Tucson Citizen.com
Caveat Lector - Politics, Government and the Free Press – by Mark B. Evans

Text of Gov. Brewer’s speech after signing SB 1070

by on Apr. 23, 2010, under Politics

Gov. Jan Brewer’s office has released the text of her speech after she signed anti-immigration bill:

STATEMENT BY GOVERNOR JAN BREWER

“Thank you for being here today, to join me as we take another step forward in protecting the state of Arizona.

The bill I’m about to sign into law – Senate Bill 1070 – represents another tool for our state to use as we work to solve a crisis we did not create and the federal government has refused to fix …

… The crisis caused by illegal immigration and Arizona’s porous border.

This bill, the Support Our Law Enforcement and Safe Neighborhoods Act, strengthens the laws of our state.

It protects all of us, every Arizona citizen and everyone here in our state lawfully.

And, it does so while ensuring that the constitutional rights of ALL in Arizona remain solid — stable and steadfast.

I will now sign Senate Bill 1070.

For weeks, this legislation has been the subject of vigorous debate and intense criticism. My decision to sign it was by no means made lightly.

I have listened patiently to both sides. I have considered the significance of this new law long into the night. I have prayed for strength and prayed for our state.

I’ve decided to sign Senate Bill 1070 into law because, though many people disagree, I firmly believe it represents what’s best for Arizona. Border-related violence and crime due to illegal immigration are critically important issues to the people of our state, to my Administration and to me, as your Governor and as a citizen.

There is no higher priority than protecting the citizens of Arizona. We cannot sacrifice our safety to the murderous greed of drug cartels. We cannot stand idly by as drop houses, kidnappings and violence compromise our quality of life.

We cannot delay while the destruction happening south of our international border creeps its way north.

We in Arizona have been more than patient waiting for Washington to act.

But decades of federal inaction and misguided policy have created a dangerous and unacceptable situation.

Yesterday, I announced the steps I was taking to enhance security along our border.

Today – with my unwavering signature on this legislation – Arizona strengthens its security WITHIN our borders.

Let me be clear, though: My signature today represents my steadfast support for enforcing the law — both AGAINST illegal immigration AND against racial profiling.

This legislation mirrors federal laws regarding immigration enforcement.

Despite erroneous and misleading statements suggesting otherwise, the new state misdemeanor crime of willful failure to complete or carry an alien registration document is adopted, verbatim, from the same offense found in federal statute.

I will NOT tolerate racial discrimination or racial profiling in Arizona.

Because I feel so strongly on this subject, I worked for weeks with legislators to amend SB 1070, to strengthen its civil rights protections.

That effort led to new language in the bill, language prohibiting law enforcement officers from “solely considering race, color, or national origin in implementing the requirements of this section…”

The bill already required that it “shall be implemented in a manner consistent with federal laws regulating immigration, protecting the civil rights of all persons and respecting the privileges and immunities of United States citizens.”

While the general protection was already included, I believe the issue is so important, we needed to make it CRYSTAL clear.

And I believe that we need to more than simply inscribe it in statute.

Words in a law book are of no use if our police officers are not properly trained on the provisions of SB 1070, including its civil rights provisions.

Today I am issuing an executive order directing the Arizona Peace Officer Standards and Training Board – AZPOST — to develop training to appropriately implement SB 1070.

Importantly, this training will include what DOES – and DOES NOT – constitute “reasonable suspicion” that a person is not legally present in the United States.

Currently, AZPOST serves approximately 170 law enforcement agencies encompassing over 16,000 sworn peace officers, 9,000 correctional service officers, and 16 training academies.

The AZPOST Board of Directors includes the Arizona Attorney General, the Directors of the Arizona Department of Public Safety, the Arizona Department of Corrections, several county sheriffs, and local police departments.

I am also asking the Board to make recommendations on possible improvements to SB 1070 before the end of the year.

For 28 years in public service, I have worked without fail to solve problems diligently and practically. I have done so always with an eye toward civility, and always with the greatest respect for the rule of law.

This new law is no different: As committed as I am to protecting our state from crime associated with illegal immigration I am EQUALLY committed to holding law enforcement accountable should this statute ever be misused to violate an individual’s rights.

Respect for the rule of law means respect for every law. I have led that way every day in every office I have ever held. That will not change.

I have also spent my career in service to Arizona working to bring people together, no matter the color of their skin and no matter the depth of our disagreements.

This bill – and this issue – will be no exception.

While protecting our citizens is paramount, it cannot come at the expense of the diversity that has made Arizona so great. Nor can safety mean a compromise of freedom for some, while we, the many, turn a blind eye.

