Send in the US Cavalry
by Hugh Holub on May. 27, 2010, under border issues, politics, SB 1070
Things are tense in cowboy country.
Once you get outside the urban area Tucson is surrounded by ranching country. South of town there are ranches that were founded 300 years ago. Father Kino brought the first cows to the Santa Cruz Valley in the 1690’s.
There are also a lot of for real cowboys out there, doing cowboy stuff. The other day was talking to one of the cowboys that’s been up at 4:30 every morning branding cattle.
But the days of cowboys and ranching in Southern Arizona may be numbered.
To hear local ranchers talk about what’s going on in the borderlands sounds eerily like stories from the days of the Apache wars, especially 1850 to 1880.
The murder of Douglas rancher Robert Krentz sent shock waves through the ranching community. Every rancher and cowboy out working the range felt like it could’ve been them that was gunned down.
Every rancher I’ve talked to tells pretty much the same story:
…they see lots of undocumented workers crossing their ranches, leaving trash, cutting fences, and getting into trouble because of the heat. Many area ranches have set up water stations for crossers.
…other than the increase in the number of workers crossing, nothing much has changed in years out there. The workers crossing have never been much of a problem. There seems to be just as much increase in crossers as Border Patrol.
..they’ve built “side step” gates through fences but the Border Patrol has put sensors on these gates, so the crossers are still cutting fences.
…they are finding dropped loads of drugs out on remote roads. They don’t go anywhere near these drops for fear someone is watching them. They call the Border Patrol. And then get the heck out of there.
…they fear that there are armed drug smugglers with automatic weapons out there now. They really do not want to run into these guys. Most of the cowboys are carrying weapons, but as one said “A 45 is no match for a 47” meaning an AK 47.
…while working out on the range, they hope that the drug smugglers will sort of ignore them “ cause we’re just cowboys doing our job.” Since the Krentz murder, they don’t believe that.
…they used to offer aid to crossers they found on their ranches. Since the Krentz murder, they don’t any more.
…meanwhile they’re moving their families out of the area because they don’t feel it is safe any more.
…and they have nothing good to say about the Border Patrol.
If you want to get an earful about how ineffective the Border Patrol really is, go talk to a borderland rancher.
Homeland Security Director (and former Governor) Janet Napolitano was testifying before Congress the other day, denying that the border was broken and touting all the Border Patrol and goodies deployed out there. During her testimony she claimed to really know the border.
I really doubt Janet has every gone incognito to the border without an escort from the Border Patrol and been fed their line of cow flop.
We’d like all these experts on border security who keep dumping millions of dollars into the failed Border Patrol “layered defense” strategy to tour the border without their press entourages and without their Border Patrol escorts. They need to see what’s going on at the ground level and talk to the border people.
The Arizona Cattle Growers Association has submitted an 18 point plan to improve border security. Please take the time to read this.
If you go to the borderlands and talk to the cowboys, not only will you hear details about this plan from the cowboys, they will show you what’s wrong with the current strategy of the Border Patrol driving on roads 20 miles from the border, and leaving the line open for crossing and smuggling.
The photos of those masked gunmen who shot at the Pinal County Sheriff’s deputies over by Interstate 8, forty miles inside Arizona, says it all.

US Cavalry
The folks crossing looking for jobs are not the border security problem we have. It’s the guys with AK 47s running around the borderlands that are the problem.
Back when the Apaches were kicking the crap out of everyone in Southern Arizona the US army established forts all over the place to secure the area. This was not a “police” type operation. It was military.
Ironically, one of the most effective Border Patrol operations has been their Forward Observation Bases at the border, with their agents riding the border on horses.
Maybe instead of sending in the National Guard, we need to send in the US cavalry.
___________________________________________
List of Arizona forts established during the Apache War:
• Fort Apache
• Fort Badger
• Fort Bowie
• Fort Buchanan
• Fort Crittenden
• Fort Defiance
• Fort Grant
• Fort Huachuca
• Lee’s Fort
• Fort Lowell
• Fort McDonald
• Fort McDowell
• Fort Milligan
• Fort Misery
• Fort Mojave
• Fort Rock
• Fort Tyson (Charles)
• Fort Utah
• Fort Verde
• Fort Whipple
• Fort Yuma

May 27th, 2010 on 8:02 am
I agree that “The folks crossing looking for jobs are not the border security problem we have. It’s the guys with AK 47s running around the borderlands that are the problem.” Our government needs to start treating this border problem as a military invasion. The United States has protected many different country’s borders when they were being invaded, when are they going to start protecting their own?
May 27th, 2010 on 10:16 am
I agree we need to start taken care of our country, we are having problems here on our land. We need to protect our borders , we need the US Cavalry back they worked to keep people safe thats what we need now. The cowboys out trying to work and make a living the way they know how shouldnt have to be afraid to be on thier land dont the job they love doing. they should have to worry about running into someone with an ak47 and drugs, when they should be safe and the borders should be watched better.
May 27th, 2010 on 10:51 am
I’m not sure I like the idea of militarizing our border but it seems like that will be the first best way to start solving this issue. Once the illegal border crossers get over the line, we’ve already failed. I’m sure with the available troop strength, technology and resources we have the entire border could be shut down except for checkpoints. A 45 doesn’t compete with an AK 47 but the AK 47 doesn’t compete with a sniper rifle out of a helicopter.
The border problem will need to be handled by the federal level with border protection. A state that tries to solve this through legislation will be sinking way more money than they currently have available.
May 27th, 2010 on 12:18 pm
Where did you get your list of “forts”. Some of those I have never heard of and some are not related to the Apache Wars. Between 1854 and 1891 there were over 70 forts and camps in the Arizoa Territory. Please do your research.
Because the Army had “downsized” after the Civil War (back to pre-war levels) we only had 25,000 troops for the entire country. In Arizona we had 2,500 troops from 1866 to 1886. Not enough. During the Geronimo Campaign we increased the level to 5,000. This was clearly a case of the Federal government not dealing with the problem. If we had flooded the Territory with thousands of troops we would have ended the Apache Wars in a very short time. And would have saved many, many Apache lives as well as our citizens.
Try some research next time.
May 27th, 2010 on 1:05 pm
I got the list from an army website. They left out Camp Little in Nogales and a few others…but the point is not getting the exact number…but the idea that when armed people are shooting at us, the response needs to be of a military style…draw a line and hold it…something our country has failed to do since WW II….funny how the lack of boots on the ground has always been a problem in Arizona since territorial days…meanwhile some of the ranch familes go far enough back to have stories about fighting off the Apaches and how similar the situation is out there now…
(1) Get the workers a legal path to work here and not run around the desert and
(2) Defend our country against armed invaders.
Simple….and lots of people will agree with that approach.
May 27th, 2010 on 12:25 pm
Otherwise a good article! Didnt mean to be that harsh!
May 27th, 2010 on 9:31 pm
Until we institute a work permit/visa for entry to this country available to all who apply for a small fee there will be no solution to the border problem.
I was down in Baja and Sinaloa this past winter – I always go south in winter. I talked to lots of Mexicans and many said they can get over the wall anytime they please. It does nothing but slow em down a bit. And its a big waste of tax dollars as is the extensive use of border patrols driving everywhere but on the border.
h wolters/Bisbee