Tucson Citizen.com

Rich Rodriguez: About those NCAA violations…

by on Nov. 23, 2011, under Sports
Rich Rodriguez introduced at Arizona

Does Rich Rodriguez’s past leave you smiling?
Photo by Rob Schumacher/The Arizona Republic

The University of Arizona has its new head football coach in Richard A. Rodriguez. Is Rich Rod the long awaited answer for the Zona Cats?

The response from the national media has been positive but the majority of the fan base was surprised. You’re not going to hire everybody’s first choice in any coaching search but many thought the same reasons that made former Texas Tech coach Mike Leach an unlikely candidate would also eliminate Rodriguez from serious consideration.

Those reasons? Stuff like getting fired, a lawsuit, player discontent, and those pesky NCAA violations.

The violations took place during both of Rodriguez’s high-profile jobs and can’t be ignored. You can read about what happened at West Virginia here and here. The Michigan summary is here and the full NCAA report is here.

Are they not that bad? There was nothing involving money to players or academic fraud. Can you live with them? Greg Byrne decided he could and the Rich Rod era is under way.

Now the bottom line is – as with any coaching hire – can he win football games at Arizona?

I look at it the same way I considered Leach. If Rodriguez was still at West Virginia he would be in the “tremendous hire but no chance he comes to Arizona” group. Alabama found out the same thing at the time.

When you look at the Michigan fiasco you certainly see the culture clash and can understand why generations of Wolverine fans would revolt after witnessing losing seasons for the first time in decades. But this wasn’t a John Mackovic situation where a guy followed up each season with a new low. Michigan’s record went from 3-9 to 5-7 to 7-6 in Rodriguez’s three years and his players (including the mesmerizing Denard Robinson) are 9-2 in Brady Hoke‘s first season.

If you’re going to gamble with a baggage-bearing coach you have to turn him loose (within the rules of course). Let Rodriguez hire his staff even if that means all the current coaches go elsewhere. If he wants to run a 3-3-5 defense – or a 2-2-7, or even a 1-10 – give him the budget to hire a coordinator who can run that defense. If he needs to cycle through the roster to get his type of players in place, give him the time to do so.

The big advantage to hiring an experienced head coach is he has a clear plan. For Rodriguez it’s not a matter of finding his way as the general of a program. Now it’s a matter of finding the officers and troops who can do what he wants and how he wants it. And then we wait and see (and hope) what he wants to do ends up being what he can do and that it works in the Pac-12.

I just happen to be in Michigan right now and the Wolverine fans have enjoyed giving me grief since the news broke. We’ll see who’s grieving the next time I pay a visit.

* * *

Quick, who has the third-best overall record among bowl eligible Pac-12 teams?

Surprise, surprise, it’s Utah at 7-4. Washington and ASU have lost a combined six straight while the Utes have won four in a row. As a result the adjusted Pac-12 bowl bubble looks like this:

Pac-12 bowl bubble

What is IUTLCG? I had to create a new tier for UCLA and ASU because, while they’re bowl eligible now, either one could make the Pac-12 Championship Game with a 6-6 record and if they lost that they’d be 6-7 and not qualified for a bowl. In other words they could lose their way out of a bowl by winning the division. Therefore, the Bruins and Devils are currently In Unless They Lose Championship Game.

Transitioning to the hot seat, the big plus in Arizona hiring Rodriguez this week is the Cats got their man before any other Pac-12 job opened up. So UA fans are less concerned about which other coaches stay or go unless they really like the mediocre job a coach is doing for a rival school.

Team Remaining Wins Record Upset?
ASU Cal 7-5 at Ore
UCLA none 6-6 Done.
Cal none 6-6 at ASU
WSU none 4-8 Done.
OSU none 3-9 Done.

I think Mike Riley and Paul Wulff will be back for OSU and WSU. Cal put up a good fight against Stanford and unless the Bears get annihilated by ASU I believe Jeff Tedford will at least get a shot in the bowl game.

The two coaches in the most trouble are Arizona State’s Dennis Erickson and UCLA’s Rick Neuheisel. I don’t think they both can survive at this point. I expect whoever doesn’t win the Pac-12 South will be fired after this weekend. The “winner” of the South may still get canned.

So if you like to see ASU and UCLA stumbling around root for both schools to get a win to end the regular season.

* * *

Nick Foles put up a monster game against ASU putting him within striking distance of most of the Pac-12 records we’ve been tracking. Of course, he can’t break any records if he doesn’t play but here’s where he stands and what exactly he needs in the final game to hit each mark:

Pac-12 Records Who, When What Nick Foles, 2011 Needs
Total Offense Cody Pickett, Wash, 2002 4,273 4,228 (pace) 398
Total Offense per Game Ryan Leaf, WSU, 1997 325.7 352.4 34
Passing Yards Cody Pickett, Wash, 2002 4,458 4,344 (pace) 476
Passing Yards per Game Cody Pickett, Wash, 2002 342.9 362.0 134
Completions Willie Tuitama, Ariz, 2007 327 354 -
Completion Percentage Rich Campbell, Cal, 1980 70.7 68.5 a lot
Completion %, Career Matt Leinart, USC, 2002-05 64.8 66.5 not much

Bonus stat: Foles needs 341 passing yards to get to 10,000 for his Arizona career.

Another 10,000 reasons to buy a cheap ticket and say goodbye in person on Saturday.