We must acknowledge the truth – people across America are watching Arizona, seeing how we implement this law, ready to jump on even the slightest misstep.

Some of those people from outside our state have an interest in seeing us fail.

They will wait for a single slip-up, one mistake, and then they will work day and night to create headlines and get the face time they so desperately covet.

We cannot give them that chance.

We must use this new tool wisely, and fight for our safety with the honor Arizona deserves.

We must react calmly.

We must enforce the law evenly, and without regard to skin color, accent, or social status.

We must prove the alarmists and the cynics wrong.

I know in my heart that this great state, my home for more than 40 years, is up to the task.

I believe every one of us wants to be safe, and none of us wants to compromise on the subject of civil rights.

I believe we must love and honor those who fight beside us – just as we must love and honor those who look and believe nothing like we do.

I believe Arizona, like America, is governed by laws.

Good laws … well-intentioned laws … laws that confer respect and that demand respect in return.

In his third State of the Union address, President Theodore Roosevelt said, “No man is above the law and no man is below it; nor do we ask any man’s permission when we require him to obey it. Obedience to the law is demanded as a right; not asked as a favor.”

So, let us move forward — ever mindful of our rights …

– ever faithful to the law … and ever conscious of our bond as Arizonans, and the blessing we share together.

Thank you.”



  • Belles

    Good on ya Jan.. that took guts to sign that law. 

    • Alfredo Bustos

      tell me one reason this law is just?

      • Don

        This law is just.  Do you think it’s okay for illegals to be here in the United States to have free reign to deal drugs, be in gangs and drain the welfare system in this, my country?  If you do think there is no problem with the problems illegals create in the United States, I disagree with you.

        • Mrs. Granado

          How could you possibly assume that all illegals are drug dealers or gangsters? Your statement is an excellent example of discrimination and racial profiling . And for your information, welfare does not aid illegal immigrants. I suggest you do at least a little bit of research before making ignorant statements like the one above. And FYI, I was an illegal immigrant once upon a time–and I was never in a gang, have never done drugs, have never received ANY type of aid from the government, and all because I WORK HARD to achieve my goals. Oh and one final thought for you, Don…this is MY country too!

          • Corina

            I don’t think all illegals are drug dealers or gangsters, but they are  here ILLEGALLY!!!!  It is a CRIME to be here without proper documentation!  This affects us financially!  That is MY BIGGEST problem with illegal immigration!!!  Do you think they pay taxes for the schools their children attend?  No, they do not! Do they pay their medical bills when they have their children here? NO, they do not!  When an illegal gets injured crossing the border and is rescued by the border patrols resue uit, WE foot the bill!!!  The crime that has built up because of drug and people smuggling are  just the tragedies that have become rampant in our cities because of the growing problem illegal immigration has become!!  I don’t pretend to have answers nor do I look down on those that ARE here to work, but I believe these people need to go through the RIGHT and LEGAL steps to working in this country.  Those that are SO UPSET by our governments attempt to control the problem should take up jobs or volunteer to help these people to become legal, law abiding citizens!!!

      • Joe

        This is a Just law. It enforces the law. It really started in 2007 with employer sanctions. Crime has gone down 27% since then. The numbers dont lie.

      • catarine castellanos

        the illegal immagrants do not drain our welfare system anyone here illegal is not eligable for any kind of goverment benifits so, you are wrong.

  • Lydia

    In honor of our governor (who we did not vote into office), I suggest we name this the “Jan Crow” bill.
     
     

    • Mark B. Evans

      Nice.

    • http://www.themoondancesaloon.com andrew

      Nice mature reply, lydia. name calling. That should do the trick.name ledgered

      • Lydia

        Name calling, Andrew? I didn’t call anyone a name. I just suggested an appropriate nickname for the new law. It’s not name-calling.

  • Alfredo Bustos

    wow Janet all i can say is wow u have just made the worst mistake in your life do you know how many tears are being released right now all I’ve had to work for, my education primarily is now gonna have to go to a different state you are the racist most ungrateful and racist  person ever may god bless you for you will need it

    • Joe

      This is a Just law. It enforces the law. It really started in 2007 with employer sanctions. Crime has gone down 27% since then. The numbers dont lie. Onward!!!

