Tucson Citizen.com
Caveat Lector - Politics, Government and the Free Press – by Mark B. Evans

Congress needs to remind Obama border crisis continues

by on Feb. 05, 2010, under Editorials, Politics

Remember when there was a crisis on the border? You know, all the way back in 2007 when all anyone talked about was how to stop the invading horde and expel from the country the millions of pernicious illegal immigrant freeloaders?

Few public officials, other than Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio and state Sen. Russell Pearce, even bother to bring it up any more, or hold town halls or issue shrill campaign press releases clamoring about all of the “illegals” destroying the country.

In President Obama’s recently released federal budget proposal, funding for border security stays roughly the same, the first time in years that it hasn’t significantly increased over the previous year.

He also will reduce the number of Border Patrol agents, albeit only by 180, or about 0.8 percent. But that’s the first time since 1993 that there won’t be more Border Patrol agents than the previous year.

And no further border fencing will be erected, the first time in at least three years the miles of border fencing won’t increase.

His budget might lead one to think the border crisis is over.

Hardly.

In the Border Patrol’s Tucson Sector, which includes every Arizona county except Yuma, La Paz and Mohave, agents apprehended nearly 250,000 illegal immigrants in fiscal year 2009, which ended Sept. 30. That was about half the total apprehensions made in all of the Mexican border sectors last year.

That’s a far cry from the peak of the crisis in 2006 when 1.1 million illegal immigrants were apprehended along the border, nearly 500,000 of them in Arizona.

But a quarter-million souls caught trying to get into the country through Arizona does not represent a solved problem; it’s still an enormous economic, environmental and humanitarian crisis, especially for Arizona.

The desert south of Tucson has been destroyed. Millions of pounds of trash litter the desert, most concentrated in a few dozen arroyos where immigrants hunker down to hide from the Border Patrol or wait for vehicles to smuggle them to other parts of the country.

In federal fiscal year 2008 the Bureau of Land Management picked up 184,000 pounds of trash and hauled away 70 abandoned vehicles. It barely made a dent in the amount of debris strewn across our public lands.

The BLM estimates that each entrant leaves behind about eight pounds of trash. Since 2006, more than 1 million illegal immigrants have been apprehended in the Tucson Sector. There is no way to know how many more got through, but using the conservative estimate of one getting away for every one caught, that means that in just the past three years an estimated 8 million to 16 million tons of trash has been left by immigrants to foul our desert. That’s the equivalent of driving 350 to 700 trash trucks into the desert and dumping them.

Camping, hiking or biking in the desert surrounding Tucson remains a dangerous affair as coyotes have become increasingly violent in the increasingly lucrative human-smuggling trade.

And the humanitarian toll has only worsened. Despite the recent drop in apprehensions, the number of bodies found in the desert by the Border Patrol hit a record high last year: 208.

The rotten economy, the banking crisis, the housing crisis, two wars and the health care reform political fiasco have obviously consumed the majority of Obama’s attention during his first year in office.

But that’s why we have a Congress. We hope that Arizona’s two senators and eight representatives have not turned their back on the terrible toll illegal immigration is taking on this state and that they set about amending Obama’s ill-considered border security budget.

The crisis continues. Either do more to seal the border or pass comprehensive immigration reform, or both. Doing the same or less than last year is not the answer.

More in Pol. & Govt.:

A Question for Believers

  • David Nichols

    I believe in controlling our Borders; however good hard working Immigrants, and their Citizen children have been here for many years, and have  been treated as Less than “Human”, since the Deportaion/Starvation of them began in January 2008, and Deserve Far Better!

    January 2008 = Start of Deportation/Starvation Program.

    January 2008 = Start of the worst Recession in U.S. History!

    You see America was Biuilt on Far Better Principles!

    This is our I.C.E.’d E-conomy!

    America needs to wake up, and realize what is going on while we still have any E-conomy Left!

    To those saying “No Amnesty”, I hope your maker allows you a little!

    To: Good and Brotherhood from sea to shining sea.

