Tucson Citizen.com

Past results when Arizona Wildcats land two Five-Star recruits not favorable

by on Apr. 28, 2011, under Sports

Former UA guard Mustafa Shakur played in his first NBA game on Jan. 22 this year, nearly four years after completing his Wildcat career (US Presswire photo/Rafael Suanes)

So Josiah Turner and Nick Johnson are Five-Star recruits as rated by Rivals.com in its most recent rankings released Wednesday. Is that good news or bad for UA coach Sean Miller?

Turner, a point guard from Sacramento who finished his season at Winston-Salem (N.C.) Quality Education Academy, and Johnson, a guard-wing from Henderson (Nev.) Findlay Prep, become the third Wildcat duo to be listed as Five-Star prospects in the same year.

In 2003, forward Ndudi Ebi of Houston was rated the No. 4 prospect overall and guard Mustafa Shakur was rated No. 12. In 2007, guard Jerryd Bayless of Phoenix was the No. 13 prospect and forward Jamelle Horne was rated No. 21.

Turner is rated No. 11 by Rivals.com in the Class of 2011 and Johnson is at No. 18. Generally, the top 25 or 26 recruits garner Five-Star status.

Bayless, who only played one season at Arizona, has enjoyed the most success in his career, compared to Ebi, Shakur and Horne.

Of course, these rankings are always suspect. Keep in mind that former UA forward Derrick Williams, a potential No. 1 NBA draft pick, was not among the Rivals.com Top 150 prospects in 2009.

Ebi never played for Arizona, opting for the NBA draft instead. He was the 26th overall pick in the 2003 draft but his career never flourished at Minnesota, which waived him after two seasons. He was subsequently waived by Dallas in the next preseason camp and has only played in Europe since.

Shakur started all but two of his games at Arizona during his four-year career, but he was not drafted by NBA clubs in 2007. A point guard with decent height at 6-4, Shakur was co-MVP of the 2003 EA Sports Roundball High School Classic. The other MVP? LeBron James.

Shakur toiled in Europe for a couple of years and played in the NBA Developmental League before signing a 10-day contract with Oklahoma City at the end of last season. He returned to the D-League this season, playing for Tulsa and Rio Grande, before Washington signed him to a 10-day contract on Jan. 22. He played in his first NBA game that day, almost four years after leaving Arizona.

He finished the season with the Wizards, averaging 7.2 minutes a game in 22 games.

Bayless’ only season at Arizona in 2007-08 was tumultuous personally as he felt let down when Lute Olson took a leave of absence and was replaced by interim coach Kevin O’Neill. The 2007 McDonald’s All-American still averaged 19.7 points and four assists per game in the Wildcats’ 18-13 season. He was the 11th pick overall in the 2008 NBA draft, taken by Indiana, which traded his rights to Portland.

The Blazers traded him to New Orleans in October, and a month later, he was shipped to Toronto in a five-player trade.

Olson was openly disappointed that Bayless did not stay in Tucson for at least two years. Olson ultimately retired, however, in what would have been Bayless’ second season. When I asked Bayless during the 2009 NBA Summer League if he would attend Olson’s retirement ceremony that August, Bayless, with disdain on his face, shook his head and told me “Nope.”

“Jerryd said all along he wanted to stay here two years,” Olson said at the time. “But then you get the agents working on the kids and parents all year. You might have the kid in your controlled environment for some time, but when (outsiders are) on the parents, you have no idea what’s going on.”

Horne completed his four-year career at Arizona last month, struggling to find his niche during most of his time in Tucson. He ultimately became a bench player as a senior, relinquishing his starting role to junior-college transfer Jesse Perry. Horne will likely go undrafted by the NBA in June, but will probably have a chance to play overseas.

Arizona’s other Rivals.com Five-Star recruits last decade did not flourish in Tucson as they expected.

Jawann McClellan (2004) went undrafted after suffering through personal problems and injuries during his four-year career. J.P. Prince (2005) transferred to Tennessee after his freshman season. Chase Budinger (2006) left for the NBA after three years but was not selected until the second round.

Brandon Jennings (2008) signed a national letter of intent but never qualified academically. He played in Italy for a season before being selected in the first round of the 2009 NBA draft

NOTES: Kentucky is the only school with four signees ranked in Rivals’ top 25, and only two other programs have more than one. Arizona has Johnson and Turner. North Carolina also has two (No. 8, forward James McAdoo; No. 13, forward P.J. Hairston). … Other UA recruits Angelo Chol of San Diego Hoover and Sidiki Johnson, who finished the school year at Brooklyn (N.Y.) Wadleigh, are Four-Star prospects by Rival. Chol is rated No. 73 overall in the Class of 2011 and Sidiki Johnson is at No. 84.