  • Josh’s English Tutor

    I think that Josh’s attempt at spelling ridiculous is ridiculous.  Go Brewer….take the Bull by the horn and do what you know is best

  • Mrs. Granado

    Shame on you, Jan Brewer! Immigrants are nor criminals! It is ridiculous to blame them for the crisis in our economy.
    Our economy is in crisis because most Americans have taken on debts that we couldn’t afford in the first place. (I.E. Expensive homes, and excessive purchases on our credit cards!) If anything, immigrants are contributing in building up our economy, by purchasing USA made products.
    Your bill, on the other hand, will produce negative effects in your state’s economy, when illegal immigrants are returned to their country or JAILED simply for lacking documents. Who will frequent Arizona establishments? Who will buy products produced locally? Who will PRODUCE them? Huge mistake, Mrs. Brewer. HUGE.

    • Joe

      This is a Just law. It enforces the law. It really started in 2007 with employer sanctions. Crime has gone down 27% since then. The numbers dont lie and this will only help.

      • aaron

        This is something completely different from employer sanctions. what we are doing by passing this law is telling local law enforcement that they have to deal with the  12 million illegals living here (regardless of whether or not they actually have the resources to do so) and allowing anyone to sue them for not doing it.
        deputizing local law enforcement to enforce federal immigration statutes has happened before, and in almost every incidence it has directly increased crime rates by alienating immigrant communities from police and by diverting police from the more serious criminals. (look at Maricopa county/Joe Arpaio)
        if you want your local police to spend all their time rounding up impoverished immigrant families that’s fine, but i’d rather they go after the real bad guys (research shows that immigrants are actually less likely than citizens to commit crimes)

    • Hoosier Woman

      Who will? Mrs. Granado, I WILL! My husband and I currently live in Indiana. I was raised in Tucson Arizona for over 25 years of my life. I left there 6 years ago because of REVERSE discrimination when my oldest Caucasion son was denied a job at a McDonalds that was run by a Hispanic manager, who hired a Hispanic teen OVER my son who applied the same day! I got so sick and tired of being treated like a second class citizen by Hispanics who only look out for their own! Oh and before you say I am a racist….my youngest son IS Hispanic! I love Hispanic people WHO ARE LEGAL and dont discriminate against Caucasions! Get your papers, work hard, and learn English and we will welcome you with open arms! If your going to immigrate to the U.S. then do it the legal way!I am planning on moving back to Tucson hopefully in the next year to a year and a half. I am hoping that illegals from Mexico wont be a problem, BUT that Arizona will get the problem under control before I get back there! Dont you all realize how much tourist dollars are lost BECAUSE no one wants to go to a state that is so overrun by illegal immigrants? Of course I am hoping that my husband and I can get jobs…since there already is a law prohibiting employers from hiring illegal immigrants! We are moving back to Arizona AFTER IT IS CLEANED UP!

  • Zuleide R Leonardo

      Friday, April 23, 201016:29:30 Dear Governor: I do not reside in Arizona, but I am an immigrant.  I have gone through the Immigration Legalization process. In order to be legal in the US, somehow we have to be illegal in some areas, like changing Visa Status, support evidences on each law one can qualify. Things have been changing in the US, and unfortunately many immigrants, by their behavior and failure to understand the country’s policies end up creating problems, when they immigrate in order to resolve their problems. Mexico has been a problem for a long time, and I wish that Mexico would agree to surrender their territory to America. The US would have 51 states instead, but they insist on being solo without no infra -organization, and that’s the reason, the states close to the Mexico borders are forced to adopt uncomfortable laws and measures.  On behalf of many immigrants who once did not have all the proper ids, not all of us cause problems similar to the one Arizona faces. To discriminate between who is right and who is wrong is not injustice, it is Justice. Maybe the Mexico elite will soon realize that they will have to give their extra wealth to their own citizens, so they are not forced to jump the border, or give their territory to the US for full and complete administration. Sincerely yours, Zuleide R Leonardo, an immigrant who once did not have proper IDs    

  • http://lippard.blogspot.com/ Jim Lippard

    What is the definition of “reasonable suspicion” in the context of this law?  If you can put it into the training, then why can’t you spell it out?

  • Mandy

    In honor of our governor?? are you kidding me? Jan Brewers political career is over.

  • David

    Gov.  Brewer is a coward.  I cannot wait to  vote  her out of office if she doesn’t get impeached before then.  This law is an embarrassment.  Arizona is now  the laughing stock  of the world.  The apartheid nations are looking at us and saying, “Damn, y’all are messed up.”

    • Joe

      This is a Just law. It enforces the law. It really started in 2007 with employer sanctions. Crime has gone down 27% since then. The numbers dont lie. She is anything but a coward.  read the blogs.. Other states and Americans in general are applauding this law. The Fed wont help us. We are not New Oreleans waiting for someone to help us. we choose to protect ourselves.

