task?

The Chair of the Commission is Mark Brnovich.  Mr. Brnovich served as a Senior Director of State and Customer Relations for Corrections Corporation of America from 2005-2006 and was a lobbyist for them in 2007.

Also on the Commission are Robert Burns, outgoing President of the Senate, and Kirk Adams, Speaker of the House.  Between 2008 and 2010, Adams received multiple campaign contributions from individuals associated with the GEO Group, and one donation from a person associated with CCA.

Burns is the Arizona Public Sector Chair of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), and oversees ALEC’s Scholarship Fund, which “reimburses” legislators for the travel expenses incurred in attending ALEC’s events.  At these events, the legislators are wined and dined by corporate lobbyists and are given a sales pitch on ALEC’s “model legislation,” such as SB1070.

Many of these same corporations make huge donations to the Scholarship Fund.  This is how ALEC is able to disburse on average over a million dollars in travel, lodging and other expenses annually to state lawmakers, while simultaneously reporting zero expenditures for “payments of travel or entertainment expenses for any federal, state, or local public officials.”  The donors to the Scholarship Fund are likewise able to remain anonymous and do not have to report this money as gifts to elected officials.  Is it just me, or does this smell a lot like money laundering?

For more background on ALEC, see Beau Hodai’s piece for In These Times and the two-part series from NPR’s Laura Sullivan on ALEC’s ties to CCA and its influence on Arizona legislation.

Yet another member of the Commission is Glenn Hamer, President and CEO of the Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Industry.  Corrections Corporation of America is listed as a corporate member of the Arizona Chamber at the “Board Level.”  According to the Chamber’s website, “Corporate membership provides varying levels of packaged benefits for membership within the Arizona Chamber.”  The Board Level requires dues and other fees upwards of $10,000.  This payoff entitles the corporation “higher levels of participation” and access to Chamber events.

It should be no surprise to anyone that this commission’s recommendations are to privatize everything.  Its members are clearly beholden to these industries and have personally profited from them.

What is shocking is that anyone in the state of Arizona would take their recommendations seriously or view them as anything but a thinly veiled attempt to further enrich themselves and their corporate sponsors.  The people of this state should be outraged that Brewer, Adams, Burns and their ilk would have the audacity to throw away millions more of our scarce tax dollars on an industry that has failed so spectacularly.



  • http://www.facebook.com/pages/Three-Sonorans/144198198931412 Three Sonorans

    Thank you for this update… Sharing this super important news.
     
    More prisons when our state is broke and schools are closing?

    • songlady

      And, the Republicans just voted down a one time check for 250.00 for social security people next year. That would have meant so much to so many peole with low social security income.  My husband will never live long enough to be awarded as much as he paid into soc sec.  That 250 and mine would have bought a set of economy dentures.  How can they say they can’t afford this but still use thousands  of times that much for so many things that don’t really help peoples living?  Shame on you, Republicans!  

  • Dick

    Could we possibly get he to privatize her pet boondoggle (5C Arizona Centennial Museum) before she pours more of our tax dollars into down that rat hole?

    • fraser007

      Good call. Just another of Brewers boondoggles. She is doing the same to Arizona State Parks, handing all away (except the ones that bring in a bunch of money like Kartchner Caves),
      Watch her dump a bunch of money into that creepy Centennial Museum in Phoenix. Just think a wonderful engaging exhibit on cattle and oranges. I cant wait…….

  • leftfield

    Somebody with Photoshop software spent a fair bit of time on that photo of the Guv.

  • Sue I

    Horrible plan….if anyone has had experience with a loved one being placed in one of these private prisons, you would understand they would be better off going to a dog kennel…they would get better food, more respect and the possibility of rehabilitation.

    They pay guards almost nothing, they don’t have to have a diploma and because they do not feel respect in their private lives, they make the inmates “pay” by subjecting them to a sneering attitude. They feel power by being able to control their every movement. They are not even allowed to ask a question without being addressed first. They enjoy taunting them, like a bullied child would in school, if given the chance.

    Now I know many would feel – Person committed a crime, they deserve whatever they get. Until this happens to your family you might feel that way but we are talking about many young people who are first-time offenders, white collar, non-violent crime…they aren’t all hardened criminals or illegal border-crossers (even that second type doesn’t mean they are “bad” people).

    The goal of our justice system is to teach a lesson, make the criminal pay restitution and rehabilitate them to enter society and give back to the community by becoming a model citizen. Apparently, the private prisons haven’t been clued in to that information. Their goal seems to be to make the inmates HATE the justice system and any law enforcement, punish in every way possible, make them miserable, make money by cutting costs wherever possible and housing all the mentally ill with no drugs or therapy in there, too. Lock ‘em up and throw away the key and someday they will get out…and what will they have learned? Hatred, and new ways to commit crimes.

  • songlady

    You are so right, leftfield.  Everyone wants to look good in a portrait but hers is way too far from what she actually looks like.  It’s really phony amd the fact that she uses it says something  about her character, doesn’t it?  Why does she need to wear a mask?    

  • Jacqueline O’Connor

    No privatization!  Why would anyone think you could farm out a task and expect that task to be done as well for less money?  No, we will see abuse of prisoners and no one knows what goes on inside with non-professionals in charge of a captive “audience” until the deaths of prisoners  (oh, yes, that’s already occurred) or escapes (oops.  That’s happened too) occur.  Dump this dumb idea and tell this “private” company to go do something we don’t care about–make a profit in the private sector and pay taxes on your profits!

  • Jacqueline O’Connor

    Random thought.  Have you ever seen an uglier governor than Jan Brewer.  She looks like a drunk (skin tone, wrinkles and awwwwful hair).  Doesn’t anyone love this woman and willing to tell her to look in the mirror?  Aside from her physical limitations, what has she ever done but pander for contributions and who better to prepare her retirement “fund” than the barbarians who want to run our prisons?  NO to Brewer and the private sectors urge to make money off the backs of prisoners.  To cut costs why in the hell are we putting so many in jail for drug charges and other crimes requiring mandatory sentences.  Who passed these mandatory sentencing laws?  Why, the very same folks who want to make money off the prisons by keeping them full-up!  And the legislators who depend on these sleaze bags to run for office and get their pay offs on the side.  Reform the prison system now and stop this myth that the “private” sector does things better.  All the “private” sector does is hide it’s payoffs and crimes while avoiding taxes.  Corporations only pay 5% of the tab for running this state.  Tooooo little.  Bang ‘em good and see them whine.