Tucson Citizen.com
The Data Port - Politics, Literature, And The Little Disturbances of Man

A Vision for Tucson: Rio Nuevo With a Soul

by on Dec. 01, 2011, under Arts and Entertainment, Politics, Rio Nuevo, The American Life, Tucson History, Tucson Museums

I’m not keen on the word ‘vision.’ It’s a word  frequently used by  politicians who don’t have one. I’m embarrassed to be using it here, but I can’t think of a better one. The word ‘plan’ is a good workmanlike alternative, but perhaps too workmanlike. It suggests a specific project in hand, an end agreed upon for which we need only specify the means; something like building a bookcase or providing for the orderly repair of  a system of streets.

If  I say I have a plan for my house, you understand one thing; if I say I have a vision of what my house will be you understand something different. My vision is more than a scheme for the mechanical arrangement of rooms and utilities, it suggests how it might fit with the world around it, and the sort of life I will live within it.

City planning that is not also informed by some less mechanical, some wider-reaching vision of what the city is, or is to become, plans for a body without a soul.  A city not anchored by some vision of itself is nothing more than a developers’ town.

There was a time when thinking of ourselves as the Old Pueblo was enough to impose, on what we built and how we lived, a certain character and style of life that made Tucson distinctive. Our public buildings, like the old courthouse and the veterans’ hospital were built in an exaggerated  Spanish Colonial style.

The interior decoration of our homes reflected the Southwest, Native American and Hispanic traditions. We wore boots and bolo ties, and gentlemen were excused by the mayor from wearing suit coats or jackets during the summer. Our sense of ourselves was that we were a vacation place, a dude ranch place, a place where Spanish was spoken as well as English, a place that was part of the cowboy west  and its traditions.

As we grew in size we outgrew the Old Pueblo sense of who we were. Does rodeo week still express to ourselves and others what we are? I think not. Rodeo is still fun, but it used to be downtown, when there was a downtown, and it was somehow at the heart of things, a culturally defining event. Now it’s banished to the south side and many families use the rodeo week school holiday to take the kids to Disney Land.

Tucson needs a new sense of itself if it is not to be just another sprawling, boring builders’ town.

There’s plenty to build on, including the Spanish accented cowboy west of the Old Pueblo, and the deep cultural traditions and touching cultural pretension that would build a theater and then call it The Temple of Music and Art.

We have made a start in a small way by redefining ourselves, on the electronic billboards  that welcome travelers arriving at the airport, as “Optics Valley.” Corny, derivative, commercial, but not bad. Beats “five dollar town” or “phone center central.”

If we’ve decided to be  the center of  a high tech, well-paid industry, attractive to an intelligent and well educated work force we’ve gone a long way toward redefining who we are.

But we should also aspire to become the artistic and creative center of the southwest. We invest money to bring businesses here, we should also invest money to attract, support, and encourage  the arts. We should make Tucson a place where young artists and intellectuals want to come because it is a center of creative energy.

We could use more studio space, rehearsal space, and above all  a well designed outdoor venue for  all of the performing arts. We should  build a regional art complex, with a mix of  studios, apartments, theaters, and public patio gardens; built at public expense if need be, or with the same sort of tax benefits and subsidies that we offer manufacturers and failing hotel keepers.

Let’s invite young architects and designers of all sorts, too. Let’s  start to think of ourselves as a place where all  the crafts flourish and are supported; a place too proud of its intellectual and artistic traditions to be nothing more than a developers’ town.

The Greek city of Athens was the center of its world. Athens was a great business and commercial power as well a  center of the artistic and intellectual  life of its time. There is no reason why we should not aspire to become the Athens of The Southwest.

It could be a transforming vision… and it would make excellent economic sense.

More in Pol. & Govt.:

Is War Dead In America?

  • Fraser007

    Where have you been? The City squandered $230,000,000. Its over. Cute blog but people are going to go to jail on this one and many others should.
    This City is “circling the drain”.

