An open letter to Obama about the border
Saturday, May 14th, 2011To: Barack Obama
President of the United States
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20500
Re: Invitation to visit the border in Arizona
Dear President Obama
I understand you have been invited to visit Nogales, Arizona by the Mayor of that city for the dedication of the new Mariposa Port of Entry .
Please come to the Arizona-Mexico border and not only visit the new port facility, but also to see the border in all its diverse manifestations.
Please come to the Arizona-Mexico border and meet with the diverse people who are the voices of the border’s issues.
Please bring with you leaders of both political parties from the US House and Senate. Especially include Senators Kyl, McCain and Grassley and Representatives Grijalva, Chaffetz and Issa.
Here is a proposed itinerary and discussion topics for the visit:
Fly into Davis Monthan AFB in Tucson and take a helicopter tour of the Arizona border region. Fly over the various Border Patrol office complexes in Tucson and Nogales and Sonoita and see all the Border Patrol vehicles parked in their parking lots. See the checkpoints on Interstate 19, and other roads in the region. Then fly the line from Douglas out over the Tohono O’odham Indian Nation and see where the border fence has been constructed and where it has not been completed. See the rugged countrysides and deserts where immigrants and drug smugglers cross into the United States. Maybe you might even see drug cartel spotters sitting on our mountain tops guiding groups of undocumented aliens and drug smugglers around Border Patrol deployment. The borderlands residents will not agree the border is “secure” until the drug cartel spotters and smugglers are ousted from the United States.
Then stop in Nogales and walk down Morley Avenue and then go to the Nogales Wal Mart and see hundreds of Mexicans shopping in border stores contributing to the US economy.. Talk to people you meet in the stores and the store keepers about the economic importance of trade with Mexico. You will see first hand that it is true that border security inside border cities is vastly improved as claimed.
Then tour both the DeConcini Port of Entry and the new Mariposa Port of Entry and see what the gateways to the United States look like. In particular notice the massive traffic jams at the two ports. The USEPA can provide you with documentation that these traffic jams create a serious air pollution problem on both sides of our border.
Then meet with a delegation of maquiladora, produce and retail interests to talk about the problems of crossing the border. They will tell you that building fancy new port facilities is wonderful…but the lack of sufficient Customs and Border Protection officers to staff the ports takes away the benefits of expanded port facilities and still leaves the border gummed up and not functioning as well as it should. You will hear requests for more funding to fully staff the ports of entry.
Then meet with the border county sheriffs from Cochise, Santa Cruz, Pima and Yuma counties. You will get a diverse view of the border from Dever, Estrada, Dupnik and Ogden. Since federal border enforcement authority and strategies reach 100 miles into the US, also include sheriffs Babeu and Arpaio.
You will hear vastly different views of the border security “problem” from these sheriffs. There is truth in all of what they have to say because they are the front line of the human smuggling and drug trafficking problems in our state.
Then meet with some of the Samaratans…folks who go out in our deserts every day to provide water and first aid to undocumented immigrants who get in mortal danger trying to enter the United States. They have some chilling stories to tell you about the humanitarian crisis in our borderlands.
Then meet with the Pima County Medical Examiner who will describe Pima’s morgue full of unidentified bodies of undocumented immigrants who died in our deserts. Hundreds of bodies are found every year around here. Bodies will continue to be discovered as long as the remains are intact and many will never be discovered because of the rugged nature of the region.
Then visit the site of one of the rape trees along our border. There is one near Arivaca. Consider the violence being wrought against undocumented aliens in our borderlands by bandits.
Then meet with representatives of the Tohono O’odham Indian Nation and hear their version of the border security problem and the impacts on their people. Half of the dead undocumented aliens being discovered in our borderlands are found on the Indian lands.
Then visit the site where Border Patrol agent Brian Terry was murdered by some of the border bandits and talk to some ATF agents who blew the whistle on their bosses for “walking” guns to the Mexican drug cartel. Two of those “walked” guns were found at agent Terry’s murder scene. Meet with agent Terry’s family.