      • David

        It is not a just law. It is a violation of my civil rights. Do you always make up your statistics on the spot.  Any change in the crime statistics is from Maricopa County Sherrif’s deputies chasing hispanics instead of criminals.

  • Michael

    I understand his mindset, being a life long resident of arizona. Simply put however, ive never heard such an arrogant stream of racism designed to hide the facts of the situation. In Arizona, corrupt politians, police, and sheriffs give asylum to the same criminal enterprises south of the border that they say this will combat. It will not, these criminals buy thier way into arizona and stay here legally and will not be sent back to mexico at all.  However many illegal immigrants who have no ties to crime other than the coyotes who brough  them here will be sent back.  These people will face severe penalties from these drug cartels, the children will be enslaved, the men tortured and killed, and the women raped and killed. This is what WILL happen to innocent people because of this law.  I really wish i could say there is something we can do about narco-trafficantes, but since they are in league with corrupt polititians (sheriff Joe Arpaio has been investigated numerous times for connections to organized crime, and has supplied sheriff’s posse badges to criminals from asia and south america so they could collect gambling debts from US citizents).  Although many may view illegal immigrants as having no right to come here, those who have lived thier life in arizona have seen how bad it is in the mexico that isnt on the travel channel.  The truth is, they only have one place to run to to escape extreme oppression and rule under narco-trafficantes, and that place is America.  I understand this may not be a comfortable idea for some people but if we send them back to inevitable torture and death at the hands of coyotes (if unaware that this isnt just an animal, coyotes are people smugglers who in exchage for upwards of $10,000 will smuggle a mexican into america), we become thier murderers.  I love the United States, but I often hate those who run it, and those who run the United States have failed miserably if it means the denial of freedom and forced death to innocent people who once called this place the only home that ever accepted them.  We Arizonans born in this land rarely agree with deportation because of this fact, and let it be known, most in this state that support deportation are NOT infact Arizonans and showed up during the population boom in the 90′s, so they have no idea of our local politics and customs, and that spanish is a state language (many outsiders, the word used for arizonans not born here, consider spanish to be insulting), and many arizonans hold great pride in the fact that those running for thier lives come to the place we built and call it freedom.  “If a man is to say the word freedom, and another man doesnt understand what it means, it is that mans responsibility to share that glory, and to never keep to himself what he now considers a neccesity of life” Anonymous Arizonan Quote

    • Ferraribubba

      Hey Michael: Along with the Sheriff’s Posse badges that Sheriff Joe has supplied to all the criminals from Asia and South America so they could collect gambling debts from U.S. citizens, how about all the white sheets with the pointy hoods that the Posse wear and the firey crosses that are always found burning in the mornings in front of non-white homes that they visit while making their ‘Welcome Wagon’ visits?
      How will Joe pay for all the carbon credits that will be needed, once the Cap and Trade legislation is passed?
      Just wondering, yer pal Ferrari Bubba

  • Bill

    The bill signing was the correct thing to do. the only people that are complaining are the people that have something to hide. You cant make everyone happy and tough  immigration legislation is what is needed in Arizona. now we finally have a way to flush out the people that dont belong here. if you want to live here there are steps that can be taken for you to become a working non-citizen. Our tax dollars are used when illigals are allowed to live here undocumented. Not to mention they take our jobs and use our services. This was something that was going to happen sooner or later. Just deal with it and say goodbye to uncle Pepe because he wont be here much longer…

    • http://hotmail Uncle Pepe

      You agreed for the law, Now you pay the consequences. And by the way I ain’t going nowheres. Uncle Pepe

      • Native Arizonan

        Go home, Uncle Pepe.

  • Lynne

    $15,000 PER year, PER Student to educate illegal immigrant children in public schools many get free breakfast/lunch programs, require ESL teachers & assistants, print materials etc (ADDED costs).
    $12,900 PER Birth to deliver illegal immigrant children. Increased health insurance because illegal immigrants use the emergency rooms as Dr’s office (there is a patient in Florida that has cost a hospital 1.5 MILLION because Mexico government will not come to get him). Increased local/city/State fees because illegal immigrants get court appointed lawyers (taxpayers charged $300 per hour), translators / print materials etc. Housing in jail/prison is $45 per day cost. Increased car insurance because of uninsured illegal immigrants. Welfare/food stamps/WIC/Rent & housing/educational social service programs used by illegal immigrants w/fake or stolen ID add up to BILLIONS of dollars per year. Identity theft programs ADD cost to banks/credit cards.

