Tucson Citizen.com

Contemplating the Arizona Book Ban

by on Feb. 06, 2012, under Uncategorized

Photo courtesy: http://www.flickr.com/photos/mcclongview/5018003313/

There’s this book ban
in Arizona
which is supposedly
in the USA
where book banning
isn’t supposed to take place
but they went on and did it anyway.

And it happened “quicker than
you can say,
Jack Robinson,”
an idiom
from a long ago day.

Here’s a play by play.
First there was
SB1070
that they say
was to get a hold
on immigration
aka
Harass a Mexican
to make your day.

And before you could yawn
and say: “What’s going on?”
Mexican American Studies
was gone.
And the book banning
came along
like lyrics
free versed
in a rap song.

Lawd, have mercy,
something’s gone
way wrong.
When I took
a look
at the books
on the list
that Arizona doesn’t want to exist,
I wondered,
“Am I stoned?”
It was chilling
to my old bones.
I counted 88.
And according to the
Grand Canyon State,
William Shakespeare’s
“The Tempest”
doth not appeareth too great!
      And it blew my mind
      to find
      James Baldwin’s
      “Fire Next Time”
      as that book
      was as essential
      as oxygen
      in the development
      of my Colored, Negro, Black, African American
      social and political mind.
      Because of cats like James
      I ain’t the least bit blind.
And Paolo Freire,
my main man,
loving mentor to the oppressed,
blessed with the gift to help a people in distress rise like birds lifting to the skies, on to hopes and dreams, banned.
Ain’t that a trip?
      Cast aside
      by people who’s brains
      are made of “Yee! Ha!” and rawhide.
      Alongside Howard Zinn,
      Ladies and Gentlemen,
      our long time friend,
      who hipped us
      to a People’s History.
      Jonathon Kozol
      who exposed before us all
      the Savage Inequalities,
      in our communities,
      in our society,
      inequities
      to which our schools give root.
And those fools
Fahrenheit 451′d
Zoot Suit
and other Luis Valdez plays
that help folks
understand their roots,
their pachuconess,
their vatoness,
their eseness,
their chicaness…;
And down, too,
went Culture Clash.
They flatout don’t want
young Chicanos
to think and laugh.
Oh, man, that’s a gas.
      It’s like a mass dash
      to bash what they see as the underclass.
      And what’s their fear of
      “Like Water for Chocolate?”
      an immaculate love story
      of tense human emotions,
      intertwined with food and
      recipes and Mexican traditions…

The powers-that-be
simply cannot tolerate imagery
wherein brown children
learn the wonders
of their culture,
who they are,
where they’ve been,
how they’ve come
to the various situations
they find themselves in.
But the powers-that-be
are a bit tardy
because the children
are already
Rethinking Columbus
and the sins
perpetrated against them,
like the one they’re
wrapped up in in this very second.
They already know the truth.
They’ve had Chicano Studies.
Recuerdo?
They live what they’ve learned,
loving life,
feeling good about themselves,
giving to their world,
as that’s what their learning
has concentrated on.
So, powers-that-be,
your hateful ugly grandiose plan
to keep Mexican Americans
from living free
is pretty much over and done.
The Chicanos will win
because when a people
are up on their feet
trekking on a path to full liberty,
a path to a life of dignity,
they can’t help but overcome.
That’s Pursuit of Freedom 101.

Watch out Arizona!

More in Tucson Life and Heritage:

Watching The Eclipse!

  • http://none JimBodkins

    :) again.

    • Ernie McCray

      Yeah…

  • JUST LIKE GREECE

    And here is where it gets really hairy
    The books are in the library 

    Find me a kid that knows the way there
    and I’ll show you a kid who knows what banned means, 
    doesn’t let others stand in their way to real education
    and has parents who know what a priority is. 

    • Ernie McCray

      And “banned” means and a “priority” is?

      • Tim

        Put your money where your mouth is and admit that you would be fine with a non-elective class that teaches American history through the lens of Goldwater’s “Conscience of a Conservative” and the writings of William F. Buckley. A sample essay question could be “How does Goldwater demonstrate that labor unions have undermined freedom?” Don’t just lie and say it’s already happening (because it isn’t), be consistent and say that you actually approve of it because you believe that not permitting this is the same thing as book banning.

        • Ernie McCray

          The best way I can address this based on the way you’ve presented it as a challenge is to cite something from my past when I was principal of a school and we initiated an African American Male Club, designed to address problems black boys were having in school and in society in general. A couple of white students came to me, mad as hell, claiming reverse discrimination and they said “If we can have an African American Male Club at the school why can’t we have a White Male Club?” My immediate answer was “You can not only have a White Male Club, I’ll help you start it – as long as it has as its purpose the same kinds of things we’re trying to do with the black guys, as long as it explores your history, your place in society over the years, as long as it is geared to taking that knowledge and considering and pursuing ways you can better yourselves as loving and caring human beings and find ways to contribute positively to the school and to the community.” They just mumbled and walked away and every now and then I would say “When are we going to get the club started?” And I was serious. That was in the late 80′s and I still haven’t heard an answer.
          I have to ask you this based on what I remember of Barry when I was growing up in Arizona in the 40′s and 50′s: With how blacks were treated in his businesses he had a conscience? And unions, made up of “We the People,” have undermined freedom? How so? These would be the kinds of questions I’d ask in the non-elective classes you’re suggesting. The classroom would roar with excitement and learning; I’d love it.

          • Tim

            The examples were rhetorical, you were supposed to disagree with them. I don’t doubt that you would relish the challenge of a class like that, but if you’re really saying that you think such an overtly biased approach should be permitted as high school curriculum then we disagree on that point. If that means I have to put up with angry right wingers complaining that I’m in favor of “banning” conservative authors, I can live with those false charges.

        • leftfield

          “A sample essay question could be “How does Goldwater demonstrate that labor unions have undermined freedom?””

          Be careful what you wish for, Tim.  Discussions and debates surrounding this and other core tenets of conservatism might not convert so much as they expose.  Children of that age tend to be open-minded and inquisitive.   

          • Tim

            Fortunately there will be teachers with complete allegiance to those tenets to steer the children’s thinking in the “right” direction. Students who are too openminded will gently but firmly be cautioned of the shameful perils of undermining liberty. If the power of academia can convince children that Cuba is a utopia, I think it can handle making unions look bad.

            So we can count on your support too then? Or are you gonna be a book-banner?

  • http://www.snakejazz.com Dave Baldwin

    Ernie, the banning of books has always been a sure sign of the fear of education.  Is this banned book list published anywhere on the Internet?  I’m anxious to read it.

    • Ernie McCray

      I’ll see if I can find it for you.

  • http://twitter.com/SafeLibraries Dan Kleinman

    It is not a book ban.  Half a century ago the last book was banned in the USA: http://www.317am.net/2011/08/banned-book-favorites-fanny-hill-reprise.html

    • Ernie_McCray

       So what is it? A book beaning? A book brush back? A book bashing?

  • Ernie_McCray

    This situation has gained attention around the world and will eventually be made right, starting in part, with efforts in behalf of the cause in San Diego this coming weekend – where we’re celebrating 100 years of free speech.