Begin to consider that your administration’s approach to the Gunwalker scandal should not be hiring a public relations agent, but to weed out of the government the misguided management that “walked” the guns. Make sure your administration understands that any US official who impedes Senator Grassley’s and Representative Issa’s investigation into Gunwalker will be fired and turned over to the US Attorney’s office for prosecution for obstruction of justice.
Then come to one of the border ranches and meet with Sue Krentz, the widow of Robert Krentz and, Dan Bell and Tom Kay and Jim Chilton and others whose ranches are along the border and daily have to deal with drug smugglers and undocumented aliens in areas where…by the Border Patrol’s own admission, the border is not secure. Hear their stories.
I would hope by the time you visit our borderlands you will see what the problems really are.
First, I would hope that you begin to understand that when folks around here demand that the border be secured, we’re not talking about a moat filled with alligators and 10,000 more Border Patrol agents.
What we are questioning is why the federal government cannot finish building the fence. As your own Government Accounting Office has documented, your federal land managers along the border are impeding securing the border.
What we are questioning is why the Border Patrol has spread itself around 100 miles into the interior of the United States instead of concentrating themselves at the border.
What we are questioning is why the federal government cannot adequately staff its ports of entry.
What we are questioning is why the federal government cannot come up with a visa tracking system so 6 million people who entered the US and overstayed their visas cannot be found.
What we are questioning is why a Guest Worker program cannot be developed immediately to get people out of our deserts and mountains.
What we are questioning is why are parts of our country being taken over by the drug cartels armed with automatic weapons.
What we are questioning is why some sort of legalization process cannot be agreed upon to bring 11 million undocumented aliens above-ground that is not an “amnesty”.
As the final stop in your trip, I’d like you to enjoy some bar b que steaks at one of the border ranches and have a frank discussion between yourself and key congressional leaders to develop a legislative package that secures the border and straightens out our immigration mess.
The claim that legalization is going to benefit Democrats in 2012 is actually bogus. If you knew our Hispanic residents you’d begin to see what a mistake it has been for some to demonize illegal aliens. We have millions of people who believe in the American dream of hard work equals a better life. If they weren’t the target of xenophobes, they just as likely would vote Republican in the future.
We must break the political and rhetorical impasse we are in now on the border. Neither side of the border debate should use the border for political gain as this does nothing to actually solve our border and immigration problems.
Come to our border Mr. President and hear all the diverse voices coming from our region….aid workers, retired Border Patrol agents, ranchers, sheriffs, produce importers, store keepers…and appreciate everyone is right from their side and between all of the various views there are solutions we can all agree on.
Thank you.
PS: If you can’t make it out here please talk to Chris Sautter who has been making a documentary film about our border and has a lot of this on film.
________________________________________________________
More on border issues:
The following are articles and commentaries on border issues and SB 1070 that have appeared in the View From Baja Arizona .
Most recent….
“Probationary Presence” not “amnesty” needed in immigration reform
Who will wipe your baby’s butt? Who will pick your lettuce? Who will mow your lawn?
California Congressman re-introduces DREAM Act
Arizona Attorney General blasts Obama on border security
Obama immigration reform proposal lands on table like dead fish
Arizona Sheriffs Babeu and Dever call Obama immigration proposal “amnesty”
Obama’s blueprint for a 21st century immigration system
Obama speaks in El Paso about immigration reform
Smugglers take advantage of distressed real estate market in Santa Cruz County
Arizona set to build own border fence …another really dumb idea from the state legislature
Another drug tunnel discovered and other border news
Illegal alien charged with murder of Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry
Issa Leads Congressional Investigation of DOJ’s ATF “Operation Fast & Furious”
Napolitano promises to change the way “border security” is measured
Cochise County Sheriff Tells Congress That Border Patrol Agents Ordered to Reduce Arrests
California Gulch..one of those places along the border wide open to drug smugglers
If the border is so secure why are there dead bodies all over the place?