     
    *PRICELESS* - Making American Taypayers TO PAY FOR  ALL OF THE ABOVE  by calling them racist because they want immigration LAWS to be ENFORCED! 

    American citizens NOW is the time to stand up! Contact ARIZONA leaders like Sen. Pearce, Gov. Brewer & Sheriff Arpaio – THANK them for being LEADERS & thank the brave Arizona residents for voting to protect the U.S. today & all of our children’s future for generations to come. God Bless America.

    • Sue

      You are right on everything, I lived in Tucson 45 yrs. my best friends parents came from Mexico years ago but they did it right and they are sick of the illegals coming over making them feel like they have to apologize everytime a Mexican does something and happens to have the same name. All you complainers, get your money together and pay for all the accidents Az. pick-up the tab for besides hospital bills. The Rancher that was killed isn’t the only American murdered, a Rancher near Sonoita was found dead in a shed back in the 90′s. Family friends in Bisbee in their 60′s were tied up and beaten and have never been trusting since. This couple every few months gathered clothing, food, building materials and took them across the line to help the people of Mexico and then they got beat for it. How would you feel coming home and finding your parents like that?
      The good need to be seperated from the bad, If the people here who hire them would take full responsiblity for any broken laws give them medical coverage, make them get a US driver’s license that would help.
      We need to stop paying for their babies I believe it was Cochise Hospital had to close it’s maternity ward because it went under.
      Just this week an Illegal was pulled over south of Springer, NM the police found $91,900 suspected drug money in the engine compartment. They seized the money and the vehicle then They took him to the closest bus depot and will let him, deal with the druglords back over the line. The money is used for covering those nasty accidents they cause bringing back cars from Colorado being towed and then one gets loose and crashes into someone on Raton Pass.
      Richardson didn’t like Brewer passing this bill because now he’ll have more in his backyard.

    • aaron

      you’re completely right, paying for their public benefits, education etc is costing us alot of money, but rounding up and deporting 12 million people and forcing them to leave would cost a hell of alot more.
      make them legal and they will pay taxes like the rest of us. in the meantime, I want my tax dollars going to better causes and my police combating real crime.
       

  • Albert

    What don’t you get about the word “ILLEGAL”? Come in legally and you don’t have to worry. Illegals come here… stand on the corner and take away the jobs of the legal people and then want the legal people to pay for all their social needs. Illegals drive cars on the roads that the legal people pay for with their taxes. Illegal people demand rights that belong only to the legal people. ILLEGALS have no rights because they are ILLEGAL. When you do something illegally, you are in violation of the law…a lawbreaker. Break the law, go to jail. Illegals come from many nations, so Mexicanos, don’t take it personally, it’s not about Race, it’s about whats right!!!   

  • Mike

    It’s about time we have strict anti-illegal laws! we should have passed this 10-20 years ago,
    now LETS PASS THIS IN ALL 50 STATES!

  • jim kelley

    There is nothing unjust about this law. At ahat point do any of you not open your eyes to the human suffering that is occuring at the hands of drug smugglers and humn smugglers using this issue of immigration to further their agenda? Why do you close your eyes to the suffering of ALL the human beings that are being tortured by these monsters? It is not the law that “makes them ” do it. That is sociopathic thinking, that is the boyfriend or husband that just beat the wife or girlfirend and said “baby if you would just not nag me about my drinking and going to strip clubs I wouldn’t hit you.”
    So shut down the sociopaths. They are the ones breaking the law, no the State of Arizona. We as a state are going to enforce the law which is the duty of the state, a duty owed and contracted by the constitution to do so.
    No more socipaths running immigration policy. It’s over, it’s done.

    • leftfield

      Do you really think this law, or any other for that matter, will dissuade coyotes or drug smugglers? 

      • Lydia

        Well, no, Leftfield. The coyotes and drug smugglers always carry their papers.

    • Lydia

      I love your typo, Mr. Kelley. Leaving the “w” off the end of the first word in your last sentence. Brilliant!
       
       

  • Johannes

    Illegal is illegal…what is so hard about that.  I came to this great country, was able to do my paperwork the right way, have live here 22 year, 15 serving our military and am now a US Citizen.  If these people do not want to do right – send them back to where they belong.  They are illegal PERIOD.
    God Bless the USA and the opportunities that affords those that want to do right!

  • leftfield

    All this talk about migrants using social services reminds me of a movie I recently watched.  The name of the movie was “Rosewood”.  The plot was based on the true story of a small rural community of black people that was attacked by a white mob.  In the scene I am reminded of, a piano teacher’s house has just been burned down and the teacher with his family are chased into the surrounding swamp.  Noticing the piano in the burning house, a member of the mob says, “Look at that.  N__r’s got a piano!  I been workin’ all my life and I ain’t got a piano.  It ain’t right that the N—r’s got a piano and I ain’t got one.”   

