Tucson Citizen.com
Caveat Lector - Politics, Government and the Free Press – by Mark B. Evans

Where were you when the wall fell?

by on Nov. 09, 2009, under Politics

There are events in the human saga so extraordinary that they become celebrated or commemorated for decades, even generations.

Some are so exceptional that after they happen, those who were alive at the time remember where they were, what they were doing and whom they were with for the rest of their lives.

Tragically, most of those events are tragedies. Depending on your age, many Americans can recall what they were doing the exact moment they learned of the bombing of Pearl Harbor, the death of President Roosevelt, the assassinations of President Kennedy and Martin Luther King Jr and the attacks of Sept. 11.

Recalling the exact moment of the triumphs of our greatest struggles in the past 70 years are far fewer, perhaps because the triumphs are rarely as sudden as the tragedies. Few of us know exactly when Jim Crow died, we just know he did.

But every American who is old enough can recall the moment they learned of the end of the war in Europe and Japan or when Neil Armstrong stepped on the moon.

And every American should recall the events of Nov. 9, 1989, 20 years ago today, a day that may go down in history as the greatest of the 20th century – the symbolic end of soviet Russia’s domination of Eastern Europe and the collapse of communism.

In October 1989, communist Hungary allowed a few of its captive citizens entry into Austria. Soon thousands of Hungarians rushed to the border crossing. They were supposed to be on holiday, but their overflowing luggage and frightened looks weren’t fooling anyone; everyone knew they weren’t coming back.

The world looked to Moscow wondering when the tanks would roll like they had in 1956 in Hungary and in 1968 in Czechoslovakia. But Soviet Union leader Mikhail Gorbachev, for reasons few understood at the time, kept the tanks in their bases.

Czechoslovakia followed Hungary’s lead and opened its borders. Tens of thousands of East Europeans, crushed under the totalitarian boot of Soviet imperialism for five decades, poured into the two cracks of the Iron Curtain yearning to be free.

Emboldened East Germans flooded into Hungary to crossover to freedom. The entire Warsaw Pact was in crisis. The only way to stop the exodus was with force. Many in the West speculated that this could be the beginning of World War III, perhaps the end of civilization as we knew it. Tension grew around the world. NATO was on full alert.

In early November East and West Germans began to congregate on either side of the Berlin Wall near the Brandenburg Gate protesting the right to freely cross. The paranoid East Germans looked to Gorbachev and he told them to open the gate.

On Nov. 9, East Germany announced it would allow East Berliners to “visit” West Berlin if they wanted and opened all the border crossings.

And that was it, the end of the Cold War. We, the democratic West, had won.

Fittingly, it ended with a party atop the very symbol of communist repression, the Berlin Wall.

We had spent trillions of dollars to fight the spread of communism on every continent on the planet (yes, even Antarctica). Millions died, including nearly 100,000 Americans.

It was worth every penny and, perhaps, every life. The future of freedom and democracy had depended on it.

Today is a great day and we should commemorate it and celebrate it every year, not every decade like it’s some high school reunion.

More in Pol. & Govt.:

A Question for Believers

  • Mark B. Evans

    I didn’t want to add this above because I want it be as close to what was published in the Star this morning as possible.
    But to answer my own question, I was living in California sort of going to college. I worked in loss prevention for Sears at a mall in the San Fernando Valley in L.A.
    It was a Thursday afternoon and I was supposed to be catching shoplifters, but as I walked past the TV section, every set was tuned to ABC and its coverage of the protest at the wall.
    I had read in the LA Times that morning that it was likely the paranoid East Germans would crush the protest at the Brandenburg gate and perhaps spark a greater conflagration in all of Eastern Europe.
    The pessimist in me was certain this was the beginning of World War III. I was sure East Germany would erupt into a civil war that would spread to other Eastern Bloc nations, and Gorbachev would be forced to crush the rebellion lest it spread to the USSR.
    There would have been immense pressure on George H.W. Bush and NATO to come to the aid of the freedom fighters and not sit on our hands like we did in 1956 and 1968. I was still in the Army Reserves and was sure I’d get the call any day.
    So standing there in the TV section of Sears, I was stunned that the GDR had opened the gates. I watched the celebration on the wall for most of my six-hour shift, as did many of the sales staff. Managers kept trying to shoo us all back to work but they became just as enthralled with what was on the TV as the rest of us. There must have been 200 people – store staff and customers – crowded around those TVs.
    I didn’t believe that this was the end of the Cold War, there was still plenty of opportunity for the GDR and Gorbachev to change their minds. But for that moment, I knew it was history and I was going to watch it.
    I don’t know how much stuff shoplifters stole that day, but I didn’t really care. I was a witness to history. I’ll never forget it.