      • Fraser007

        Bet you saw unicorns and rainbows too. I have been here since 1966, served the public in the arts for 35 years. I have given….. $230,000,000 thats Million. Tell me what did we get for it………..a Presidio and the Fox Theater. Where did the rest go.

  • Tip O’Neill

    For a small town Tucson has a lot going for it – I’ve lived in a lot worse. The people are friendly, the local government is – well, better than most, there is quite a bit of activity both artistic and political.

    It has great weather, a very low cost of living, and the U of A. It seems to me it should be attractive to a lot of people. What it lacks is networking – both locally and especially to the outer culture. It’s too isolated.
    I don’t know how you fix that. In the internet age it wouldn’t seem to be such a problem, but it is. 

    • Fraser007

      Tip:
      Good points from an astute commenter.. We have always been isolated. Even since the 18th Century!
      I will ask you too. Where the hell did the $230,000,000 go. In the pockets of a bunch of consultants. Including the U of A. Did you ever read what they spent on the Bridge/Museums etc. Just a big gravy train and we are the chumps.

  • Clement R Knorr

    What doesn’t Jacobson understand about BROKE?  The entire Western World is on the brink of an absolute financial catastrophe, largely because of decades of endless entitlements and foolhardy government spending.  Mark my words, within a year we will be wittness to an historic collapse, far worse that the great depression.

    • snack bar

      When the moochers and looters out number the producers this is what you get!!

  • ERW

    Did this run in in 2006? 

    We would rather have our $230 million back than your “vision”.   Who knows, maybe this type of story will work on the masses, and we can pass a ‘Rio Nuevo II’ bond in 2013.

    The ‘pining for the days of yore’ does not cut it, either.   Times were not so wonderful and the sky was no more blue back then.  You want a to transform Tucson into your own little Nirvana, and it is not going to happen, nor should it.  These are YOUR ’visions’, how about letting the rest of the Tucson population participate in what the community looks like?
     

  • Mark Parity

    Kinda sucks, Mr. Art, that only two people agreed with you.  Then there were six that didn’t.  There were also about 300,000 that snorted and clicked “Next”. 
    The Internet is great.  Lots of talentless opinionated uninformed people can share their “vision” with the masses.  Thank you for sharing yours.  As you said, although you never used the big words, your vision is a bit myopic.
    Tucson’s doing fine.  The rodeo is fine where it is.  If families want to take days off to visit DisneyLand THAT TOO Is good.  I’m sorry in your world they’d be forced to go watch horses poop on asphalt.  In the real world (which includes Tucson) they can go have a GOOD TIME, not a SHITTY time. (pun intended).
    It’s great that everyone gets to express an opinion.  Just don’t forget that the fact that you have an opinion doesn’t mean it’s worth a horse’s poop on the road south of Broadway.
     
    M

  • sethers

    I don’t think Tucson is as far from this vision as one might think.  It may not have an artistic “center,” but it certainly has an artistic and intellectual heart.  That heart could use a little soul added to it, but I think it is there. As far as Rio Nuevo goes, though, the dream died for me when the city failed to actually bring back the river. That was primarily what I voted for way back when. It was a way to reconnect Tucson with it’s natural center and even better a way to renew and upgrade the sewer/water reuse system. Oh well, I guess…

  • Tip O’Neill

    >It may not have an artistic “center,” but it certainly has an artistic and intellectual heart.
    When I first moved here I tried to find a place in the local gay ghetto – only to discover that there isn’t one. Ditto for any kind of artist ghetto. 
    I’m used to living in places where people live in close contact – it foments a certain energy that is lacking here. 

  • alohapuna

    I agree, Tip. I had the same experience when I moved here.
    As for Rio Nuevo, there was a vision. That’s what was presented to the voters in 1999 when the TIF was approved. But it got lost in the feeding frenzy when the moochers and looters took over.