Tucson CitizenTucson Citizen

A time for pomp? Or penitence?

Los Angeles Times – Washington Post News Service


At the height of the potato famine, Queen Victoria of England made a state visit to Ireland. Facades were built in Dublin to prevent her from seeing the dire suffering of the people who lived along her route from ship to castle, where she was wined and dined. The wrenching issue of the famine was totally ignored.

As Pope Benedict XVI visits the United States, will he likewise be shielded from a scandal that has brought an unprecedented harvest of shame for the Roman church in America (and elsewhere)?

I am speaking, of course, of the plague of clerical sexual abuse. Or will he deal forthrightly with the matter, as needs to be done?

In 2004 a report commissioned by Catholic bishops was released, revealing 10,667 allegations of abuse against minors and accusing 4,392 of the nearly 110,000 priests who served in U.S. dioceses and religious orders from 1950 to 2002. This does not count the victims who never came forward.

More than $1.5 billion has been paid out, with more to come. Unprecedented numbers of dioceses have declared bankruptcy.

(The Diocese of Tucson filed for bankruptcy in 2004 after lawsuits were filed over the sexual misconduct allegations. In 2005, the diocese agreed to pay $22.3 million to more than 50 victims of sexual abuse by priests. The diocese has since emerged from bankruptcy protection.)

The Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life has noted that while 31 percent of Americans were raised in the Catholic faith, today only 24 percent describe themselves as Catholics. The decline in vocations to a demoralized priesthood continues.

Bishop Geoffrey Robinson of Australia, in his book, “Confronting Power and Sex in the Catholic Church,” contends that the sexual abuse scandal is “one of the ugliest stories ever to emerge from the Catholic Church. It is hard to imagine a more total contradiction of everything Jesus Christ stood for, and it would be difficult to overestimate the pervasive harm it has done to the Church.”

His is a rare voice facing the issue publicly.

The Roman Church is steeped in symbolism. Benedict’s visit to America ought to be in purple, scarlet or black, penitential colors – not triumphal white or gold.

Robinson holds that the institution’s modus operandi is to manage the problem by not seriously re-examining underlying issues that contributed to its systemic presence and by only addressing it when forced to.

The pope’s agenda, emerging in the press, reveals no meeting with victims of clerical sexual abuse. He washed the feet of 12 priests recently on Holy Thursday in the safe confines of St. Peter’s. Would he replicate this act by washing the feet of victims in public? This action could give real meaning to the ceremony. Otherwise it remains just a passé symbol.

This could be Benedict’s “Obama moment.” After news reports on the controversial remarks of his pastor, Barack Obama went public and faced the prickly issue of racism in America, rather than spinning it away. A true leader hits head-on, rather than ducking, vexing issues.

Americans, Catholic or not, are acutely aware of the clerical sexual abuse issue. More than a leader, will the pope be a true pastor, a shepherd who will walk into the wilderness to seek the hurting members?

The pope, when he was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, was the watchdog of orthodoxy, intent on sniffing out any deviation from doctrine.

Few people are led to the gospel by doctrine; many are led to it by practice.

The officials who invited Queen Victoria to Ireland conspired to protect her from the sight of the ravages of famine lest she experience it and be moved to intervene.

Will the pope pretend that the issue of sexual abuse by clergy doesn’t exist? Have the American bishops been co-conspirators who, unlike Bishop Robinson, ignore this great challenge to the Catholic Church in America?

Will Catholics here be enablers for those who would maintain a facade of normality, keeping the victims voiceless and invisible? Is this historic moment one for pageantry or penitence?

Emmett Coyne is a Roman Catholic priest. This article was distributed by the Los Angeles Times-Washington Post News Service.


February 2008 nationwide poll of 1,007 self-identified adult Catholics by Center for Applied Research. Margin of error plus-minus 1 percent.

How important are the following factors to your sense of what it means to be Catholic:

Helping those in need 83%

Receiving Holy Communion 79%

Sacrament of confirmation 74%

A life consistent with church teaching 73%

Devotion to Mary 68%

Attending Mass 68%

Having devotion to the saints 63%

Going to confession 58%

Our Digital Archive

This blog page archives the entire digital archive of the Tucson Citizen from 1993 to 2009. It was gleaned from a database that was not intended to be displayed as a public web archive. Therefore, some of the text in some stories displays a little oddly. Also, this database did not contain any links to photos, so though the archive contains numerous captions for photos, there are no links to any of those photos.

There are more than 230,000 articles in this archive.

In TucsonCitizen.com Morgue, Part 1, we have preserved the Tucson Citizen newspaper's web archive from 2006 to 2009. To view those stories (all of which are duplicated here) go to Morgue Part 1

Search site | Terms of service