    P.S. The U.S. Border Patrol used to maintain water stations in the desert to help Immigrants across on their Hard Journey here!

    I think now we could at least treat them as “Human’!

    • Don Miller

      I will treat them as humans as soon as they start paying taxes

  • leftfield

    Open the border and let ‘em in!  In every country where neoliberal trade policy has been forced upon the people; in every country that American capital is free to come and go at will, let the people also come and go at will.

    • radmax

      And do exactly what with ‘em when they get here? Give them the imaginary jobs that Americans won’t do? Sorry Lefty, the jobs vanished like they were never here in the first place. If we ever get out of ten percent unemployment, we’ll talk.

      • leftfield

        And what with them?  A large population of people with revolutionary potential that can be organized?  Hmmmm….let me think.

        • radmax

          The ‘Red Menace ‘rears it’s ugly head. I know what you’re gettin’ at Lefty…”The American working class has no revolutionary potential, in my opinion…”. So bring another country’s downtrodden in for commie indoctrination. Heinously brilliant. V.I and Grandpa Ho would be proud of you, ya bomb throwin’ Trotskyite. ;)

          • leftfield

            “V.I and Grandpa Ho would be proud of you…”

            That would be more than I could hope for.

          • radmax

            Yes, there are those of us who cherish liberty, freedom of expression, self determination and justice; then there are those who choose to live with the crushing weight of a hob-nailed boot of  communist oligarchy firmly planted on their collective throats…BTW, if you hear of such a place with the aforementioned ideals, let me know. ;)

  • azmouse

    What’s wrong with people going through the proper channels to come here legally. There is a right way and a wrong way. In the meantime, border security is very important to me.

  • Ferraribubba

    My paternal granparents, Wilhelm Dieter and Elizabeth Hilser got off the boat from Germany on Ellis Island in 1905 with their two daughters, Anne and Madeline. My dad was the only one in the family born in the U.S. of A. 5 years later. They came the legal way.
    If they hadn’t come to America for a new life, my grandmother, a full-blooded German Jew probably would have ended up like most of her relatives did, being gassed in the ovens of one of Hitler’s extermination camps. And her half-Jew children, including my father would have ended up in the camps too.
    Unlike most of the Hyphenated-Americans that I saw while I lived in the OLd Pueblo and elsewhere, they just called themselves Americans, never German-Americans, and only spoke English, even around the one-room cold water flat above the saloon that they rented in the Bowery before moving to California, where my dad was born. They became U.S. citizens before the First World War.
    My grandfather died of TB when my dad was 6 months old, and my grandmother took in ironing to support the family. She never took a penny of welfare or anything like that, and my dad had to quit school at the age of 15 to help support the family.
    Relying on FedGovCo is a crutch that gets to be a habit that some people find hard to break. Take New Orleans for instance. Over 4 years after Katrina, and thousands are still sucking on the public teat. Living and eating on the taxpayers’ dime.
    Why? They just don’t know no better. That’s the way it was, that’s the way it is, and that’s the way it’s gonna be.
    That’s  just one of the examples of why our once great country is $13.4 Trillion Dollars in debt, and going to hell in a handbasket, quicker than salts go thru ZaZa Gabor.
    Yer pal, Ferrari Bubba

    • leftfield

      Great story, FB.  But what has that got to do with anything?

      I am not sure why, but you seem to be convinced that there’s an army of people out there that are, at this very moment, watching big screen TV’s, drinking cheap beer and laughing about how they are getting everything they need for free.  NO doubt they are also living in a much nicer place than your grandparents and never doing a lick of work, partly out of laziness and partly because they are too busy reproducing. 

