Tucson Citizen.com
Carolyn's Community - Our sense of group togetherness and "community" in Tucson

Visit the Gordon Hirabayashi Recreation Site (former WWII prison camp)

by on Sep. 06, 2010, under Life, Politics

Visit the stone remnants of a WWII prison camp named after Gordon Hirabayashi,the Japanese American from Seattle who served his violation of curfew conviction there, from 1943 to 1945. It can be reached by driving up the Catalina Highway in Tucson heading to Mt. Lemmon, and just beyond the 7 mile marker, turn left to the Gordon Hirabayashi Recreation Site in the Coronado National Forest.

Gordon Hirabayashi as a college student

Here’s a photo of Gordon as a young man in 1942,as a Senior at the University of Washington when he challenged the relocation order of E.O. 9066 & violated the curfew in Seattle. He was turned himself into the F.B.I., was convicted, and appealed all the way to U.S. Supreme Court on constitutional grounds, but his conviction was upheld at that time. (see Hirabayashi vs. U.S. 320 U.S. 81 (1943). Because the Federal Attorney did not want to pay his way to the Federal Prison Camp in the Santa Catalina Mountains in Arizona, Hirabayashi hitchhiked from Seattle, saw his family in an internment camp in Idaho, and arrived in Tucson where he had to convince the Federal Marshall to imprison him.

In 1987 his case was re-opened and and overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court. The National Commission on Wartime Relocation and Internment of Civilians (which I as a legislative aide helped U.S. Senator Inouye create) investigated the mass WWII Japanese American internment and determined that it had been caused by “racial prejudice, wartime hysteria & failed political leadership”. President Ronald Reagan signed the Civil Liberties Act in 1988, apologizing for the relocation/internment of 120,000 Japanese Americans, 2/3 of whom were U.S. Citizens, on American soil.

Federal prison camp map

Above is a photo of the map of the Catalina Federal Prison Camp. The prisoners laborers built 24 miles of road (the Catalina Hwy) through Coronado National Forest, completed in 1951. The prisoners housed there were convicted of breaking federal immigration or tax laws, most were conscientious objectors, such as Jehovah’s Witnesses, Hopi Indians and Japanese Americans (about 40) protesting their relocation & draft. Many resisted the draft because their families were at the same time in the 10 large W.R.A. internment camps. (These resisters were later pardoned by President Harry Truman in 1947).

In 1999 the Coronado National Forest named the recreation site after its most famous inmate Gordon Hirabayashi (who later earned a Ph.D in Sociology). Interpretive signs (see photo below) were installed in 2001. See National Forest’s website (click here) for more photos of Dr. Hirabayashi and the prison camp itself, which existed from 1937 to 1973.

Mary Farrell, a Forest Heritage Program Leader & Tribal Liaison for the Coronado National Forest has given lectures at Agua Caliente Park and elsewhere, about this prison camp. Her email is: mfarrell@fs.fed.us, phone 520-388-8391.

During a recent visit my husband and I walked along the paths and riverbed of the former prison camp, trying to imagine the life of the federal prisoners in that remote, but picturesque area. There are numerous concrete slab building platforms and walls still remaining, and stone abutments along the riverbed. It is a somber remembrance of the injustice done to my people (including my father), fitting on Labor Day 2010 (today).

The present site is suitable for picnicking, hiking, camping, mountain biking, bird watching…and reflecting.

tourists reading the interpretive kiost signs at Gordon Hirabayashi Recreation Site

More in Tucson Life and Heritage:

"A Hero's Salute" for Memorial Day

  • fraser007

    Great article. A topic we should all know about.

  • Carolyn Classen

    Thanks fraser007.  I didn’t know much about that prison camp, though I had of course heard of Dr. Hirabayashi’s constitutional challenge up to the U.S. Supreme Court.   And I want to hear Mary Farrell’s talk someday as I’ve missed it a few times now.  She and her husband are doing archaeological work on the Honouliuli Camp outside of Honolulu, that housed Japanese Americans, and prisoners of war.

  • leftfield

    …Japanese Americans (about 40) protesting their relocation & draft.

    Now there is some real bravery.  To sacrifice their freedom and their property; to be isolated from their families and communities in protest of wrong knowing that there would be almost no support at that time in history; that takes a lot of courage and determination.

  • Carolyn Classen

    Yes, many Japanese American men later enlisted or were drafted right out of those internment camps. Yet others resisted, questioning their draft notice when their families were behind barbed wire on American soil.  My Japanese American uncle and cousin were not interned, being in Hawaii, but they both enlisted and served bravely in the 442nd Regimental Combat Team. (My cousin was wounded in Germany  & became disabled).

  • erniemccray

    Great story, Carolyn. I love accounts of human beings standing strong with dignity for their beliefs.

    • Carolyn Classen

      Thanks Ernie.  Yes, “courage of conviction” is something we should all have, as these men did back in WWII.  Try to visit this recreation site whenever you’re back here in Tucson.

      • erniemccray

        I will definitely visit.

  • http://www.facebook.com/pages/Three-Sonorans/144198198931412 Three Sonorans

    There were about a dozen or so branch camps throughout Southern AZ, including in places like Sahuarita and Marana. In Marana they were forced to pick cotton.

    • Carolyn Classen

      Thanks David, I don’t know much about other WWII federal prison camps, not having grown up here in Arizona.

      • fraser007

        You have a couple of books on that now!!

        • Carolyn Classen

          Yes, thanks very much for “City in the Sun” about the Poston relocation center here in Arizona, and “Democracy on Trial” about the mass evacuation & relocation elsewhere.  In reading the Poston camp experience I learned about the extreme weather conditions they endured, without air conditioning or heaters.  And about the traitors within the camp, the “inu” (dogs) who betrayed the internees themselves.  But those were  internment camps, and this one named after Dr. Hirabayashi was a federal prison camp.
           

  • Carolyn Classen

    UPDATE: Dr. Hirabayashi died on Monday 1/2/12,  at age 93.  Read article in AZ Daily Star:
    http://azstarnet.com/news/national/gordon-hirabayashi-dies-fought-japanese-internments/article_4e54036c-31ce-50a9-908d-06f1439ecccc.html