  • Eric

    Sorry Javier, but not a fan of this article in the least.  You trash all of UofA’s 5 star recruits over the past decade but fail to establish what exactly would be favorable for a 5 star recruit!  Are they supposed to play like they are NBA ready during their entire tenure at UofA and stick around for more than 2 years?  Good luck on that happening for any college basketball program that routinely lands 5 star recruits! 

    And amazingly enough, you even trash on Chase Budinger by listing him as someone who “did not flourish in Tucson as they expected” yet he had a very good career at UofA and stuck around for 3 years!  What exactly was he supposed to do in order to “flourish in Tucson as expected”?  You’re even a little harsh on Mustafa Shakur.  He was a good PG for Arizona!  Not great, but good.  Are all 5 star high school recruits supposed to have brilliant college careers and go on to be NBA All-Stars?  If you want to berate the recruiting services who mistakenly rated some kids as 5 star high school players; by all means please do so!  But no need to trash on our 5 star kids who played to the best of their abilities.

    You’ve had some great pieces in the past but this isn’t one of them.

    • macjoneszona

      Excellant points, Eric.

      All the prep rating services have innate bias’ and generally OVERRATE players as well as UNDERRATE players. As Olson would’ve said, that’s just the nature of the beast when it comes to these H.S. rating services.
      That’s why I can never fathom why ‘ Zona fandom get all caught up in the rankings. LOL
      Also,  that Duke mens hoops program is one benefactor of having highly overrated players in their program.  For instance, a prospective Blue Devil recruit who’s a FOUR-STAR H.S. player will all of a sudden become a FIVE-STAR player once he signs a LOI with Super-K’. Say it ain’t so.
      And a THREE-STAR Duke signee miraclously achieves a FOUR-STAR ranking. Go bloody figure.
      Again Eric, thanks for speaking bloody TRUTH to power concerning the brief note above.

    • http://www.wildaboutazcats.com Javier Morales

      You have your opinion on this and I have mine. Budinger didn’t reach his potential at Arizona, in my opinion, and that is certainly the case for Shakur. Budinger’s deal is different because he played under O’Neill and Pennell. But yes, in my opinion, if these kids are 5-star players they should be the cream of the crop, especially by their junior and senior years. Budinger slipped to the second round and Shakur went undrafted. What other proof do you need?
      The bottom line: Let’s not put too much stock in this 5-star player stuff.

  • Carlos J. M.

    Seriously, I don’t think anyone can honestly argue that *****s like Shakur, Budinger or Horne played to their God-given ability while at UA.  If Arizona gets *****-quality play at PG from Mustafa in that infamous meltdown vs. Illinois in the Elite 8 of yesteryear, Lute & Co. are on their way to the school’s 5th Final Four.  It arguably took a Houtson Cougar’s size 15 to the face of Chase to motivate him & Co. to beat a lowly Conference USA team – and at home!  And then there’s Horne…All I can say is the guy promises to have a better pro career – anywhere - than anything he was a part of as a Cat.  Whatever that means, we’ll soon find out.  A good reporter calls them like he sees them.  That’s Javier.

  • magistrate

    Shakur was awful. Cats play in the 2005 final four with anyone playing point guard besides Shakur.

    • macjoneszona

      Typical SIMPLE SIMON rebuttal from ‘ Zona fan. Get outta’ here.
      The diaster in suburban Windy City isn’t as Red and Blue as you and like-minded Wilbur fans believe it to be. There’s was more nuance to the meltdown than you-all Wildcat fandom would like to imagine, Eh.

  • lka789

    How many 5 stars don’t pan out each year?

    • macjoneszona

      More than the typical Wildcat fan would ever admit too. That’s all.

      Case in point. No.1 seed Kentucky and that roster stacked full of McDonald’s All-Americaines were eliminated in the Elite-8 in 2010.  Cali’s Wildcat squad was odds on favorites to play in the 2010 National Championship game that March.
       And believe it or not, that particular Kentucky team had more 5-Star ballers than Arizona’s 2005 squad, which happen to be a No.3 seed playing on Illinois’ home court. Say it ain’t so.

  • lutefane

    Javier what happened to wildaboutazcats.com?

    And on this subject, although I think Lute is a awesome, these five star guys coming in late in Olson’s career were developing as they were earlier in Olson’s career. That will not happen with Sean Miller who is at the top of his game. Sean has proven to get the potential from all his guys.