Tucson Citizen.com

Education is Ground Zero In Arizona’s Immigration Battles

by on Aug. 18, 2010, under Uncategorized

Jacquelyn Jackson

Jacquelyn Jackson

by Jacquelyn Jackson

The forum that featured four candidates in the race for State School Superintendent of Public Instruction Aug. 11 was a microcosm of the highly charged emotions in the national immigration battle where Arizona is on the frontlines.  But instead of merely providing fodder for political rhetoric and punch lines for late-night television, the forum made obvious that our schools, kids and teachers are the real victims in this highly toxic debate.

As the head of Tucson Values Teachers, I had a stage-level seat in the Little Theater at Rincon High where I shared the job of vetting the many written questions from the audience, deciding which ones should be passed along to moderator Jim Nintzel of the Tucson Weekly.

I was impressed with the range of issues raised by audience members.  They wanted to know where the candidates stood on early childhood education, adult education, special needs students, the role of charter schools, funding levels for our schools and the fate of AIMS testing. But clearly, the highest percentage of questions focused on La Raza studies at Tucson Unified School District. In that Little Theater, where Secure the Border advocates anchored one side of the room and First Amendment shouters held court on the other,  debate on the broader issues facing our educational system were, quite literally, drowned out.

While the debate was forced to end early due to the high levels of emotion in the room, there were no physical encounters.  However, it was obvious that our schools have become both battleground, and pawns, in this highly politicized debate. This is a reality that is bad for our region, our kids, and our long-term future and economic viability.

When did education become such a polarized political issue, and why can’t we turn down the volume and realize that our kids are literally being sacrificed on the altar of inflamed political rhetoric. Further, the underlying subtext of racism that played out Thursday night is a topic that needs to be faced head on if we really want to find solutions that build, not destroy, our collective future.

In a country where the Hispanic resident population increased 52% from 2000 – 2008, and where Hispanics in Arizona are the fastest growing segment of the population, it would seem that a wiser course of action would be to plan for this new reality. In just over one more generation, Hispanics, not Caucasians, will be the majority population, and today’s anger and vitriol is nothing more than a head-in-the sand reaction.

We are all avoiding the planning and preparation required for this major demographic shift. We need to be wiser, and prepare for this inevitable new reality.  We must bury our anger, tone down vitriolic language, roll up our sleeves and make sure, just as our Founding Fathers did, that the highest quality education for all, not denial, is our top priority.

Children, whatever their ethnicity, are the future of our state, and in Arizona, especially, we should be doing everything possible to ensure quality education. We must reduce the very high drop-out rate among Hispanics. We should encourage Hispanic kids to know their history and work together to weave that history into what will be the new fabric of existence in our nation and state.

When I left the building Thursday night, one of the young Hispanic men – 20-something, starkly handsome and shimmering with anger – caught my eye. As he shouted for First Amendment rights, I wanted to sit down with him, know more about who he was and what he believed, and then work with him to find common ground.

This young man is the future of Arizona.  His children will enter adulthood as the new majority in our State.  We need to accept and prepare for this new reality, which is not very far down the road. We need to become a state where his child will be able to respect and understand his roots and get the best possible education, which has forever been the path toward the high-paying jobs and diverse economy that must be the future of this state.

The changing demographics of Arizona are inevitable. It is in our hands today to lay the groundwork, to assure quality education for all, to create a future for our state of growth, cultural richness, and economic stability.  Today’s politicians need to be the stewards of this strong future – they need to lead with wisdom, intelligence and open hearts.

We must all put down the banners, tone down the harsh words, shake hands, and sit down at tables all around this state, working together, calmly and intelligently. Together, we must create today the strong future for the Arizona of tomorrow.

Jacquelyn Jackson is an educational advocate in Tucson.  She moved to Tucson seven years ago from Washington, D.C. where she was the chief lobbyist for the Times Mirror Company.



  • fraser007

    “New reality”. Thats what it’s all about. Loved the way you slipped that in. Who told you to write this article? Marching orders from the left? Open borders, pro-illegal alien muddle headed thinking.
    This “new reality” you speak of will destroy the United States. Wow, I want to be just like Mexico too! What crap.
    We will be watching for your future articles.

    • erniemccray

      Why does a “new reality” have to be synonymous with destroying the United States? Why can’t it, as suggested, be used to inspire people to sit down and create something positive for all concerned. And, as an educator, I come alive just thinking about all the rich learning experiences that would be available to me and students, the poetry and prose we could write together and the movement we could choreograph to tell stories of overcoming, the dramas we could improvise and polish to illustrate what we’re learning and what remains to be learned. “Teachable moments” are in the very air we breathe in our world. There has never been a time in the history of humankind more rife with opportunities for humans to learn about each other and appreciate the power we have to make our world just a little better, one individual at a time. The children are ready. It’s us, the adults, who are lagging – big time.
      Thank you, Jacquelyn, for exposing the diamonds in the rough, for finding what could be extremely positive in the midst of a kind of negativity that literally dampens notions of hope. Teach, my sister. You reflect the kind of thinking that can help us shine as a people. You’ve touched my soul deeply through the stand you’ve taken for the children, our future. Lately, I haven’t seen anywhere near enough of such from my hometown, my home state. You make this old dude sing out loud: I’m a Sonoran and I’m proud!