  • radmax

    “quicker than salts go thru ZaZa Gabor”…Hey FB, my gal and I are pondering what the heck that means, and it’s a curious phrase, so could you clear it up for us please?(bet it’s a good one)

  • Ferraribubba

    Hey Lefty: BINGO! Now you’re starting to get it. <g>
    And Radmax: It’s an old saying to illustrate the speed that something can, and probably will happen.
    Not unlike the vexing question: Which has more fingerprints, the FBI, or ETA?
    That answer of course is . . . Elizabeth Taylor’s Azz.
    You had to ask .
    Yer pal, Ferrari Bubba

    • radmax

      Got that part-I don’t get the reference to Zsa Zsa, now if it was diamonds…or husbands…Help us out FB! ;)

  • Ferraribubba

    ZaZa has been reamed my so many different drills, so to speak, that it would be like trying to go bowling with tennis ball.
    Remind me to tell you about one of her ex-husbands that I met when I was a kid. The Dominican playboyPorfirio Rubirosa, who was killed when he crashed his Ferrari into a tree early one morning in Paris.
    To say thay Rubbi was ‘well endowed’ would be the understatement of the year to date.
    In Paris restaurants in his day, when the server would bring the salads, with the huge pepper mills, he’d hold the mill up over your salad and ask with a wink and a smile. “Would you like a lille Rubirosa, sir?” And grind away. 
    Rubirosa couldn’t walk enywhere without women pulling him into dark corners and having their way with him. Rich, hansome, suave, he was a lady killer for sure, equally at ease in either a tux or a drivers suit. Or between the sheets for that matter. <g>
    He was married ti two of the richest woen in the world, Doris Duke and Barbara Hutton. Also had flings with actresses Joan Crawford, Jean Teirney, Rita Hayworth, Jayne Mansfield, Betty Grable, Ava Gardner, and even little Judy Garland.
    Yer pal, Ferrari Bubba

    • radmax

      Ya know FB, I figgered you were gettin’ at that, but my lady insisted that you would have said ‘protein thru Zsa Zsa’. The ‘salty dog’ strikes again. ;)
      She’s such a stickler for accuracy, must have done better at chemistry than me… :)

      • radmax

        BTW-My gal wants to head to gay Paris this summer. I gotta tell ya, if one of those froggys tries to ‘ruby’ my salad, they’re gonna be pickin’ up French chicklets for a week.

        • radmax

          Oh, and while we’re at it, close the border down like the commies did in Berlin in ’61. Let the exodus try the airways…

        • Ferraribubba

          ey Radmax: Google Porfirio Rubirosa and go to ’Porfirio Rubirosa the last of the famous international playboys.’ And be sure to check out the pictures at the bottom. They’re a gas!
          BTW, It would be an honour to be ‘Rubi’ed in Paris, imho.
          Yer pal, Ferrari Bubba

          • leftfield

            And Porfirio’s redeeming features would be?

  • tiponeill

    I understand our Republican representatives are in a tizzy about Big Government Spending – doesn’t seem likely that they will be pushing for an INCREASE in budgeting.

  • Thomas D.

    And the Arizona Daily Star would report a story like this, no way. I have to get this the the Citizen (good for them).

  • bingbong

    Obama and company want to retain power. Livin in the Whitehouse be cool.  The obvious to reduce unemployment is to enforce the immigration laws.  Obama knows it and if necessary will throw the illegals under the bus to retain the stay in the whitehouse. A drug gang incident at the border could be blown up to justify extreme enforcement on the border and cover for Obama (they happen every day just pick one).  Enforcement of illegals working can be increased by not fighting the actions of state and local governments.  Obama with use immigration enforcement to fight unemployment if necessary but will make it look otherwise.

  • Gringo Viejo

    Where does this fellow get his facts?  He says that “millions of tons of trash” ….” are concentrated in a few dozen arroyos”.  Whatever credibility this guy might have had is lost with this incredulous assertion.  Instead of his Chicken Little/The Sky Is Falling approach, perhaps if he would offer a few coherent ideas he might be taken seriously.   His opinion piece sounds more like some diatribe that could have been written by the so called “minutemen” organization.

