Tucson Citizen.com
Carolyn's Community - Our sense of group togetherness and "community" in Tucson

Remembering January 8, 2011

by on Jan. 08, 2013, under Health, Life, Politics

Yes, it’s been two years since that fateful day when Jared Lee Loughner chose to go to that Safeway at the SE corner of Oracle/Ina, and attempted to assassinate CD 8 Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords. He ended up shooting 19 people, 6 fatally. And he wounded and injured a then-39 year old Congresswoman, who had to resign the job that she loved after a year of recovery. She now walks with a limp, uses an arm brace on her right arm, has become left handed, and is partially blind in her right eye.

Clearly, Jared Loughner was mentally ill, and pled guilty to these crimes. He is being treated in a mental hospital where he will serve the remainder of his days, as his life sentences have no possibility of parole.

What have we as a community learned from this horrendous mass shooting, right here in our midst? Almost all of us knew someone in that shooting. I was personally acquainted with Gabby, having worked on her campaigns. I knew her Outreach Director Gabe Zimmerman, who was struck down on that sidewalk. I knew aide Pam Simon, who was also shot but recovered. I know now Ron Barber who was shot twice that day, and who as her District Director stepped up to the plate and ran for Congress in CD 8 and CD 2 upon Gabby’s endorsement and request. My professor husband knew Gabby as well, and had taught Suzi Hileman who was shot and injured that day. She was the neighbor who had taken nine-year old Christina Taylor-Green to that Congress on your Corner event, and Christina died that day.

Clearly Loughner was ill, but why didn’t people notice enough? Pima Community College had expelled him due to mental problems but he didn’t get counseling help which he clearly needed. He was living with his parents, Randy and Amy Loughner, but they couldn’t or didn’t get help for him as he was over 18 years old. And where did he (an unemployed 22 year old) get the hundreds of dollars to pay for the Glock 9 gun and the two magazine clips he was captured with? I had worked as a board member for 3 years with Amy who manages Agua Caliente Park out east in Pima County. And I have also worked for a year with Gabe’s mother Emily Nottingham on the Casitas on Broadway board. Two mothers, two shattered lives.

Yes, we as a community have grieved over the past 2 years — a huge outpouring of sympathy and support at all the memorials — at Gabby’s former Swan/Pima office, at that Safeway on Oracle (where a permanent stone memorial was erected by the store), and at University Medical Center where most of the injured were taken to. Generous donations were made for the victims to help them recover, and to various foundations to help children & students in the names of the deceased.

Cactus garden by Wright Elem. School students at memorial outside of Congresswoman Giffords’ former district office at Pima/Swan, taken by Carolyn Classen

Now there are Beyond Tucson annual events to commemorate, heal, and move beyond the pain & horror of that day. Now people ring bells at 10:10 a.m.on January 8th when the shooting occurred, and now the politicians talk about gun control especially for firearms with a capacity to be used for mass killing. Also now there are multi-faith services in Tucson bringing together people of Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh, Baha’i faiths.

Since then there have been attempts at more civility in public discourse, and two foundations created expressly for that purpose. We all remember January 8, 2011 and hopefully we will remember to watch out for danger signals in isolated, depressed young men, to lobby for better mental health services, and more effective gun control to prevent criminals and mentally sick from obtaining firearms.

Hopefully we have become better people after this mass shooting of January 8, 2011. And if you have any creative ideas about what type of permanent memorial should be erected, click here for my previous post about the January 8th Memorial Foundation.



  • tiponeill

    I remember how truly crappy our local NPR affiliate is. They broke in with a brief announcement that Gabby Giffords had been shot and was dead, and then returned to some crap like Wait Wait Don’t Tell Me.

    I switched on the TV and was quite impressed with the local television coverage of the tragedy.

    • Carolyn_Classen

      Yes, I heard that Gabby had died as well, then the news retracted and started to slow down the hysteria. I heard Ross Zimmerman speak today at the Pima County Bd. of Supervisors how he and Gabe’s fiancee Kelly looked for him at UMC and then, with horror, realized why they couldn’t find him there, as he had died at the Safeway.

      • Karyn_Zoldan

        Thanks for that excellent article about remembrance. It was shocking that NPR announced her dead and then retracted. I have to agree with Tip that our local media did an exemplary job of covering the story. Nobody ever thinks that a mass shooting will ever happen in their backyard until it does. I wonder how many Jared Loughners there are out there walking around, semi functioning in society? Scary thought.

        • Carolyn_Classen

          There are probably quite a few. When our son was 15 he had a male classmate who was just like that: becoming isolated, depressed, threatening to kill another student in class, was from a mililtary family with guns. I called the HS counselor & reported him, and family intervention jumped in & helped the boy & his family. I wonder how many lives I probably saved back then? That boy also drew depressing pictures of a dead dog and people, which was another very dangerous sign. I had had suicide training in Boston so I knew the symptoms, but obviouslty others don’t know when to act.

  • Carolyn_Classen

    Pima County Bd. of Supervisors passed a proclamation today “January 8th Remembrance Day”, and presented it to Ross Zimmerman, father of deceased aide Gabe. The Supervisors spoke of how much they liked Gabe’s work, and how they choose to remember that day now. Chair Valadez said that that day “changed our community and we became one community.” Read the proclamation here:http://www.pima.gov/cob/e-agenda/01082013/RA7A_ProcJan8RemembranceDay.pdf

  • Ernie_McCray

    I was leaving a friend’s house in Oceanside, on my way home in San Diego when I heard the news that Gabby was dead. I think that was retracted by the time I got home. I could barely breathe, realizing that this kind of tragedy had marred a beautiful day in my hometown. Hearing of Christina’s death, particularly, bothered me. She was so full of promise, so bright. I think of her often.

    • Carolyn_Classen

      yes, Christina’s untimely death at age 9 really affected a lot of us in Tucson and elsewhere. Here’s the link to the memorial foundation created after her death:http://www.christina-taylorgreen.org/

  • Carolyn_Classen

    My husband and I just stopped by that NW Safeway to see the stone memorial. Many people have left cut flowers, some potted plants, four softballs for Christina, bells, other mementos in memory of the victims, and a beautiful balloon.

  • Dr John

    Carolyn,

    Thank you for this very moving article and your remembrances from this horrific shooting that took place two years ago today. I really do believe that in the wake of the recent massacre of 20 innocent children in Newtown, Conn that the tide is changing and that the overwhelming majority of our nation’s citizens are demanding truly responsible and effective gun control measures, combined with drastically improved mental health counseling and intervention services in our public schools. After last night’s town hall forum at the Loft, and Gabby and Mark’s announcement of their launch of “Americans for Responsible Solutions”, I am confident that our Tucson community will continue to play a vanguard role in these efforts. Also, I enjoyed talking with you and your husband after last night’s town hall forum!

    • Carolyn_Classen

      I sincerely hope the tide is turning on gun violence in our country, esp. after Newtown, CT. Good to meet you again as well at the Loft, and welcome to Tucsoncitizen.com. I’ve been here almost from the beginning since June 2009.

  • sdgman

    It’s a terrible thing to have happen and I feel for the families. Time to move on.