  • radmax

    I remember the shock, disbelief and tension of this time. Who knew the Soviet Bear was in actuality a facade, rotting from the inside out? Apparently not our intelligence agencies.
    I do recall my Naval recruiter in ’81 telling me that Reagan was going to triple the Navy’s budget and start building warships at a pace not seen since WWII. I believe massive defense spending, along with some of the more exotic exotic weapons systems,( remember the Soviets scrambling to put an end to ‘star wars’? ) hastened the fall of the Iron Curtain. Today many minimize Reagan’s contribution to the Soviet collapse, saying it would have happened anyway. Whether intentional or not, I believe RR deserves our thanks, if nothing else. He helped alleviate  probably the greatest threat to the free world since Adolf put a bullet through his noggin.

    • radmax

      sorry about the doubly exotic weapons systems… :)

  • tiponeill

    It was great for a few moments – there was a rumor that we could stop spending 500 billion a year on the military and get a “peace dividend”.
    Who knew, maybe we could afford healthcare.
    Of course as we all know Bush immediately found someone to go to war with and here we are.
    “For 45 years of the Cold War we were in an arms race with the Soviet Union. Now it appears we’re in an arms race with ourselves.” Admiral Eugene Carroll, Jr., U.S. Navy (Ret.)

    • fortbuckley

      tip, I do believe that, if Ronald Reagan or George H.W. Bush had cured cancer…you’d have critcized them for putting gravediggers out of work.

      • tiponeill

        I’m willing to give credit where it’s due, just not to make up fairy tales after the fact.
        Bush didn’t even want the wall to come down, and the idea that Regan bankrupting us by spending on missiles and Star Wars caused the end of the Cold War has been thoroughly debunked.
        I also think that we would have been better off without the Vietnam War, and would be better off without being at war today in Iraq and Afghanistan.
        Of course, none of these expenses has put gravediggers out of work – just automated a lot of it.
         

        • fortbuckley

          <i>the idea that Regan bankrupting us by spending on missiles and Star Wars caused the end of the Cold War has been thoroughly debunked.</i>

          Debunked by whom?  Noam Chomsky?  The spineless wonders of the Carter/Ted Kennedy era appeasment Democrats?

          For some reason, the Poles think Reagan had a big part to play in ending the Cold War.  Lech Walesa, for one, credits Reagan for giving the Soviet Union the shove it needed to crumble.  There are places named after Ronald Reagan in Gdansk, Krakow and Wroclaw.

          For some other reason, the Google search “tip o’neil honors poland” returns—nothing.  Gee—I wonder why?

          • tiponeill

            You’re entitled to believe your your alternate history, but it won’t affect the real history books. Or Gorbachev’s Nobel Peace Prize.

          • radmax

            Lost an empire, give ‘em a consolation prize. We also have some wonderful parting gifts…didn’t that snake Arafat win one of those?

          • radmax

            Sorry tip, that was snarky, but I’ve yet to hear a more plausible alternate history.

        • fortbuckley

          tiponeil, I triple-dog-dare you to show some supporting evidence for these words of yours:  Bush didn’t even WANT the wall to come down.
          Cite that.  Show us your source?  I’ll bet you can’t.

          Matter of fact, it wouldn’t surprise me if you’re making it up.
          In case you’re wondering, the Op-Ed Lech Walesa wrote praising Ronald Reagan is in the Wall Street Journal’s Opinion Journal, June 11th 2004

  • fortbuckley

    I was sitting on the couch in my apartment in Lawton, Oklahoma.  I turned on the TV, saw people standing on the Berlin Wall, and thought to myself “Hey!  Those folks better get down or they’ll get shot!”

    I’d just returned from a three-year tour in Germany, which included three extended trips to East Berlin.  Once you went through Checkpoint Charlie into the eastern part of the city, a pervasive gloom smothered you.  Everything seemed gray—the buildings, the people.  West Berlin, on the other hand, literally bustled.  An island of normalcy in a sea of misery.

    To give you an idea of how strained the atmosphere was in/around the Soviet Zone:  the Soviet border guards at the West German border weren’t permitted to talk to–or even make eye contact with—American, British or French military personnel  When we presented our travel orders, we put them in a mail slot in a boarded-up window.  A Soviet guard on the other side would stamp them and fling them back through. 

    The Allies refused to officially recognize the existence of an “East German” army.  Only soverign nations have armies.  And, as far as the Western Allies were concerned, Germany was only “temporarily” divided.  So, when American military personnel had official needs in East Germany, they insisted on speaking only with Soviet soldiers—our, ahem, “allies.”  In that sense, WWII hadn’t really ended.

    Of course, this led to some silly extremes on both sides.  The East Germans would encourage American military personnel to visit their war memorials.  If we did, and happened to take our hats off out of respect, you ran the risk of being photgraphed showing respect to—and therefore “recognizing”—East German soldiers.  

    Once, while driving into the east, I stopped at the East German checkpoint.  An East German border guard dutifully noted the number of occupants, our services and ranks.  It was raining, so the guard wiped the rain off my car window so he could see my insignia.  When I was leaving East Berlin for the day, the American guard asked if I’d had any incidents with the East Germans.  Jokingly, I told them about the window incident—and I think the guards wrote it down.