  • tiponeill

    Welcome to Arizona/Alabama…
    It’s sort of like moving to Birmingham in the 60′s – the schools are always dragged into socaila change.

  • fraser007

    Guess you are looking forward to millions of illegals in the USA. I am not. Countries/civilizations gain sometimes by the cross pollenation between civilizations. Sometimes that is done by violence sometimes not. Or by invasions. England for instance. Celtic/Saxon/Norman etc. The Japan has not experienced that. China not often, just the Mongols once but they asorbed them.
    …….We gain nothing from the invasion from mexico. Just look at them …do you want to be like them? I am terrified by a United States that looks even a little like that cesspool. Drugs, violence, corruption should I go on.

    • Lois C

      I am Hispanic and was born here to parents of parents all citizens . And my heritage of being American citizens goes back further than that. So being a citizen I feel I can speak freely!  The problem really isn’t the illegal immigrants coming here in droves. The problem is that you are racist and don,t like Mexicans.Why else would you keep mentioning Mexico. And I’m sorry but the cesspool of drugs,violence and corruption started the first day the English settlers landed on our eastern shores to drop off their criminal element and unwanted citizens here in their prison colonies. Also there is plenty of that here already and it Is not inherently a Hispanic problem., or not even a Mexican problem. Just today I read a report that said that Asians are the group with the most people that stay here illegally. So get your facts straight before you post.Also your statement..…….We gain nothing from the invasion from mexico. Just look at them …do you want to be like them? Actually there is nothing wrong with being “LIKE THEM”. I could choose worse and decide to be like you, close minded and self-righteous. I could choose to hate people that say these terrible things and I could choose to be a bigot and judge your whole race by your words, but I choose NOT to because it is NOT the right thing to do.I choose to follow a different road. Why don’t you. All this blaming Mexicans for this countries ills is getting old.

      • erniemccray

        Say it, Hermana.

      • Tucsonsonlywhiteson

        Please tell us what  report you read that stated “Asians are the group with the most people that stay here illegally”. 

        I believe you are ignoratnt, first becase you bring racism into the argument, 2nd you to not quote facts you lie about so called articles you read.

  • Jonathan DuHamel

    Should not the parents and grandparents be the principal teachers of cultural tradition and history?

    • erniemccray

      That would be ideal if done accurately and in a way that would be relevant to their children’s understanding of the world. But what, say, would fraser 007 teach his children about cultural tradition and history? That a country near us is a cesspool that offers the world only violence, corruption… should I go on?

    • tiponeill

      If parents would be the principal teachers of everything, there would be no need for schools at all.
      Most parents don’t have the time, or education, and aren’t equipped for the job – which is why we have schools

      • Tucsonsonlywhiteson

        Parents do not have time because they are taxed too much.  A small amount of these unwise taxes is  to fund estupido projects that la raza wants to teach in school.  La Raza = La Racist

        • Dusty

          The book of Enoch .. seventh from Adam .. banned by Nicene Council 1200′s .. says that the names of the children of the fallen angels will contain a code .. “aza.” It also says that they can not look up when they pray! Who does that remind you of?

    • leftfield

      For better or worse, they have primary influence on a child’s education (or lack thereof) in all manner of subjects.  But, for better or worse, the media, peer groups, one’s environment; also have influence, as well as educators.  This is not to say that a child should not be exposed to a variety of cultures and traditions while growing up because of the parents prejudices.   And none of this means that a child’s parents do or should have carte blanche.  In an environment where abuse is part of the family tradition, the public has a legitimate interest and steps in (or should).  

      Now, having said this, be aware that folks of the same philosophy as those always crying about protecting their children from secular and liberal influence are also the ones who didn’t seem to feel that applied in the case of non-christian peoples or Native American children.  In those cases, they felt absolutely obligated to take those children away from the influence of their family.  So, one has to be wary about those folks, because what they are really interested in (in many cases), is not protection of the children, but controlling the children.  

  • fraser007

    And how is thinking that the invasion of millions of illegals into the USA is “social change”?? That is pretty much warped thinking.
    Blacks are American 1000%, they are us, our culture, our values, they serve in our miltary (with my son), the people who oppressed them in Alabama in the 1960′s were sick, poor excuses for human beings.
    My views are based on history and military history. What are yours?