    • http://thechollajumps.com Jim Kelley

      Truly a stretch on your analogy. Lefty, you just don’t have the knack for it.  Will you ever take enough ritalin to stay on topic? I mean really.

      • leftfield

        If the analogy is too much of a reach, it’s enough to know that a cracker is a cracker, regardless of their time and their target.  I mean really.

        • santacruzsam

          Kelley writes some decent narratives, but when he puts on that commenter cap his persona turns aberrant.  I have read many of his posts and he asks for dialogue right before turning into a pit bull.  I am reminded of the communication of dry drunks who still carry their bar-room style.  If they do not agree with you, they just holler back, “you are not listening to me!”  Or, “you’re off topic,” meaning they are not able to follow you.  Metaphorical thinking and literary references are not in their stable of linguistic ammo.  It is attack mode or mute.  You might expect more from a teacher however. But then he is a substitute and they only have to think part-time.
           
          Kolble and McCain had three decades to enact sensible immigration reform. Nada. And, there is a reason for this goose egg performance.  Not until the back is broken of all union trade labor will we have true reform in Arizona.
          Drive the streets of Ft Huachuca and Sierra Vista area and you will witness that the General’s, the Defense Contractors, and homes of retired military,( I am one),  are built with 98% Mexican Labor, all of whom had temporary work visas that were simply not renewed. So the term, ” illegal” requires a bit more nuanced thinking. But then writers like Kelley would just dismiss such a thought as being, “off subject.” Again, meaning their “subject,” not any comprehensive approach to truth.
          Yes ,they are illegal if the visa is not renewed. Yes indeed. And that must be resolved. Yet, who brought them here?  As Doc Holliday so aptly stated, “my  hypocrisy has no bounds.”
          Who offered housing and daily meals for labor? Mostly very rich white men. And when the work is done it is now suggested that we just throw them to the wolves?  Drug dealers yes. Smugglers yes.  They account for maybe 5% at best of the population that worries us. But hard working families who pay SSI taxes  the will never see, and sales tax every time they shop?   We have never seen the likes of the boycott that is on the horizon.
          One third, yes 1/3 rd of retail sales in Southern Arizona comes from Mexican shoppers. You think we got pot hole problems now?
           
          So starting Monday, does this mean that every home builder in Arizona will be raided and the house cleaning will commence, or will they just remain the untouchable, exempt icons of industry that have been for the past 40 years?   The hypocrisy and polarity this is going to cause will result in an exodus from this state. And it will not be Mexicans leaving. It will be middle class Americans  seeking a place to find enlightened leadership and a place to educate their children in an environment that has a heart and soul, and maybe some literary talent.
           
          I and my family will pray.  We will not be returning to Arizona.

          • http://thechollajumps.com Jim Kelley

            It is my hope and prayer that the people of Arizona figure out that not every single one of their kids is going to go to college if they graduate from high school. Through the JTED program in this state’ I am confident that we can offer multipaths of mastery of life and job skills , construction sciences being one of them, that enough of them will go into the construction field and start building a better quality home than what we have seen in the last 7 years. With that being said, it is clear that one; we have the desire and the skill set to grow our economy and workforce without using illegal labor, and two that the population here presently of any race is quite capable of filling out the forms for immigration , get documented and start living the dream. I am not a racist, I actually believe brown people are as smart and capable and have the same value as the rest of humanity. I don’t believe the labor of a brown person should be artificially forced lower than any other skin color. The people who engage in that artificial price fixing of labor need to be held accountable to the degree of the offense.

      • Winn

        Good analogy, Leftfield, and certainly on topic. Mr. Kelley has a hard time thinking outside his own narrow field of vision. Maybe he’s taking too much ritalin…or whatever is his drug of need.
         
        It’s a well-known fact that when times are tough, people look to blame those lower on the socio-economic scale. It’s no excuse. Racial profiling is wrong, wrong, wrong.

        • http://thechollajumps.com Jim Kelley

          And the constatnt mantra of racist racist racist is getting old. No one is blaming this on the lower class. Quite the contrary, I and many others are laying it at the feet of the true racist that artificially fixes brown labor at a lower rate and constatntly tells white people “you wont do the job, only brown people will do the work”
           That my friends is the real racsim going on here. It is the beahavoir of liberal paternalism that is the true racism. It is in the actual behavior that the harm is done, not in the message being presented that exposes the harm. 

