Tucson Citizen.com
Medicare and More -

$1.2 Trillion wasted on Health Care Each Year

by on Mar. 06, 2010, under Health

According to a recent CNN report, for every dollar the nation spends on health care, 50 cents is wasted. Wasteful spending may account for as much as $1.2 trillion of the $2.2 trillion spent on health care in the United States each year. The medical waste includes costs associated with inefficient insurance claims processing, defensive medicine, preventable hospital readmissions, medical errors, and unnecessary emergency room visits, according to a 2008 report by Pricewaterhouse Cooper’s Health Research Institute.

Doctors are also to blame according to Dr. Howard Brody from Texas. His op-ed in the New England Journal of Medicine (January 28, 2010) referred to studies that show too many doctors order too many unnecessary or unhelpful tests and procedures. For example, one study of seniors who had arthroscopic knee surgery showed no real benefit from this costly but common procedure as compared to a control group who received physical therapy.

In a New York Times interview Dr. Brody said, “When you combine this love affair with high technology with a reimbursement system that pays so much more for technology — and less for thinking and sitting and talking with patients — you end up with an expensive kind of medicine, which, when practiced by doctors, puts more money into their pockets.”

The 2008 Medicare trustees’ report on projected revenues and spending, estimated that Medicare will be $660 billion in the hole by 2023 unless health care spending slows down. We must absolutely reduce the annual growth in per capita spending from 3.5% (the national average) to 2.4% (which has been accomplished in San Francisco).  A study showed that doctors in San Francisco order fewer tests and procedures than doctors in Florida and New York.

Copying the successful practices in San Francisco and putting them in place across the country would leave Medicare with a healthy estimated balance of $758 billion, a cumulative savings of $1.42 trillion, according to another study.

So, while insurance companies have been getting all the recent bad press, the problem in our health care system goes much deeper. We must address the overuse of hospitals and emergency rooms, the overuse of specialists, and too many tests and minor procedures.

What’s that I hear? It sounds like Tea Party crowds yelling, “They’re going to ration your healthcare!”


  • tiponeill

    But but but… we all know that the free market is the  most efficient thing in the world and big government like Canada’s can’t do anything right !!!!!!!
     

  • leftfield

    Does the waste figure include the thirty-some percent spent on administrative costs; higher than any of the “less-efficient, non-free market” countries?

  • Ferraribubba

    Back in the day, when we used to actually have use our own money to pay for the doctor, we went when we were sick. Not any more.
    Now people use the ER for a hangnail or a case of the sniffles. When I lived in the Old Pueblo, I had all the clasic symptoms of s heart attack, and went to the ER at TMC where I sat in the waiting room for 7 hours, while hords of people who had the above mentioned minor hurts went ahead of me. 
    Everybody from grandmas, grandpas, aunts, uncles, infants, teens, everybody in to get their taxpayer supported free check-ups and shots, or a band-aid. 
    Is this a great country or what?
    Yer pal, Ferrari Bubba

  • tiponeill

    Everybody from grandmas, grandpas, aunts, uncles, infants, teens, everybody in to get their taxpayer supported free check-ups and shots, or a band-aid.
    Doesn’t happen in Canada where those grandmas, grandpas, aunts, uncles, infants, teens, everybody can more easily go to a nearby clinic and get faster and friendlier free check-ups and shots, or a band-aid.

  • Mark A

    Billions of dollars are wasted on health care for seniors.  Medical care that doctors know will not increase their abilities to have a normal or reasonable lifestyle.   Much of the cost is spent on seniors.  That includes drugs, unnecessary operations, etc.  Doctors make millions are un needed medical care for seniors.  These are seniors where their quality of life will not improve with advance medical treatment.   

