Tucson CitizenTucson Citizen

Gimino: UA needs winner – or else

AD’s reputation, finances hinge on big season

Arizona kicks off its third season under Mike Stoops on Saturday against BYU before a likely sellout crowd of more than 57,000. The Wildcats have not had a winning season since 1998.

Arizona kicks off its third season under Mike Stoops on Saturday against BYU before a likely sellout crowd of more than 57,000. The Wildcats have not had a winning season since 1998.

Arizona will begin its third football season under Mike Stoops on Saturday night, and all that hangs in the balance is the health of the athletic department and Jim Livengood’s legacy.

“That’s just the way it is,” said Livengood, UA’s athletic director. “All the good things that happen can be undone by not being very successful on Saturday nights.”

Livengood has overseen plenty of good things in nearly 13 years – perpetual upgrades to the facilities plant, typical top 10 finishes in the all-sports Director’s Cup rankings and keeping the self-supporting athletic department in the black every year.

But the margin of error in a $39 million budget has been reduced to peanuts, and an athletic director, Livengood concedes, is judged mostly by the company he keeps.

Which is to say, the coaches he hires.

Livengood, after whiffing wildly on football coach John Mackovic, has double-knotted his rope to the Good Ship Stoops, which must tug the athletic department through choppy waters.

Livengood can’t afford to be wrong. Again.

“We put our professional life on the line all the time in the hiring process,” he said, “especially in the high-profile sports. They have to make it.”

Early signs are good. Stoops has stirred the fan base, with ticket sales approaching high-water levels. The Wildcats, although they finished last season with the same 3-8 record as in 2004, were more competitive. The coaching staff has recruited well above reasonable expectations.

But if something goes wrong – if Arizona fails to turn the corner and fans become impatient, or there’s some sort of football scandal – that’s Livengood’s neck way out there.

“That’s how it is in business,” he said.

It is Livengood’s blessing, and an ever-lasting credit to former athletic director Cedric Dempsey, that he has never had to replace UA’s coaching cornerstones – basketball’s Lute Olson, softball’s Mike Candrea, swimming’s Frank Busch, golf’s Rick LaRose.

Likewise, Livengood has never had to touch women’s basketball (Joan Bonvicini) or volleyball (Dave Rubio) and just had to shuffle some papers to promote ready-to-roll assistants Fred Harvey (track and field) and Bill Ryden (gymnastics).

Livengood’s third try at women’s soccer (Dan Tobias) hit the mark. So did his second attempt at baseball (Andy Lopez).

But his lack of opportunity in making revenue-producing hires (men’s basketball, football) only emphasizes the couple of choices he did make.

Stoops’ grade is still incomplete. Mackovic?

What was Livengood thinking?

“At that time, what I thought we needed was someone who was very, very organized,” Livengood said. “We needed to have someone who was offense-oriented, because fans were not finding us exciting. And I wanted somebody who had an awful lot of experience.

“Was it the right hire? Absolutely not. I thought it was going to be an outstanding hire.”

It ended up being more like an outstanding fire.

When Livengood told Mackovic to walk just five games into his third season, in 2003, Arizona had the time to conduct a two-month coaching search, a rare luxury.

“There are very few things that I didn’t know about Mike going into the final stages,” Livengood said. “That almost never happens with a football coaching search.”

What he didn’t know then, Livengood says now, is how much Stoops would be committed to a long-term plan of developing a program, not just a team.

“In my exit interviews with seniors, it is amazing how many guys say they wish they had more years to play with this staff,” Livengood said.

“The common theme I hear is that the players are going to be coached hard and coached tough, but they are also going to be cared about. That same voice that says, ‘What a horrible job you did on that play,’ is the same voice that is going to be telling them what they did great.

“The players leave the practice field with an ‘up’ feeling. That doesn’t mean it’s a love-fest, but the coaches and players are in this hand in hand. That is what is so exciting right now.”

It is telling that after the softball team won the school’s seventh Women’s College World Series in June, Candrea told a celebratory crowd at McKale Center to be sure to buy some football tickets.

Everybody in the belt-tightening athletic department, which slashed 18 jobs in the summer of 2005, is thinking about how a winning football team could affect the bottom line.

Livengood has cast his lot: In Stoops He Trusts.

Anthony Gimino’s e-mail: agimino@tucsoncitizen.com.



Stoops’ years in bold

Year – Home games – Home W-L – Home Avg.

1. 1994 – 6 – 5-1 – 56,562

2. 1990 – 6 – 4-2 – 54,074

3. 2005 – 6 – 2-4 – 53,613

4. 1986 – 6 – 5-1 – 52,739

5. 1995 – 6 – 3-3 – 51,749

6. 1999 – 6 – 3-3 – 51,151

7. 1993 – 6 – 6-0 – 50,761

8. 1998 – 6 – 5-1 – 50,206

9. 1989 – 6 – 5-1 – 50,199

10. 2004 – 7 – 2-5 – 50,111


Online poll: How many games do you think the UA football team will win this season?
1-2, all hype, no results: 9%
3-4, about the same as last year: 10%
5-6, in bowl territory: 42%
7-8, a marked improvement: 28%
9-10, this season will be awesome: 2%
11-12, Fiesta Bowl, here we come: 5%
375 users voted


More football stories

UA Football: Islanders give Cats toughness, quickness

What do fans think about UA outlook?

UA must ground BYU passing

Corky: ‘Desperate Devils’ debuts on Fox Sports

NCAA Roundup: OSU’s young QB gets lots of snaps in win

Heinsman watch

Football: Devils topple Lumberjacks, but take 3 quarters to do it

Uncle on UA’s staff helped land Amituanai

Wildcat blog: Cats want crowd to growl at BYU

Three point stances: Would a bad showing against BYU spell doom?

BYU at UA: Staff picks

UA (3-8 in 2005) VS. BYU (6-6): The breakdown

UA VS. BYU: The statistics (top returning players)

BYU at UA: Rosters

Moredich’s nifty nine

PAC-10 Capsules

Fooball: Ranked Vols, Bears renew rivalry

Pac-10 standings

Citizen Online Archive, 2006-2009

This archive contains all the stories that appeared on the Tucson Citizen's website from mid-2006 to June 1, 2009.

In 2010, a power surge fried a server that contained all of videos linked to dozens of stories in this archive. Also, a server that contained all of the databases for dozens of stories was accidentally erased, so all of those links are broken as well. However, all of the text and photos that accompanied some stories have been preserved.

For all of the stories that were archived by the Tucson Citizen newspaper's library in a digital archive between 1993 and 2009, go to Morgue Part 2

Search site | Terms of service