          • Winn

            What does racism have to do with the “lower class” exactly?
             
            Sorry, but paternalism is the province of conservatism. Odd you wouldn’t know such a simple fact,

            • http://thechollajumps.com Jim Kelley

              Odd you would repeat something as fact without it’s empiracy to back it up.

              • Winn

                Odd you would address a fact about paternalism, but not address the question directed to you: What does racism have to do with the “lower class?”

  • Poli

    All I have to say after reading these statements is WOW…This is just another ignorant person trying to blame someone else for what is happening to our economy. It’s everybody’s fault why the economy is so bad  especially us Americans that waste so much money on unnecessary junk. And now some are saying illegal immigrants are taking their jobs, really? How many Americans do you see in fast food places, or in the fields or any job that requires real difficult effort. My point exactly . I am 19 and its so upsetting how many people act on hate because it is just a hate law, its just so sad to think this is what my generation has to face. I am also a taxpayer and I am so great-full that my money is heading to help unfortunate  human beings, yes you heard right HUMAN BEINGS, that don’t have enough to put food on the table. Its just so ridiculous to think all illegal immigrants are criminals, they just want a better shot at life and provide for their families and now they cant even cross a street without being noticed by a racist police officer asking about their legal status. I guess we all have to look in the mirror and see our reflection and see if we can find any sign of humbleness because we are all humans and a border should not come between that.

  • Dave

    This is discrimination at its finest.  I wanted to live in Beverly Hills and they wouldn’t let me either.  I had to move back to arizona.  I was willing to mow lawns and clean others mansions if they would provide me with a small house in the neighborhood that I could live in.  It social prejudice I tell ya…
    Just aint right….

  • Ferraribubba

    Hey Mark: Nice Try, comrade. “Anti-immigration bill? Don’t make me laugh. I don’t see Janet’s Homeland Gestapo or Joe’s mounted thugs, wearing white sheets rounding up all people entering the state yet.
    Hell, if I was black, brown, yellow, polka-dot, gay, bi, or straight, provided I was legal citizen of the United States or had a visitors permit and wanted to pay triple the taxes and put security screens on all my doors and windows, I could move back to the murder capital of the west in a heartbeat. Anti? <g>
    And Dave, yea, life is a bitch sometimes. I too wanted to live in Beverly Hills when I worked in Hollywood. The only thing was, I was working at the newspaper, making $135 a week and couldn’t find a place in B. H. that would fit my budget. So I had to live among the great unwashed in Anaheim. (The shame of it all.) I was even forced to drive a used Porsche rather than my present Dino Ferrari.
    Yer pal, Ferrari Bubba

  • leftfield

    “I don’t see Janet’s Homeland Gestapo or Joe’s mounted thugs…”

    Joe does have thugs, though not mounted.  Money has been appropriated for a vigilante group in Cochise County.  Not since the old days of the KKK has the great State of AR seen anything like what’s going on in AZ. 

  • jqc7

    I am proud of our governor!  She is standing up to enforce the law of this country.
    There is nothing wrong with immigration but the people who come here should do it legally!  Other countries enforce their immigration laws, why do people think that this country shouldn’t?  Take a look at Mexico’s south border and how they enforce immigration as an example!
    If you come here legally, you are welcome.  If you chose to break the law and come here illegally, you should be sent home to whatever country you came from.  And that includes Obama’s aunt who is in this country illegally and living off taxpayers.

  • mary recklein

    I think the Constitution covers Mr. Grijalva’s angry appeal for economic penalties for the State of Az. solely because we dare to attempt controlling/removing the endless horde of illegal entrants.  “Domestic enemy”.  This guy is pd. to represent this state.  Not foreign countries and their citizens.  This state and it’s people.  Turn on your boss as he has and what happens?  You get fired.

  • copout

    Dear Governor Jan Brewer: I’m really glad you decided to protect our state and families of Arizona.  Now if only President Obama would do something to help protect our own country he was sworn in to do.  Arizona is behind you on this one and support you all the way.  We Arizonans are tired of being victimized by criminal South of us, who continue to take advantage of Arizona and other states.  I know you are the beacon of light that will guide us though the tough times ahead of us, and the only Governor that has done anything to help Arizona.  I personally am tired of our Department of Economic Security (DES) being used by Illegal Immigrants in getting free government aid by virtue of obtaining a factitious address; it happens a lot here in Douglas.   What opponents of the law don’t understand until they have not been victimized by an Illegal Immigrant they will never understand, and the President of The United States is feeding the system by virtue of allowing agencies such as DES to operate under the current standards and giving Federal monies away to Illegal Immigrants.  So to all of you opponents of SB1070; Stop your whining and consider yourself lucky, you have not been victimized…yet.
    What Arizona needs is a SB identical to 1070 for agencies such as DES and Post Offices who sell PO box numbers to Illegal Immigrants so that they can get Government aid, and stop the crimes being committed there.
     