    • tiponeill

      And how is thinking that the invasion of millions of illegals into the USA is “social change”?? That is pretty much warped thinking
      “warped thinking” would be thinking that an increase in the Hispanic population was an “invasion”.

      • erniemccray

        Amen! “Invasion.” Wow!

  • pogo

    I don’t know why Jacquelyn Jackson was surprised by the racist tone of this meeting. After all racism is as American as apple pie and motherhood.

  • Human

    Fraser, you do not fool anyone with your racist statements.  A racist is a racist!  Just a tip, African Americans are to smart to fall for your rants. They know that  every racist hates every race that is not his.  Today it’s Illegal immigrants\brown people\ tomorrow black and yellow.And if your views are based in the military you would be for illegal immigration! Since thousands of illegals are serving in our military with the promise they will get citizenship. Which most of the time it never happens. So guess what they die for racist like you. So when you talk, make sure you know what you are talking about.

    • erniemccray

      Right on, Human. Teach. I know of “illegals” of which you speak.

  • fraser007

    To Lois: You must be thinking about Australia where England dumped its criminals. Go read a history book. I like Mexicans. I like the legal ones. NO nation in the world would allow the influx of 12 million or more like that. Check into the history of mexico. The Aztec generals who worked for Montezuma told him to kill the Spanish who showed up at Vera Cruz in 1519. He was a weak leader, he thought they were gods. The generals knew what would happen. And it did. I say build more fences. Is that racist. I dont think so. Where does it say that we have to allow everybody who wants to come here? I didnt read that anywhere.
    I am sure that there are some Asians who have immigrated illegally. But I haven’t seen them on the evening news lately shooting people? Have you? When was the last time you saw Chinese gangs shoot up a nightclub or operate a drop house or haul meth into the USA. I am waiting for your answer. Lots of violent crime here in Tucson. Guess the Chinese are doing that.

    Erniemcray: You sound like an educator. Sure glad you didnt teach my kids.

    • erniemccray

      Frazer, teaching kids has been the joy of my life. One of my fondest identities. And, I don’t know what you expected of teachers who taught your kids but – and I don’t want this to come across as bragging – but based on my experiences with families with whom I’ve worked over the years, I would say that you would have been thrilled that I taught your kids. I made learning challenging and fun; kids had  ownership of the classroom, wanted to be there. I love learning and it came across to kids and their moms and dads.
      I’m sharing this with you to just get you to possibly look at things in a different way. There are rewards in life when one approaches it with an open mind, with compassion for others. One of the most rewarding experiences I’ve ever had as an educator was a few years ago a little before I retired. I was principal of a school that was falling apart before I got there and I managed to get it going in a good direction by helping people see that they really had something to offer and then getting out of their way – somewhat- so they could fly. A man who had been a student in my first class ever drove his granddaughter from across town everyday just so she could be at a school where I was, based on his love for what he experienced being in my class. The first thing he said to me on the first day of school was: “Can you still dunk?” He kept memories alive of me, one day in P.E., capturing a missed shot by one of his classmates and doing a reverse 360 slam. The whole class went :”Wow!” There’s nothing more gratifying than getting your students to go “Wow!” whether it’s from dunking a basketball or turning them on to the magic of numbers and words and social concepts.
      Hey, I wish I could have had you as a student because I’ve dealt with “fences,” so to speak, as a human being, as a black man, and there are a number of ways at looking at “fences” in all its meanings.

      • leftfield

        Always good to hear from you, Ernie.  I’m happy that you found teaching as rewarding as you did; happy for your students and happy for you.  It’s an honorable thing to do with your life.  Too bad as a society we don’t give out the material rewards teaching deserves to go along with the spirtiual rewards.

      • Tucsonsonlywhiteson

        Nobody cares about you.  You were just another liberal teacher, a dime a dozen.  I bet you were even fired for “in-appropriate” behavior with small male children.  LaRaza=LaRapist

    • leftfield

      Sure glad you didnt teach my kids.

      OMG – he has children!  Sadly, we don’t get to choose our families.

  • fraser007

    It’s not a color thing. I am not a rascist. I just wish we didnt have 12 million illegal mexicans here. The local mexicans who are here legally have crime rates that are far, far higher than the general population. That is a fact. They have the benefit of being here and enjoying the fruits of this country. Am I wrong. Watch the news tonight.
    When I stop at the local Circle K  it is run by a Sikh and his workers are from Nepal, all of them. (The Nepalese are the Gurkhas from British fame.) They speak English, are hard working, dont create crime, do not take welfare and if the economy got tough they would not leave and go back to their villages. They will stay and gut it out. Just like my relatives did and yours. The illegals view this country as a big job market inhabited by a bunch of evil white people. Liberals like the posters above would just love to have them here do they will all vote for democratic canidates. There goes the two party system. I say bring us more Nepalese and Indians.
    Is mexico a cesspool. Yes. There is a war going on there, yes. It is here in Arizona and coming to a neighborhood close to you.

