Tucson Citizen.com
Cell-Out Arizona - Prisons, Privatization, and Politics

Hawaiian Prisoners Beaten, Threatened in CCA Prison in Arizona

by on Dec. 16, 2010, under Arizona, Arizona State Legislature, Corrections Corporation of America, private prison, Privatization

A lawsuit brought on behalf of 18 Hawaiian prisoners held in Corrections Corporation of America’s Saguaro Correctional Center in Eloy charges that guards stripped, beat, and kicked the prisoners and threatened to kill them in retaliation for a prison disturbance over the summer that injured a CCA employee.

The guards beat the prisoners in order to coerce statements from them.  The guards beat their heads against tables while they were stripped to their underwear with their hands cuffed behind their backs.  CCA staff, including the Warden of the facility, threatened the prisoners and their families.  The Warden reportedly told them he would add time to their sentences if they did not cooperate. 

The suit also alleges that the CCA administrators and guards destroyed evidence of the beatings, including videotapes, and deliberately falsified reports to cover the incident up.  The prisoners were also denied prompt medical treatment for their injuries in an effort to conceal evidence of the abuse.

An article in the Honolulu Courthouse News provides the shocking details:

“Plaintiffs were threatened with harm to themselves and their families, including through such statements as:

     “a. ‘We have your emergency contact information;’

     “b. ‘We know who your family is and where they live and we are going to harm them;’

     “c. ‘We are going to kill you;’

     “d. ‘We will continue to beat you and the only way to stop that is to commit suicide;’

     “e. ‘We will send you to hell;’

     “f. ‘We will stick something up your ass.’

The Governor of Hawaii, Neil Abercrombie, has pledged to do everything in his power to bring all Hawaiian prisoners back to the islands and out of CCA and other private prisons on the mainland. 

Meanwhile, here in Arizona, state legislative leaders are pledging to do everything they can to put more of our prisoners in these facilities.  Representative Nancy McLain, who represents Mohave County, where the Kingman prison is located, said she’s all for allowing for-profit corporations to run our prisons:  “I’m still in favor of private prisons, and the escape at the Kingman prison doesn’t change that,” she said.



  • Carolyn Classen

    Thanks for covering this issue, I had heard that Hawaii’s new Governor has pledged to bring these prisoners back home to Hawaii.  It is very difficult to be separated from their families by such a distance, across the Pacific Ocean.

  • Pancho

    Brutality has long been commonplace at CCA prisons.  Estelle Richardson, for instance, appeared to have been murdered by CCA guards, but prosecutors dropped charges against four and did not proceed against another because it couldn’t be proven which guard delivered the fatal beating.
    “Guards’ riots” were reported at CCA’s CADC prison in Florence in 1998 and 2000. Prisoners were dragged from their cells to be gratuitously beaten.
    After a CCA guard killed his wife in Appleton, MN, he attempted to transfer to California City, but couldn’t pass the federal background check. He then went back to work for CCA at Florence, until the victim’s family located him and he was brought back to Minnesota and convicted of the murder.
    Shannon Clover, a CCA Eloy warden was convicted for charges arising out of the death of another motorist while he was drunk driving. He went to work for GEO Group as a Major, then was hired by CCA to work in Eloy.
    The CCA La Palma prison in Eloy was said to have experienced almost daily violence after California prisoners were imported.
    Representative McClain is well aware of the benefits of supporting the for-profit prisons which corporations provided a substantial boost in money and time to Jan Brewer’s election as well as other Arizona Republican legislators. She’s collected contributions from lobbyists for every for-profit prison corporation in Arizona. It’s nothing like what Russ Pearce receives, of course. He practically has a conveyor belt from the for-profits to his campaign treasurer.
     
     
     

  • Concerned Citizen

    The warden of Saguaro, Todd Thomas, has no business running a prison in my opinion. I have worked at Saguaro and I have personally heard the warden make threatening comments to staff and then lie about the statements later. I have also heard him threaten to keep the facility on “lock down” for six months after the first murder that happened there. It would not surprise me at all if those alleged incidents did happen. CCA it seems is only concerned about making money and covering up wrongdoings.

  • Hawaii Veteran

    I feel for my “brothers” at CCA prison!  No wonder the local folks back in the islands don’t trust some haoles and popolos because they like to do these kinds of violence in the mainland prisons.  Time to bring them back home!!

  • Doug Ohlemann

    And would an inmate lie? Hellooooooooooo.

    • leftfield

      How about a corrections officer? A CEO? A Senator?  Your government? Hellooooooo. 

  • Justin Fournier

    Free  Taryn Christian !!!! INNOCENT !!!!!

  • http://yahoo Jones

    Shannon Clover needs to be put behind bars. He is cheating on his wife and still beating inmates up. He also still threatens staff and inmates.