    Now, if you go back to the Brandenburg Gate (I have), there’s hardly a trace of the wall.  Thank goodness. It was a perversion.

    • fortbuckley

      And, for the record, I was stunned to see the Wall come down so quickly.  Most Germans I knew felt it would never fall.

      Gladly, we were wrong.

  • tiponeill

    I’m not sure about Arafat, but I know that Tom Lehrer declared satire to be dead when they gave one to Henry Kissinger.

  • tiponeill

    Really ?
    You think that the brilliant St. Ronny’s plan to spend trillions of dollars on nuclear warheads (that we can’t figure out how to get rid of now) so shook the great Soviet Menace that it simply collapsed, and if he hadn’t done that then today the Soviet Empire would be a colossus and we would be training our kids for Red Dawn ?
    Makes a great movie, but it isn’t “believable” to historians who point to many other effects on the Soviet economy, from the Afghanistan adventure to to drop in the cost of oil.
    Boring, I know – wouldn’t make nearly as good Morning in America ad.
     

    • radmax

      No tip, I believe his hawk mentality to build up the military inadvertently precipitated a catch-up mode the Soviets could not keep up with. I’m not saying that they didn’t have serious problems to start with.
      Probably more luck than anything else, right time, right place, right policies. Still, I think the Soviets perception of RR as an unpredictable  ‘cowboy’ scared the hell out of ‘em.

    • fortbuckley

      OK, Tip, I’ll take that deal.  You and the Democrats can hang your hats on the learned “historians”—many of whom felt the Soviet Union was too big to challenge.  We Republicans will stand with Ronald Reagan and Lech Walesa—men who made things happen and made the world a better place.

      There’s a reason people call the Republican Party the “daddy” party, tip.

      • tiponeill

        There’s a reason people call the Republican Party the “daddy” party, tip.
        Again we obviously know different “people”, since I have never heard that.
        I’ve heard it called a lot of things :) but never the “daddy party”.
         

  • JerryAnn

    I believe that the Berlin wall coming down was gradual in coming and that the signs were everywhere that it would happen.  I believe the act of tearing down Berlin Wall was very symbolic for what was happening in the Soviet bloc at the time.  They were imploding.  I think that Reagan came at a time when the Russian politicos knew their days were numbered and wanted any excuse to shut down shop.  I think that my memories of greatest joy and pride  would be the landing on the moon some 20 years earlier, the fall of the Berlin Wall, the end of the first Persian Gulf war andmore recenty the election of Obama. My memories of  greatest sorrow  would be  JFK’s assassination, the 9/11 attack and the first day of the Iraqi war, in that order. 

    • fortbuckley

      Lech Walesa seems to think that Ronald Reagan had a lot to do with the Berlin Wall falling and the Soviet Union collapsing.  Yes, the Soviet Union might have collapsed on its own—but totalitarian regimes have a habit of lasting long, long past their prime.  All the while, their people suffer.

      If Ronald Reagan was, in reality, insignificant in the big scheme of things, when it came to the Wall’s falling—then why did the people of Gdansk–home of the Solidarity movement—go to the trouble of naming a square after him?

      • radmax

        I think you shut ‘em up FB. :)

  • JerryAnn

    I didn’t mean that he wasn’t instrumental and important to the moment in time.  He was instrumental to the Soviet politicos in giving them a  chance to save face internationally.  With radio, television the internet, etc. their own citizens would have, sooner of later, revolted and hung them in Red Square.  The power of Solidarity and Lech Walesa was unprecedented and  became the perfect storm against the communists  in the Kremlin.  That Reagan backed them and encouraged them to continue was important to the Poles. The right people in the right place at the right time. 

  • leftfield

    It’s premature to talk about the death of communism, and it is also misleading to equate the fall of the Soviet Union with the death of communism.  I think communism is much better of without the USSR around; gave the whole idea a bad name and gave the capitalist toadies a bad guy to point at.  It was the deaths of Lenin and Trotsky and the rise of Stalin that doomed the Russian Revolution, much more so than anything that flatulent and demented fool Reagan could ever do.

    • radmax

      Well said Lefty. The USSR was on the downside since Trotsky was axed and Stalin had Lenin poisoned. Still, RR had a lasting effect on European politics for some time to come, leftist hatred,vs.  admiration for his steadfast hatred of communism, and unrelenting passion to rid the world of an  abomination of uncle Karl’s dream. :)
      PS- how’d the protest go? No broken skulls I hope…

  • leftfield

    I had never heard that Stalin poisoned Lenin.  I am inclined to want to believe it, but, have you read anything credible in this regard?

    Yes, RR had an effect, just as an overdose of laxative will have an effect.  With Margaret Thatcher and Ayn Rand at his side, how could he not effect Europe?

    The protest is coming up this weekend.  I think I can outrun most of the counter-demonstrators.  I may have to, as most of my fellows will be religious folks and inclined to turn the other cheek.  Sad but true.

    • radmax

      Just an educated guess on Stalin…seems to fit Jo-Jo’s m.o. though.
      Be careful at Ft. Huachuca. :)