Tucson Citizen.com
Views From Baja Arizona - brought to you by Hugh Holub

Another Open Letter to Obama…this one from the residents in Eastern Arizona on their border situation

by on May. 16, 2011, under border issues, politics

 

Drug smuggler backpack Photo by Stephen Cullen

This Open Letter to Obama was written by Dinah Davidson of Portal. The folks living around Portal are in one of the most dangerous drug smuggling corridors on the border…over by the Chiricahua Mountains in Cochise County which is called the ” Chiricahua-Peloncillo drug and human smuggling corridor” :

President Barack Obama
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20500

Copies to: The Honorable Gabrielle Giffords, Senator John McCain, Senator Jon Kyl, Secretary (of Homeland Security) Janet Napolitano, Secretary (of Agriculture) Tom Vilsack, Secretary (of State) Hillary Clinton, Governor Jan Brewer, NPR.

Dear President Obama:

It is with great wonderment and sadness that we listened to your May 10 speech on immigration issues.  All of the joking about moats and alligators cut residents of Portal, AZ, to the core as we sheltered with friends or at a Red Cross evacuation site, to survive a terrible fire that still threatens our lives and property, as well as our ecotourism-based economy.

Like last spring’s ‘Horseshoe Fire’, fought in SE Arizona at a cost of more than $10 million, ‘Horseshoe Fire 2’ was ignited by humans along a well-established route used by human and drug smugglers high in Horseshoe Canyon, about 50 miles north of Mexico.  This fire burned catastrophically in an environment stressed by the worst drought this region has ever recorded, and 50 mph winds have propelled it through whole mountain valleys in a heartbeat.  During its first 24-hrs, the fire consumed a greater area than did last year’s fire over a 6-week period.  Local residents were roused after midnight, and some slept fitfully in cars after fleeing with family photos and any valuables that could be quickly assembled.  Elderly retirees left with medical supplies, including oxygen tanks on which some depend.

Thinking about this in the context of your own loved ones, does this account strike you as a description of security?  We can personally attest to the fact that neither the border nor daily life is secure for members of our community.  Seizure of record quantities of drugs may pad the statistics of Homeland Security, but it does nothing to ease the burdens we have been forced to bear.  Over the years, as our homes have been burgled or invaded, our fences, water lines and windows repeatedly broken, our businesses driven toward bankruptcy, our natural surroundings desecrated by trash and fire, and our lives even obliterated (neighbor Rob Krentz, murdered by a drug scout), it has amazed us how little note is taken of these tragedies by our government and the press.  Is it enough, now that we have suffered back-to-back fires that threaten to erase our very reasons for living here?  What must we say or do to garner your attention and help?  How is it that, on the same day we took Osama bin Laden in Pakistan, we could not prevent illegals – 50 miles within our borders (!) – from setting a fire along a known smuggling route in an extremely dry year?  Why were federal agents (BP, ICE, National Guard, or Special Forces) not posted along this route in anticipation of a repeat of last year’s calamity?  Better still, why were the illegals not captured before they had traveled 50 miles north of the border?!  Or, in the eyes of our government, do we just reside in a ‘sacrifice zone’?

The region where we live is not just our personal homeland but a repository for much of the nation’s biological diversity.  Naturalists from all over the world come here to study at the American Museum’s SWRS field station, or just to observe, but year after year, less natural habitat survives to accommodate them.  For them and for ourselves, watching this environment collapse is akin to watching a beloved family member die. 

All of Arizona’s highly biodiverse ‘Sky (Mountain) Islands’ are in jeopardy and for the same reason – fires set by drug and human smugglers.  (For other examples, you might ask your Agriculture Secretary about the Santa Rita range south of Tucson, and the Sierritas, west of that, and also on fire at this moment.)  Moreover, the country itself is in jeopardy of losing not just the extraordinary biological patrimony represented in these mountain ranges, but (extrapolating over a century or two) the U.S. territory itself.  If this strikes you as hyperbole, what Americans do you know who would choose to remain in lands so tragically depleted?

We therefore wish to know what you plan to do to protect our constitutional right (Article IV, section IV) to defense from foreign invasions, especially as this regards fires set by Mexican drug and human smugglers.  We thank you in advance for your anticipated response.

Sincerely,

The following residents of the Chiricahua-Peloncillo drug and human smuggling corridor:


6 Comments for this entry

  • Fraser007

    Good article Hugh.
    Here is a short note to Mr. Obama. Send the Third Infantry Division. They are at Ft. Benning and Ft. Stewart. Leave the tanks. Bring everything else. They will seal the border in one week. Obama wont send the Army because he knows they will do the job. He doesnt want the job done.
    After them send a couple more. Its time. I am sorry to say this but the Border Patrol can no longer do the job. Unless you triple the size at least. Obama just stabbed you in the back in the El Paso speech.
     

  • Hugh Holub

    An interesting problem…under Posse Commitatus the US can’t directly use military on the border to enforce fed and state laws…..but the need is for a military-like strategy that secures territory instead of chasing people around in trucks.

    And…I’d make a some of the borderlands a training ground for our special forces units.

    • Fraser007

      I am aware of Posse Commitatus. Maybe make some Border Patrol into an armored division. (minus the tanks)! lol. Lots of ex military they could hire. Or make the BORTAC a division size unit. Just let them borrow the Army equip. If we don’t then we don’t deserve to have a country. Who the hell is in charge here.

  • Bajada

    Hugh-
    Although I disagree with you on some issues (I am proudly a biologist who has spent a lifetime working with endangered animals ) I can tell you that you have written a great letter regarding that all-important area of SE Arizona.
    The fire in the Chiricahuas breaks my heart. And clearly that area, those people, the wildilife, and the range itself may take many, many years to recover, if it ever does. Wonderful people in that area who love and cherish those mountains are devastated, and apparently no one cares. And it is clear that neither party will stand up for those who need protection and support from their own government,
    Two years ago, in the late evening, I hid in a ledge in those mountains until a group of drug runners moved down the trail with their drugs and had to cross country my way of the same area that has now burned due to illegal activity. It wasn’t the first time for that, for me. And I know that the powers that be have known that this was an area that needed and didn’t get intensive focus by the BP and the DEA. And of course, because the “border is all secure”, that never happened. Absurd.
    WE are losing a treasure here. And no one seem to care. Perhaps if illegals were running through neighborhoods in Washington, DC and starting fires someone would notice.
    The BEST Americans, the people who follow the rules, who love their country, who defend its hallowed earth are paying for the cheap labor and drugs that both parties seem to want. It makes me ashamed of my country.

    • Hugh Holub

      I did not write the letter…the folks over in Portal did.

      Scotty Anderson (Price Canyon Ranch) was a client for years….and I know the area well and  I hear you about about the loss….

  • leftfield

    Keep reassuring folks that we can see “the light at the end of the tunnel”; keep doing things the same, never give up on a flawed policy; change the goals if you run into trouble; create some heroes to make the story personal and create some objective criteria to prove we are ahead on the scoreboard (body counts and drug seizures).  It worked so well in Vietnam; why fix it if it ain’t broke?

2 Trackbacks / Pingbacks for this entry