Republicans Introduce Bill to Secure Border on Federal Lands, Protect Environment
Apprehensions of illegal aliens at the border are way down…why?
GAO confirms federal environmental laws and federal land managers hinder securing our border
Senators Kyl and McCain propose new border security plan
DHS testifies at same hearing as border rancher…compare the view of the border situation
Rancher tells Congress the way it really is down at the border
What does “securing the border” really mean?
Illegal entry and drug smuggling in perspective…what if all this was going on in your front yard?
Probationary Presence…another Immigration Law Reform Proposal
Drug cartels have made Nogales the tunnel capital of the Southwestern border
GOP drafts legislative assault on illegal immigration
Arizona would go broke if all the illegal immigrants left the state
230,000 displaced in Mexico by drug war
Janet Napolitano: Border security better than ever
Birthright citizenship debate…is the solution worse than the problem?
Immigration enforcement efforts damaging to community, police group says
10 million more illegal aliens coming to America?
Border officials say security is improving…and the tooth fairy is real
US Census Report on Arizona…Hispanic population increases dramatically
Utah avoids mistakes Arizona made on immigration laws
Cops don’t want to be junior Border Patrol agents (except in Maricopa County)
Inside ATF…an ugly picture …how many dead bodies are out there as a result of Project Gunrunner?
Grassley blasts Department of Justice on coverup of guns used in Agent Terry’s murder
Dept. of Justice denies gun claim about Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry’s death
Is there a cover-up on Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry’s murder?
Was Border Patrol agent Brian Terry killed by a gun bought in Phoenix?
DHS chief Napolitano living in a fantasy land about border security
Guns and Mexico … be very afraid my friends
More on the coverup of the truth about the guns that killed Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry
Secure the border at the border
Border safe and secure, CBP commissioner Bersin proclaims
Dept. of Justice denies gun claim about Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry’s death
Is there a cover-up on Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry’s murder?
Arizona ranchers question Napolitano’s claims the border is safer
Napolitano touts Homeland Security’s border efforts
Guns from Arizona going to Mexican drug cartels according to Mayors Against Illegal Guns
Was Border Patrol agent Brian Terry killed by a gun bought in Phoenix?
11.2 million illegal immigrants in US according to Pew Research Center
Arizona legislators determined to keep Arizona as the center of anti-immigrant efforts
Arizona’s harsh immigration law cancer not spreading across nation
Murdered Border Patrol Agent’s mom still in the dark about what really happened
Birthright citizenship bill unveiled by Arizona lawmakers — 2011′s version of SB 1070
McCain willing to seek immigration overhaul bill when the border is secure
Mexican cartel violence prompts calls for bigger National Guard deployment along the border
Celebrating the New Year in the borderlands with automatic weapon gunfire
An NPR report: Nogales, Sonora — Once A Mexican Tourist Town, Now No Man’s Land
Mexican drug cartels killing their border cities
More rumors and few facts regarding the death of Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry
Texas border ranchers face same unsolved problems as Arizona’s border ranchers
Does America hold children responsible for the crimes of their parents?
Feds making a big mistake in secrecy over death of Border Patrol agent Brian Terry
Green Valley News Reports Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry was shot in the back
Border Patrol agent death a wake up call to many
Nogales International report on BORTAC and Peck Canyon
Dream Act dead because a majority isn’t a majority in the US Senate
Napolitano confirms bandit gang killed border agent
Some ideas about how to really secure the border
Tucson Sector U.S. Border Patrol Agent Killed in Line of Duty
Mexico a powder keg about to explode
A 14 point proposal for immigration law reform –”probationary presence” instead of amnesty
Humanitarian crisis on our border must be addressed
Special law enforcement task force needed to prosecute crimes against illegal immigrants
Drug cartels fight over control of northern Sonora
Are the Mexican drug cartels taking over Mexico? Is there any doubt?
Border wildlife refuge turns into battleground over humanitarian aid to illegal immigrants
Broken immigration law fuels illegal entry
What to do about drug cartel “spotters” on the US side of the border?