  • leftfield

    The local mexicans who are here legally have crime rates that are far, far higher than the general population. That is a fact.

    If this is “a fact”, I have two questions: what evidence do you offer to support this contention and, if this is in fact true, why do you think this is?  Here’s where it gets real sticky, fraser.  Are you going to say (in so many words) that there is something about being born on one side of a geopolitical line in the desert that makes people inherently violent and/or larcenous?  Because you clearly can’t say it’s in their genes.  That would tend to refute your denials of bias. 

  • fraser007

    For years I tracked the crime stats that were posted in the Arizona Daily Star. Or should I say convictions. Hispanic surnames totalled over 55% of those convicted. Hispanics number about 35% of this valleys population. Their birth rate numbers over 50% of the births in local hospitals.
    Just watch the news tonight. When the crime stories appear what faces will you see.

    • erniemccray

      Let’s say every crime story features Latinos, okay, then what? What does that mean? What does that justify? It’s then all right to denigrate Latinos as a whole, even those who are good citizens, those who contribute much that is positive to our society? We give up on getting to the root of societal problems and trying to solve them?

    • leftfield

      Their birth rate numbers over 50% of the births in local hospitals.

      Fear of a brown nation keeping you up at night, fraser? 

  • fraser007

    Maybe its time for them to step up to plate and not commit crime.

  • Hoosier Woman

    Lois C —I doubt very highly that any study would indicate that there are more Asian illegal immigrants than Hispanic illegal immigrants in Arizona! Get your fact straight! I guess your going to say that Arizona is closer to Asia, than Mexico next! UGH ! The stupidity of some! And don’t bother to call me a racist either! I have a son who was born in Tucson AZ and his father was Hispanic and was born in Tucson AZ and his parents were LEGAL immigrants, so since I have loved and born a child with a Hispanic man (and my son is half Hispanic) then obviously I don’t hate Hispanics! But the fact is there are WAY too many illegal Hispanics in Arizona and the U.S.! And we are getting sick of it!I have lived over half my life in Arizona but now live in Indiana to get away from the HUGE influx of illegals in Arizona. Here in Indiana I have worked with ASIAN immigrants and I can tell you that they DO keep their visa’s up to date and don’t overstay them!They don’t get public assistance and have babies and get free health care just to have their children be legal U.S. citizens. They work in meat packing plants or doing nails to get the hundreds of dollars to pay the fees to keep their visas legal. I have worked with several Asian immigrants and just last November one woman who was in the U.S.on a two year visa just got her 10 year visa and wants to study and get her U.S. citizenship. The Asian’s do it legally, unlike the Hispanic illegals who know that they can just run across the border and come over again later!
    Now on the topic of education and race. I don’t have a problem with ethnic studies classes….the problem is when one race in the classroom says that they are better than another race! OR when a teacher of one race starts teaching that their race is better! If there is no way to teach ethnic studies without raising one race above another then YES GET RID OF ETHNIC STUDIES classes!!!! Its racism that our kids don”t need to be learning or being exposed to! If ethnic EQUALITY cant be taught in an ethnic studies class then it shouldn’t be taught!

    • leftfield

       I don’t have a problem with ethnic studies classes….the problem is when one race in the classroom says that they are better than another race!

      Well, you must quite a bone to pick with American education in general, since the education system essentially teaches that white, northern european history, values and culture are worth knowing. 

      Remember, absent ethnic studies programs, every day is “white studies” day in American schools.

  • fraser007

    Watch the news lately? Lots of Canadians and North Dakota farmers and Chinese causing crime? Every story this week has been what I said it was.

  • fraser007

    And yes I am afraid of a brown nation. We have one south of us. Thats enough. And yes I sleep well.

  • http://thechollajumps.com Jim Kelley

     In just over one more generation, Hispanics, not Caucasians, will be the majority population, and today’s anger and vitriol is nothing more than a head-in-the sand reaction.

    1. Hispanics are caucasion.
    2. La Raza is at it’s very core a “racist” approach to historical teaching.
    3. Claiming majority does not make your argument. The immorality of teaching a skewed sociopathic victomology is exactly how Palestine, Northern Ireland, Bosina-Hercgovina, Azerbajan, Kosovo all started their civil wars.
    You ae right, it is the children that are suffering. Theya re being held hostage by a progressive leftist agenda that puts a gun to the kids head and tells parents “Pay Up OR The Kid Gets It.”  You are demanding that our community accept YOUR skewed history or you will punish the whole of the district.
    Big Education and Big Labor ar acting like gangsters in Chicago.