    • Mark B. Evans

      “millions of tons” was a typo, I meant millions of pounds, obviously.
      As for the assertion that the desert is awash in millions of pounds of trash, see any of the following:

      See any of these reports at BLM’s website:
      http://www.blm.gov/az/st/en/info/newsroom/undocumented_aliens.html
       
      Here’s an excerpt from Arizona Daily Star article on the same topic:
      Crossers Burying Border In Garbage
      By: Tony Davis, Arizona Daily Star
      After three years of cleanups, the federal government has achieved no better than a 1 percent solution for the problem of trash left in Southern Arizona by illegal border-crossers.
      Cleanup crews from various agencies, volunteer groups and the Tohono O’odham Nation hauled about 250,000 pounds of trash from thousands of acres of federal, state and private land across Southern Arizona in 2002 to 2005, says the U.S. Bureau of Land Management.
      But that’s only a fraction of the nearly 25 million pounds of trash thought to be out there.
      Authorities estimate the 3.2 million-plus entrants caught by the Border Patrol dropped that much garbage in the Southern Arizona desert from July 1999 through June 2005. The figure assumes that each illegal entrant discards 8 pounds of trash, the weight of some abandoned backpacks found in the desert.
      The trash is piling up faster than it can be cleaned up. Considering that the Border Patrol apprehended more than 577,000 entrants in 2004-05 alone, the BLM figures that those people left almost 4 million pounds of trash in that same year.

  • leftfield

    I’ve been there and seen it; yep, there’s a lot of trash along the trails.  As bad as that is, what’s more important is the human tragedy taking place. 

    The militarization of the border, the waves of migrants coming North and NAFTA all began simultaneously.  The trade agreement forces Mexico to accept US corn which sells for less than what it can be grown for in Mexico.  This has resulted in a mass migration from rural areas to cities and North, looking for work.  Similar issues contributed to the disaster in Haiti.  Prior to Haiti being flooded with US rice (courtesy of neoliberal trade policy forced on Haiti by the IMF and WB), Port Au Prince was about the size of Tucson.  Since then, the population has grown to millions as people abandoned the rural areas looking for work.   This contributed greatly to the death toll in the recent earthquake. 

    Once again, in the interest of profit for transnational corps, the people the US as well as those in Haiti and Mexico pay the price. 

  • Ferraribubba

    Hey Lefty: I know that you’ve got those photos of WB leaving the grassy knoll in Daley Plaza on that NovemberFriday noon in Dallas in 1963. Why are you covering for that scum?
    And Haiti was the pearl of the Caribbean until WB took office wasn’t it.?Such a high standard of living, it was the envy of the world.
    Will he stop at nothing to further his rotten political agenda?
    Yer pal, Ferrari Bubba

    • leftfield

      FB – The WB I am referring to is the World Bank.  You might be thinking of Clinton?  He was certainly also a central player in the whole fiasco.  You’re wrong about the grassy knoll, though.  Recently enhanced photos of the shadowy figure leaving the grassy knoll show him to be a policeman wearing a “Sooo-eeee – Go Razorbacks” hat.

  • http://Gmail.com El Caballito

    Who cares what the Gov. does because one way or another illegal immigrants will cross the border. The Gov. should instead use the money that their wasting on the border were it’s needed. Also  I’m not saying that the Gov. should leave the border completely unprotected but should revert some of the resources being used there somewhere else.

  • Wingwalker

    Sorry Gringo Viejo:  The guy has the right information.  I probably know more about the Tucson Sector of the Mexican border than most.  I document and photograph it every day.  “The Federal Bureau of Land Management reports that Illegal Aliens drop 8#’s of trash per day.  The average IA who travels from either Nogales or Sasabe takes 3-4 days and usually arrives in this area on Thursdays.  Last year the BP apprehended 241,673 Illegal Aliens.  Since it takes usually 4 days that amounts to 7,733,536 pounds.  Just as a side….20% now apprehended are convicted criminals…no not traffic or DUI tickets but Murder, Rape and very often Child Molestation. (406 of those last year).   I personally found one layup sight that had 1,500 to 2,000 backpacks.  That doesn’t count the clothes and every item you can think of.  In reading some of these posting, I’ve found very very little of substance in the statements.  Lots of speculation but NO facts that would stand up.  The protection at the border is working.  In two years the recidivism rate has dropped from 78% to 18%…..and getting better.