Tucson Citizen.com
Three Sonorans - Progressive and activist news in Tucson and Arizona

MAS student responds to KGUN9 complaints about no media allowed to their event

by on Jan. 26, 2012, under Headline news

The local TV news just doesn’t understand what they are covering.

Behind bars or in "revolutionary garb."

They like to repeat the same words that Tom Horne uses, for example when a person wears brown khakis and a beret, they are wearing “revolutionary garb.”

Yet how many times do the media refer to Junior ROTC high school students are dressed up as soldiers, as killing machines, as those ready to take orders to kill even if that means overthrowing a democratically elected leader in Latin America.

It’s all a matter of perception, and Chicano students are usually given the negative light even though what they are fighting for is education, books, and their classes.

I guess when Arizona is ranked last in education, fighting for education is a truly revolutionary concept, especially when it is our rulers attacking education, thus to fight for education is to revolt against Arizona government?

At this week’s School of Ethnic Studies, the media was shut out.

KGUN9 is complaining about this, and has been getting lots of comments in regard to this.

So to respond to their complaints and why Chicano students don’t trust the local media I include a recent clip of a MAS student who spoke to KGUN9 about why MAS should not be banned, and then how the ABC affiliate cut out most of what was said and only used a part that had nothing to do with the defense of the classes.

You can see that for yourself in the video above.

As for bias in the local media, consider this. How many negative editorials has the Arizona Daily Star written about TUSD superintendent and former Vice-President of SALC, Tucson’s club for the 1%, John Pedicone?

I do not think they have ever written anything negative about Pedicone, ever.

Media bias is huge in Tucson. The only coverage of the book ban was to defend TUSD’s position that books were not banned, only boxed up and not allowed in the classroom, and even with this Orwellian response, the local media lacked the critical thinking skills to follow-up with easy questions; “How is this NOT a book ban?” — “Will the teachers get in trouble if they teach out of these books?” etc…

The whole nation is watching Tucson right now, and in particular TUSD.


  • http://kgun9.com Forrest Carr

    Dear Three Sonorans:
    First of all, stating that the media were shut out of the event does not constitute a “complaint.”  It’s a statement of fact, one that we found newsworthy.  If you don’t understand why the fact that protest organizers, after enticing kids to leave class, were then able to herd them behind closed doors and address them privately on a politically charged subject is newsworthy — well, you’re welcome to that opinion.   But I note that this was not a private club meeting on the weekend.  It was an event taking place at a time when the kids were supposed to be in school. 
    The student in your web interview complains that his entire KGUN9 interview didn’t make it on to TV.  We interview several people for each TV story.  If you don’t understand why each entire interview can’t fit into a two minute TV news report, I can’t help you.  As to the student’s other points — outrage over the books being pulled has been well reported on KGUN9 News, as have the statistics about graduation rates, academic achievement and so on.  
    You complain that we compared the brown berets and khakis worn by some of the protestors to garb worn by some revolutionaries.  If you really think that there is no such connection, your article was the place to make that point.  I note that you did not do so, however.  
    The conversation continues, including comments about our coverage.  You and anyone else who’d like to do so is welcome to join it on KGUN9.com or on our Facebook page.
    Forrest Carr, KGUN9 News Director

  • Gail Shoultes

    These students are the kind of critical thinkers we need to run this state in the future. To try and make them believe they dropped out of the sky and have no history is beyond comprehension.

  • http://none JimBodkins

    DA, please follow up on this if you would …

    http://www.readersupportednews.org/opinion2/275-42/9628-arizona-shuts-mexican-studies-classes 

    … I think facts from here need to be communicated – possibly by links to your blog. Also, they need to understand that while this is a conservative state – some of the comments made about ‘Tucson’ dont really identify the true culprits in this drama. We know who they are. Most outside Arizona dont.

    Thanks