Tucson Citizen.com
Caveat Lector - Politics, Government and the Free Press – by Mark B. Evans

It’s AGTA, not TGMS that’s unhappy with TCC

by on Feb. 01, 2010, under Editorials, Politics

In a blog post last week, which also ran in the Arizona Daily Star today, I said the Tucson Gem & Mineral Society was unhappy with the city and the progress (or lack of it) in renovations to the Tucson Convention Center, but I got my shows wrong.

It’s the American Gem Trade Association, which has a huge wholesale show at the TCC the week before the TGMS main show at the TCC, that’s unhappy and talking about moving.

Big mistake, but it doesn’t necessarily change the premise of my argument, which is that politicians and others have been saying Tucson “could lose the gem show” if improvements aren’t made to the TCC. That leads people to think the whole shebang, all 40 some shows including the TGMS main show, might leave. And that’s just not going to happen.

But I should have correctly stated who’s unhappy. Mea Culpa.

It’s a further example at just how complicated this amalgamation of shows has become. Perhaps we should train ourselves to call it the Tucson Gem Shows, with emphasis on the plural. (Others have tried to create a name to offset “Tucson Gem Show” and demonstrate how big it is, but  “Tucson Gem, Mineral & Fossil Showcase” has never really caught on, it’s too long).

Below is the text of an e-mail I got from the MTCVB, correcting my post.

Hi Mark,

I just read your blog post on the Gem Show.  I am especially impressed with the accuracy and discussion of the number of shows in Tucson.  Unfortunately, many Tucsonans still think that the “Gem Show” is one single show at the TCC when the Gem, Fossil & Mineral Showcase is, as you’ve pointed out, 44 shows in 42 locations around the city. We at the MTCVB certainly agree with you and support the idea that Tucson must be supportive of this event in every way to make attendees feel welcome and appreciated in our city.

I do believe that there is a misunderstanding on which show organizers are voicing concerns about Tucson’s Convention Center space and downtown offerings.  You state that the TGMS show (Tucson Gem & Mineral Society show Feb 11-14) organizers are unhappy with the TCC. To our knowledge, the AGTA Gem fair, the wholesale show (Feb 2-7) owners/representatives have been most vocal about issues with the TCC.

I have personally spoken with members of the Tucson Gem & Mineral Society, the group that began the Gem Shows 52 years ago, and they have stated that they don’t plan on ever moving the TGMS show from Tucson.

The TGMS and AGTA shows are the two largest shows of the showcase and both at the Convention Center.  Perhaps this fact has caused some confusion.

I hope to help clear up any misunderstandings that may have existed about the gem shows.  Please also know that if your readers need one place to go for information on the entire showcase, they can visit www.visittcson.org/gemshow <http://www.visittcson.org/gemshow> or call our Information line at 800-638-8350.

Thank you for taking the time to make corrections and clarifications.

Kimberly Schmitz
Director of Communications & PR
Metropolitan Tucson Convention & Visitors Bureau
100 S. Church Ave
Tucson, AZ 85701
Visit us at www.visitTucson.org <http://www.visitTucson.org>
Follow me on Twitter at
http://twitter.com/KSinTucson <http://twitter.com/KSinTucson>
Find us on FB. Become a fan of Tucson Will Surprise You <http://www.facebook.com/pages/Tucson-Will-Surprise-You/84160305904> .

More in Pol. & Govt.:

Arizona's Failed Leadership

  • Rio Never

     Dear Gem Show: Our actions speak louder than words “We’ll do whatever it takes to protect (the Gem show),” Walkup said.  “if we have to reprioritize projects, we will do that.”http://www.tucsoncitizen.com/ss/related/110465 ”We do not want to lose it and under my watch I’m going to be doing whatever I can to make sure that doesn’t happen,” Glassman saidhttp://www.kgun9.com/Global/story.asp?S=11270605 Walkup said the gem show has an annual exit interview with city officials in which they bring up perceived deficiencies in Tucson.http://www.azstarnet.com/sn/biz-topheadlines/280808 I think it’s important that when the gem show comes to town, they see we are following through on our commitment,” Trasoff said. http://www.hotel-online.com/News/2009_Oct_07/k.AZC.1254936968.html   2005 Gem Show came and went.  During the next fiscal year Rio Nuevo spent $12.3 million on everything except renovating the Convention Center or a hotel.  Major expenditures included:$6 million for the Fox Theatre (a truly wonderful venue but a financial disaster)$1.3 million for Presidio & Heritage Park.  2006 Gem Show came and went.  During the next fiscal year Rio Nuevo spent $16.7 million on everything except renovating the Convention Center or a hotel.  Major expenditures included:$4 million for Mercado Avenue$3 million for Mission Site/Origins Park$1.5 million for the Mission Landfill$1.2 million for Presidio & Heritage Park.I don’t remember the Gem Show asking for any of these projects.  These must have been higher priority than the gem Show.  2007 Gem Show came and went.  During the next fiscal year Rio Nuevo spent $33.2 million on everything except renovating the Convention Center or a hotel.  Major expenditures included:            $11 million for Mission Site/Origins Park$9 million for I-10 underpass$5.5 million for the Science CenterSo far we have spent $18 million on the Mission Site/Origins Park; I am sure this will be magnificent.  Unfortunately, this project is not likely to help keep the Gem Show, nor does it generate revenue.  2008 Gem Show came and went.  During the next fiscal year through May 2009, Rio Nuevo spent $28.6 million on everything except renovating the Convention Center or a hotel.  No wait, Rio Nuevo spent $553,000 on planning for the hotel.  Major expenditures included:$8 million for downtown infrastructure$5 million for depot parking garage$2 million on Mission Site/Origins Park$1.4 million on AZ History Museum$1.3 million on Mission GardensTo be fair, infrastructure and parking can help the Gem Show.  But, still no renovation of the Convention Center or anything of significant interest to the Gem Show.  This City Council has sent a very clear message to the Gem Show: Rio Nuevo has spent $118 million on all sorts of things, but nothing that indicates your show is of value to our community.  Expenditure data taken from “Rio Nuevo Flow of Funds”http://www.tucsonaz.gov/rionuevo/docs/RNExpenses.pdf