The battle is on: El Guero Canelo vs BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs
by Elizabeth "Bjay" Woolley on Jan. 22, 2010, under food/recipes, Life, local fun, mex food, Tucson
Sonoran hot dog
The arena is ready! The challengers have been chosen!
(Cue drum roll)
In one corner is El Guero Canelo. The cinnamon blonde is ready and snapping his tongs.
In the other is BK Carne Asada and Hots Dogs, wielding a mesquite log. He whispers something in Spanish to his sister and translator outside the ring. She yells, “Bring it on!”
The fans go wild!
These two establishments are very similar. They both have 12th Avenue restaurants on the south side that appear to have sprouted around humble hot-dog carts. Each opened second restaurants on the north side about the same time. Both serve Sonoran dogs. You would think a Sonoran dog is a Sonoran dog. However, many Tucsonans seem to have very strong opinions that one is better than the other.
And so, these restaurants have been in an epic hot dog battle since the early 90′s. Tucson print and electronic publications usually list these as the top two, and they often take turns in the #1 spot year to year.
So, the debate may be settled once and for all next weekend when the Travel Channel comes to town to shoot an episode for a new series that will be visiting towns across the country and featuring their iconic food dishes. The show will be a companion to their popular Man V Food series and will air in the spring. They will pit food establishments against each other, interview fans, and choose Superfans.
So if you are one of those Tucsonans with a strong opinion in the Sonoran dog debate and consider yourself a big fan of either establishment, you are welcome to attend the shoot of your favorite (show your love), and have a chance to be crowned a Superfan.
They will be shooting at their 12th avenue locations:
January 28th (Thursday): BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs
January 29th (Friday): El Guero Canelo
January 30th (Saturday): Both restaurants.
Exact times have yet to be announced but will be early afternoon or evening. I will update this post with the times if I hear more.
If you think you qualify as a Superfan for either restaurant, email FoodFanCasting@gmail.com and let them know about your love.




January 22nd, 2010 on 1:20 pm
I’ve been to both, eaten both their Sonoran dogs many times and I just can’t decide which one I like best. In the interest of science, the honor of the Sonoran Hot Dog and our fair city, I feel I must accept the duty of going out and eating some more today.
January 22nd, 2010 on 1:53 pm
Leftfield, on behalf of Tucsonans everywhere, I recognize the hardship and sacrifice you are about to make for us. God speed and may your journey be fruitful.
January 22nd, 2010 on 2:55 pm
I’m jealous leftfield. I’ve never tried a sonoran hotdog. I need to get with the times. lol
January 22nd, 2010 on 7:56 pm
Guero canelo is the best! I’ve tasted the B.K. hotdog, not as good as guero, but may the best man win. Good Luck Men!
December 28th, 2010 on 7:52 am
Keep it coming, I want to see some real opinions onthis
December 28th, 2010 on 10:28 am
Meh…
I’ve tried and enjoyed Guero Canelos and I will go back for more, but after seeing that BK place involved in the scripted hit piece on Az I am going to have to pass on giving them a try.
So Guero Canelos for me
December 28th, 2010 on 11:45 am
Nene’s, on Wetmore, would never do such a thing as did BK; and their dogs are mucho gusto!!!
Gringa Teresita
June 14th, 2011 on 1:41 am
Perros Locos has the craziest dog, and that’s no joke! The classic piled-high Sonoran, but on a fresh fried bun- BK’s and Guero Canelo’s dogs are just as good, but the Sonoran dog needs the right setting, and the classic white bread bun just doesn’t measure up to the fillings. My money’s on this recipe!
August 31st, 2011 on 7:10 pm
Depends on what kind of environment you prefer.
Guero Canelo — hits home base! Feels like home.
Bk’s is alright, been there more than once. Definitely more of a sit down place.
I vote GC’s
November 19th, 2011 on 9:35 pm
The best place to eat hot dogs is “El perro loco”, the service is so nice, they are so kind and CLEAN. i’ve heard that in “Guero Canelo” found flies and coackroach on the hot dogs eewk…..!