  • copout

     
    To Congressman Raul Grijalva: Resign!

    When you decided to boycott the state you represent, you have decided to step into a new capacity.  You may want to consider moving to Mexico, they are in need of opponents of Arizona
     

  • John

    This law only gives the police authority to enforce the federal immigration law that is already in place.  Moreover, the governor is mandating proper training through specific police training to ensure proper application.

    The police will only ask for immigration status once lawfully stopped for an infraction, they can ‘t simply profile someone who hasn’t committed an infraction.

    Furthermore and under article 8 of the U.S., immigrants here on visa’s are required to carry thier identification with them to show thier status and failure to do so is a misdemeanor, under federal law, not state.

    Once again, this state law mirrors the federal immigration law and only now allows arizona police officers to legally enforce it.

    If you don’t like the law, its a federal law thier enforcing.  By the way, state police officers are sworn to uphold the, local, state and federal laws when they are sworn into office, otherwise they couldn’t respond to bank robberies in progress since it’s a federal crime, not state crime to “rob” a bank.

    The main stream media is running with this one but once again, they are not informing the public properly. 

    For the record, illegal immigration costs the U.S. taxpayers approx. 330 billion (yes billion) annually, directly and indirectly.

    Immigration is fine, but lets all agree to respect the laws and keep it legal.

  • http://oilanswerman.com Guy Arnold

    Great job Governor Brewer.  Took guts and you showed your a true Arizonian.

  • Betty K

    I do not live in Arizona but I would like to comment after reading all of these replies.

    Do the Hispanics  not realize Govenor Brewer is Protecting you as well?!? It’s not about immigrants that are there settled, families..it’s about the illegals who do not try to pursue legal status in any form!

    I have many hispanic friends. they are really good people for the most part but the violence, drugs kidnapping ect ect is what Govenor Brewer is trying to stop..

    And I would also like to say, I live in Virginia, I was born in North Carolina in 1954 but when I moved toVirginia…. to get my Virginia license   I  had to prove my citzenship….did i complain? no..I have nothing to fear and Until Congress and President Obama addresses Immigration states are going to have to pass laws just like this in order to protect it’s citizens…

    America is not anti immigrant like democrats are saying We are only trying to protect our country from the very thing immigrants from Mexico ran to the US  for. it may cause inconvience to prove who you are but it’s a small price to pay to live and prosper in America.
    Also remember Obama promised to secure the border  and solve the immigration issue, this way blaming conservatives is taking focus off his failure to follow thru..

    Republicans are ready to addresss it and see’s how important it is for all, but Obama says the Congress is too tired to deal with it…

    If this offends anyone I apologize but I just needed to clear up a few things I read here…

    God Bless! 

    • http://bueno2ruiz@yahoo.com Monique Ruiz

      There is nothing to clean up. You are very misinformed. Look into this country’s history and you will see that this country was made on immigration, and those who support SB 1070 are the worst sort of hypocrites. You my dear Betty also have no clue as to what you are saying. Look in your family tree and I am sure you will find that your ancestors were immigrants too. I doubt that they would have liked it if we the Native americans and hispanics were to have kicked them out. But you “Americans” tell people from other countries that we are ” The Land of The Free” Ha! You would like for other people to come from other countries to do your dirty work but you want us to be gone by closing time am I right? Then you say God Bless? God would not care if people were coming to him to for help. But yet you would support someone who would? You are absolutely loathesome if you think so. I can care less if you are my elder and have had more experience than me you are misinformed and ignorant of this situation.This is all I have to say to you.

  • NoArmegeddon

    Kudos to Jan Brewer..After she signed the bill there was no armegeddon, no asteroids were falling some cracks opening in the earth.. Turns out it was a beautifl day..birds chirping , people strolling in the mall.  See it’s all good.

  • http://bueno2ruiz@yahoo.com Monique Ruiz

    For following politics most of my life I have come to the conclusion that though Gov. Jan Brewer probably means good, she has no idea what the is talking about. SB 1070 is a joke. Plain and simple.

  • Ferraribubba

    Hola Monique: When and where is the next Brown Beret meeting? I’d like to attend.
    Tu hermano, Pancho Bubba