  • tiponeill

    These are seniors where their quality of life will not improve with advance medical treatment.
    Here in the US we refer to that as “pro-life” and, of course, anti-”Death Panel”.
    We will even stop Congress in its tracks and call the President back to Washington to pass laws attempting to overturn the Supreme Court so that we can administer worthless treatment against everyone’s will.
    It isn’t just MDs that profit – it is Repubs who profit in votes.

  • Jim Hunt

    And don’t forget that $2.5 Billion dollars a year is spent on Medicaid for illegal aliens.  I, as a US citizen, don’t qualify for that which we give to persons who are not.

     http://www.cis.org/articles/2004/fiscalexec.HTML

    • tiponeill

      And don’t forget that $2.5 Billion dollars a year is spent on Medicaid for illegal aliens.

      When all else fails, blame our problems on “illegal aliens” ;)

      • Jim Hunt

        It is all called waste!

    • leftfield

      If it’s so great being undocumented, you could cross over the border, leave your passport behind, cross fifty or so miles of desert and then head straight to the Medicaid office and sign up for all your free goodies. 

      Let me know how that works out for you.  I promise not to complain about you using all my tax dollars.

      • Jim Hunt

        I once was an illegal alien in SE Asia.  I overstayed my visa and was given 2 choices:
        1. Jail
        2. Take next flight out of the country.

        • medicareblogger

          The trillion dollars in waste cannot be attributed to illegal aliens.   Illegal immigration needs to be fixed by having a system where people can be documented and can pay taxes and can buy health insurance.

    • knid

      Let’s fix the trillion dollar issue before trying to fix the billion dollar issue.

    • easttxisfreaky@live.com

      Exactly. 

      Illegal aliens have more rights than Americans.

      They can walk into an E.R. and get medical care for free – but you and I can’t.  They jump into our housing projects, eat food stamps, get medical – and NOW are

            MARCHING on our capital demanding ThEIR rIGHTS.

      This is insanity.

      Mitchell needs to go.  I am so sorry that he is up there and decided to vote YES.

  • Ferraribubba

    You know, when Mark says that, \Billions of dollars are wasted on seniors. Medical care that doctors know will not increase their abilitities to have a resaonable or normal lifestyle, \ he just might be right! Adolf  Hitler had the very same idea. If you were a drag on society, you were of no use to it anymore. Fair enough, don’t you agree? Even our friendly neighbors from ‘The Great White North’ have adopted the same Nazi-type health care program. And they don’t even wear riding breeches, high boots, and goose-step around like the Uber-race did. Earlier this month, the Gauleiter (that’s Governor in the States)  of Nova Scotia-New Foundland had to come to the USA for his heart operation because he was too old at the age of 63 to qualify for a free one (or any one for that matter, under penalty of prison) in Canada. Let the old fool die, he’s past his prime anyway, ya, mein Fuhrer? Just wait ’til it comes to your house. Yer pal, Ferrari Bubba

    • knid

      This post is partly false and partly misleading.  The Premier was not turned down due to age, nor was he turned down at all.  He would have been placed on a waiting list (which would be similar to the average person in the U.S.).
      If you have an extra $50k lying around in spare cash plus a condo waiting for you in another state in order to rest for the next several weeks to recover, you’re probably in the minority.
      It’s amusing that anti-healthcare trolls use Reducio ad Hitlerum to make their point.

    • easttxisfreaky@live.com

      I watched every minute of the Rules Committee Meeting on CNN Saturday – the day before the vote.

      It was evident that our elderly are being sacrificed for the young, the illegal, the immigrants, the poor.

      Our elderly are being sacrificed for this Progressive Party – agenda. 

      VOTE OUR MITCHELL!  CALL HIM BEFORE SUNDAY’S VOTE.

      MAKE A BELIEVER OUT OF HIM

      • knid

        From your tone, I would suspect you didn’t vote for Mitchell in the first place.  You wouldn’t vote for him even if he voted ‘no’ on the healthcare bill.  This makes you an irrelevant and shrill voice in this discussion.  Begone troll.

  • Pingback: texashealthinsurance.pro