- – - – -

Scott Terrell hopes his violations aren’t that bad. Consider sanctions on Twitter and Facebook.



  • wildcatfight83

    Very happy I get to root against ASU this weekend.  Though, I’m still hoping that ASU ends up keeping Erickson.  He’s been good for Wildcat Universe.  I do think the ASU situation is much more complicated that Arizona’s was.  ASU is looking at needing to fire both their football coach, their basketball coach and their AD (I don’t know how you can keep an AD whose main coaching hires had to be let go).  The media deal should help them with cash flow, but that’s a lot of money and major changes at leadership.  

    My guess is that they end up not firing one of the coaches and maybe keeping the AD.  Erickson might be saved by ASU basketball is so pitiful.  

    Tedford is pretty safe too.  Cal wasn’t smart enough to put a buyout in his contract.  If they fire him they still owe him something like $10 million.  Cal is not a school that can take a hit like that….
    —-
    What do you think that RichRod’s timetable is here? I think he’s actually set up for a nice season next year.  He has a read-option capable QB in Scott, a helluva RB in Carey, really solid WRs to prevent teams from selling out to stop the run.  On defense we will still be a bit shallow up front, but if he wants to run a 3-3-5 we already have the DBs for that.  Personnel-wise, I don’t think the transition will be that great.

    Unreasonable to expect us to contend next year, but 8 wins?   I think that’s possible.  Maybe to the point of being expected.  Not to say I don’t think that he should be given time…. just that he should have an easier transition than he did at Michigan.  A dip later might be expected since this recruiting class is probably not gonna be stellar.

    Any thoughts on who on the staff might get to stick?  I’m hoping against logic that Kish gets offered a positional coaching gig (or even special teams) and accepts the demotion.  He’s been a good Wildcat.  Probably not happening though.  Scelfo has probably also earned his keep.   

    • http://uasports.net Scott Terrell

      I agree with your forecast for the next couple seasons.  Next year looks really good for everything you say plus the eight home games.  Then there might be a dip during the transition from Stoops’ system/players to Rodriguez’s.
      If any assistants are retrained I think Scelfo should be at the top of the list.  He’s got a good relationship with Matt Scott already and he coached with Rodriguez at Tulane.  My guess is Rich Rod starts completely over on the defensive side of the ball.

  • JK

    He’s going to sell tickets for the next few years…I can’t wait to see how different the wildcat offense will be next year.

  • UM Class of ’81

    I’m a born and bred, died in the wool Michigan alum-football fan. The reason some – some – of the fanbase revolted against him was that he stepped into a mess, with the alumni high court and the U-M Athletic Department divided three or more ways on the direction that the program should take in the wake of Bo Schembechler’s death in 2006. There is plenty of evidence that the very reason that the overblown charges of violations leveled against the program by the Detroit Free Press (“Stretchgate”) was because those very writers had it out for Coach Rodriguez from the beginning. Lawsuit? Please! Michigan agreed to pay, but then left Rodriguez to swim in the wake of bad press, not allowing him to even comment on what was going on. It was one thing after another.
    Coach Rod made mistakes. I doubt that he will ever overlook the defensive side of the ball again, at least the need to get a good coordinator in position. Perhaps he will also be able to let that coordinator run a system at which the DC is proficient. I also doubt that he will allow any employer to fumble the ball the way my alma mater did on some many PR-related matters.
    Arizona got themselves a very good head coach. I wish him nothing but the best, and look forward to following the team’s progress.
    Just hope that they don’t have to play Michigan anytime soon!

    • UM Class of ’88

      I agree with UM ’81 wholeheartedly.  Coach Rod was undermined by the previous coaching staff (who committed the same practice violations if you read “Three and Out.”) and those in the AD aligned to them.  Furthermore, the plethora of career-ending injuries on the defensive side of the ball before he got there plus transfers  contributed to the team’s poor defensive performance.  Did Coach Rod make some mistakes, yes (he should have demanded the money for a top-flight coordinator, U of M limited his budget in that area) but considering that he was boating upstream the whole time at UofM, he did the best he could under the circumstances.
      As an alumnus of Michigan, I was sickened by Coach Rod’s treatment by the University Administration and the Detroit lap-dog media.
      I am a critical person by nature but, I believe that you hired a great head coach (look at the play of his WVU teams with so-called 3-star talent).  I wouldn’t be surprised to see Arizona in a Rose Bowl before Michigan.

  • rblyel58211

    get used to the qb draw… its his best play…. and fyi, hes really over-rated.. he never won anything till va-tech, miami and bost college left the big east.. he was a loser until then…. he shd kiss pat whites butt everyday thanking him for making him look good

  • DHaupt

    Actually, he won his first Big East championship in 2003, sharing the title with Miami (who he lost to 22-20) and beating Boston College (who was also still in the Big East), and won his second before Pat White arrived in Morgantown.  By the way, what’s Pat White doing these days?  Because based on what has happened since he left college, I think it’s safe to say Rich Rodriguez made Pat White.

    Regardless, he dominated the Big East for half a decade and his teams beat an SEC champ and a Big 12 champ in BCS bowl games. 

    He will make Arizona football more relevant than they have ever been.

  • Jim Keyes

    “I have something to prove”   RR – that says it all.. fire in the belly is the best motivator… he will make UA both a BB and Football school…. kind of like UW and Texas