Napolitano says border is largely controlled
Border Patrol agents in shootout near Nogales — what’s wrong with this story?
Sealing the border is unrealistic says border boss
Marijuana fuels Mexican drug cartel profits
Do people deliberately come to the US to have babies who will be citizens?
Illegal immigration trashes wildlife refuge
Tohono O’odham Reservation deadly place for migrants
Are there fewer drug tunnels in Nogales?
Immigration law reform—overstaying a visa should be a crime
12 million illegal immigrants…a resource that should not be wasted
Some difficult issues in the “amnesty” debate
Border tours offer opportunity to see border realities
Sovereignty and a secure border
The difficulty of securing the border
A Cochise County rancher’s view of the border
Is the effort to secure the border deliberately designed to fail?
Alice in Wonderland and border security
Out in the desert on immigrant trails
Are there some areas near the border that are too dangerous for the Border Patrol?
Mexican drug cartels are not listed as official terrorist organizations
Is the Border Patrol avoiding some areas of the border because “it is too dangerous”?
Posse Comitatus and the Mexican border
Legalize drugs to bankrupt the cartels…Pfizer versus the Aztecas…the ultimate “smack down”.
_____________________
Major posts…..
We need immigration law reform — Opinion
What does “no amnesty” really mean?
Secure the border or immigration law reform first?
Life on the border — the residents of Nogales, Rio Rico and Tubac
Life on the border — the ranchers
Life on the border — Entering the US illegally
More horses needed to secure the border – Commentary
More on the cartel attack on a border ranch
Border ranch attacked by drug cartel
Ranchers report smuggler scouts on the border area hilltops
Has the federal government abandoned land to the Mexican drug cartels?
Abolish the Border Patrol and replace it with a new Border Security Agency
Is racism on the rise in Arizona?
Has Arizona become the “cracker state”?
Klan types ride again … only on electron beams
Guide to Border Patrol Checkpoints
Are there human rights for people who cross the border illegally?
Who will stand up against the racism in Arizona?
Poll results show politicians the way on border issues…if they’ll listen
Background on why SB 1070 even exists
More blame to share on illegal immigration
Who is at fault for illegal immigration?
How would you deport 11 million illegal aliens?
Securing the border and immigration law reform
What is your definition of a “secure border”?
__________________________________
More….
“Attrition through enforcement”…SB 1070 attempts to make Arizona the “bouncer” of illegal aliens
59 dead in the desert in July due to killer coyotes
Why Americans Think (Wrongly) That Illegal Immigrants Hurt the Economy
Law enforcement discretion and SB 1070
Commentary on the judge’s decision to stop parts of SB 1070 from going into effect
Do politicians have the will to work together to stop illegal immigration and drug smuggling?
Should SB 1070 have been enjoined?
Was SB 1070 worth it? Commentary
SB 1070 enjoined by federal judge July 27, 2010
Arpaio takes 50 caliber machine gun out into desert hunting cartel smugglers
Is it safe to visit Southern Arizona ?
Arizona Republic Poll: Most Arizonans would let immigrants stay in U.S
Would you allow illegal immigrants to remain in the United States if…
Feds’ suit raises stakes for Arizona’s immigration law
US sues Arizona over SB 1070 — Justice Department Press Release
Full text of Complaint filed against Arizona on SB 1070 by US
US Brief in support of injunction against SB 1070
Statement of Santa Cruz County Sheriff in support of suit against SB 1070
Statement of Tucson Police Chief in support of suit against SB 1070
What if a state said “welcome” to immigrants?
The immigration debate — it never ends
Pinal County Sheriff: Mexican drug cartels now control parts of Arizona
SB 1070 does nothing to stop drug cartel gunmen
Can you qualify to be a US citizen?
_______________________
Citizen bloggers are not paid for doing their blogs.
If you like the View From Baja Arizona you can make a contribution to support this blog.
It is a secure Pay Pal transaction.
Thank you !!! DONATE BY CLICKING HERE

